Resizing a ring down 0.25 size at Jared

Does anyone have experience resizing a ring at Jared? I got my engagement ring from them 6 months ago. It was originally a size 7 and they made it to a size 5 when they gave it to me, so I gues it already has been “resized” once, and I have had no problems with the ring itself, other than the fact that it is still slightly too big... it doesn’t fall off, but there’s a noticeable gap between my finger and the band. I thing they measured my finger incorrectly, ugh.

I want to just size it down by 0.25 of a size just to make it fit a little better, but I’ve read so many stories about people’s rings being made weaker and cracking after resizing. I’m scared because it’s in such good condition I don’t want to risk ruining that and weakening the metal, but also it’s super annoying that it doesn’t fit properly.

Anyone else resize a ring at Jared and have positive/negative experiences? And/or has anyone resized a ring by a very small amount like 0.25?