Pie vs cake?

We're getting married tomorrow and we're having both! I like the idea of both! I like cake, he likes pie, why not?

I think pie is a great idea for a dessert!! Because it's a fall-themed wedding, you could have the different fall pie flavors: pumpkin, apple, rhubarb (if you're into that), pecan, even mincemeat (if you're into that). I don't know anyone who doesn't love pie. Plus, as much as I like cake, wedding cake is usually boring and not very flavorful. Pie would be much more interesting!

If you want to do pies, I say go for it!!! I think it's perfect for your fall wedding! You can have a variety of pumpkin, apple, etc. I love it when I see other couples go for nontraditional desserts, I think it's so much fun and adds a personal touch! For instance, we're doing donuts. I know that's a bit trendy at the moment, but my FH and I always said we would LOVE to have apple cider donuts instead of a cake! (we're going to have other flavors, but we want primarily cider donuts)

I'd probably do some of each. Maybe 2 flavors of pie and 1-2 flavors of cake or cupcakes for the traditionalists. It doesn't have to be all or nothing!

We did individual pies (for my "cake") and doughnuts (for H's cake), because we don't like cake. People loved it.

Having pies sounds great! As long as you have a good variety it should be fine!

The mini pies looked SO good 🤤

Yeah why not!? i think thats a great alternative!

I think pie is awesome! You could even do mini pies for the guests to eat! It is your day, do what you feel is best!!

I don't like cake much, and went to a fall wedding that had just a spread of different pies and thought it was the best thing ever. A lot of the recent weddings I have been to skip cake in favor of different dessert options (cake pops, donuts, pies, and individual dessert bars and brownies have all been popular options, and I went to one wedding with an ice cream cart with a guy hand scooping ice cream and that was my favorite of all). Almost all of those other options are also less expensive than a traditional wedding cake, which is an added bonus. Do whatever you want!