Please help me with my 1st dance song

I know I know.. this gets beat to death here but I'm so torn on what song to dance too. Why can't I mix in 4 different songs? Lol. I want a song that most people will know.. but not something that everyone plays or will expect and something that screams the love we share. I've narrowed it down to these

1. James Arthur Say you won't let go. Every word was written for us except the alcohol part. But that's pretty popular and to be expected. Although it moves my soul

2. Myron-Dystany. I know right.. you don't even know this one. It's a one hit wonder from 1998 when we 1st met and its technically our song. Afraid no one will know it and they won't be able to appreciate it ya know?
3. Raheem Devaughn-You. Omg I adore this song and it reminds me of my honey so its ridiculous but its maybe not known enough either.
4. Tamia-Still ... good one since we are still together after a zillion years but it's just ok to me

1. Reminds me of us the most
2. Reminds me of the teenage us
3. Reminds me of the bedroom us
4. Reminds me of the song that should best resp us

Help please 😊😊😊❤