So after months and months of going back and forth, I have decided I will take my FH's last name. My dilemma is, I realllly don't want to give up my maiden name. My dad just recently passed away and has no sons to carry on the family name, and I'm the oldest child, so between this sense of honoring him (even though he was super traditional and really wanted me to take FH's name), combined with the fact that I'm pretty independent and want to keep my identity, and also that I just like my name, I am trying to figure out how I can legally keep my last name somewhere. My options are:
1) Add my maiden name as a second middle name. I don't want to replace my middle name, it would be more like FirstName MiddleName MaidenAsMiddleName FHLastName. FH seemed to like this idea the most of the options, since then I'm taking his last name and nothing else. HOWEVER, I live in NJ and have read that this is an extremely difficult process to do, as it may require you to get a court order, and that could potentially result in changing my birth certificate??? Sounds like changing for SS would be fine, it's the DMV that might cause me trouble and send me down this court process, which I would like to avoid.
2) Have two last names, so it would be FirstName MiddleName MaidenName FHLastName. NO hyphenation. This appeals to me more than hyphenating because then I don't have to introduce myself with the hyphenated name all the time, our names together is kind of a mouthful. Legally, I know I would have to sign everything with both names, but at least I can casually take my FH's name in everyday life. This process seems to be more straightforward than Option 1. However an issue with this would be that I might not be able to fit both names on documents and things in the future, so I'd have to abbreviate my maiden name anyway (similar to middle names), and I don't know if this causes issues long term.
I'd love to hear people's thoughts on this. I'm a little torn. Especially if you're in NJ and did something untraditional, please help and let me know how much of a pain in the butt changing your name was