Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Catriona
October 2023

"Married" but never had a wedding

Catriona, on May 24, 2020 at 12:17 PM

Posted in Planning 81

Okay, so this may be a bit confusing but I need some opinions (please kind ones only). I met my partner almost nine years ago. We have been together for 8 of them. We were 19 and 20 and we became really good friends. At the time we had both gotten out of rough relationships and we wanted to take it...

Okay, so this may be a bit confusing but I need some opinions (please kind ones only).


I met my partner almost nine years ago. We have been together for 8 of them.

We were 19 and 20 and we became really good friends. At the time we had both gotten out of rough relationships and we wanted to take it slow. However, there was also a very intense attraction to each other almost immediately.

Less than a year into our "friendship" I became pregnant. Which was a huge shock to both of us as I have PCOS and was told as a young teen that I would either not be able to have children or it would be EXTREMELY difficult for me to. I was also on birth control only to assist with my excruciatingly painful periods.

Neither of us had ever planned to have children, we were both of the mindset that if we ever did (and not necessarily as a couple) it would be when we were in our late 30's.

I only wanted to adopt as I have/had a phobia of foreign things being in my body.

Neither one of us believe in abortion (unless under specific circumstances) so that was totally out. Plus it was my responsibility and I meant to stand by it.

Fast forward a few years into the future and we have two beautiful children, a boy and a girl.

Now I'll get to the reason behind my post.

Back in 2014 we were really struggling with figuring out what to do with our lives and how to provide the best possible lives for our children, I had served in the Navy until I was injured so he had the idea to join.

If only to provide for us.

Here comes the issue.

Due to the Military's rules he wasn't allowed to join despite his exceptionally high ASVAB score.

Reason? Because he was unmarried and had two children. They viewed it as family abandonment.

So despite my immense reservations ( not because I didn't love him but because I had a vision ever since I was a little girl of big romantic proposal and a dream wedding) we sat down and very coldly decided to marry just so he could get in.

We decided to go to a courthouse and do it as generically and as unromantic as possible.

We didn't tell our parents, we didn't tell anyone. I barely even remember the date it occurred. We didn't dress up I wore jeans and a winter jacket and same for him. I despised doing it but he reassured me that it was only a strategic business move and nothing more and one day we would do the whole thing.


Now let's move to the present.

He never joined.

We both made the decision to go back to school.

We even considered getting a "divorce" to erase the marriage completely.


We are coming up on our ten year "dating" anniversary and I want a real wedding.

I want a proposal

A bridal shower

The whole thing because I never got to have it.

I didn't think I would care, I was never the type of woman to be bothered by that sort of thing, but I am almost thirty now and I still refer to him as my boyfriend whilst my parents and his parents AGAINST our wishes call us husband and wife.

Every time I think about the fact that I never had a wedding I feel utterly devastated. Attending others weddings literally breaks my heart.

I love weddings and I am an extremely empathetic person, I am that girl that always cries at weddings out of sheer joy for the bride and groom.

However, that has been tainted, now whilst I am thrilled for them, it is tinged with jealousy and hurt, and embarrassment.

My father is getting old, he is almost 70 will be next month and I can't stand the thought of him never walking me down the aisle or seeing me get married, (God, I'm crying now as I write this.)



I don't know what to do. Is it unseemly for me to do have the whole nine yards?

The shower, the Bachelorette party?

I want to do it but in reality I'm not a bachelorette and I don't feel like my family would respect my wishes to view it as such or if they would even participate in it.

I literally fought with my parents over them calling him my husband, and his parents are a super strict holiness pentacostal pastor and wife and wouldn't respect it either.


I could really use some advice...







81 Comments

  • C
    Dedicated 0000
    Chloe ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    This seems so callous and nit picky. It's not a quenceanera, it is a wedding. A wedding (and a sucessful marriage for that matter), is more than just signing the legal document. That marriage certificate is only for being considered married in the eyes of the law.
    A marriage ceremony (or ya know a wedding), incorporates your personality, family, community, heritage, cultural traditions, and religous beliefs. It is a public celebration of your love and commitment to each other.

    Maybe re-read OP because she wrote 13 paragraphs and only mentioned a bridal shower in two sentences, and NEVER once did she ask for presents. I have known many modern brides who didn't have presents at the bridal shower or bachelorette party. She could have a bridal shower to play games with her older generation family who would not attend a bachelorette party.
    • Reply
  • Caytlyn
    Legend November 2019
    Caytlyn ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    A bridal shower is, by definition, a gift giving event. The entire purpose is to “shower” the bride with gifts. It’s great that you have your own opinion and you’re welcome to voice that, since it’s what OP asked for, but it doesn’t change the fact that married people can’t have weddings and it’s tacky to ask for a bridal shower when you were a bride 6 years ago.
    • Reply
  • C
    Dedicated 0000
    Chloe ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Again I feel your stuck on two sentences out of 13 paragraphs... Most modern brides have already been living with their SO, and I have known many brides who didn't have presents at their shower.


    To OP - The obvious majority responding here, do not see any issue with what your wanting. You will always find someone who will judge you on a technicality. (Even though your post was clear about what you were wanting.) I hope you talk to your SO, and follow thru with a wedding and all that it includes!
    • Reply
  • Elizabeth
    Super June 2021
    Elizabeth ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I'm so sorry you're feeling this way! Personally, I would frame it as a vow renewal for your families, but plan it just like a wedding. You can have all of it and call it a vow renewal to make your families happy. Good luck!

    • Reply
  • Sasha
    Dedicated September 2021
    Sasha ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Hi Catriona,


    I’m so sorry you feel this way and for some of the very insensitive comments on here! You do what you want and plan the weeding of your dreams no questions asked. It sounds like you had a civil court wedding and should now plan a religious wedding. And yes you are welcome to plan all the pre-wedding parties as you wish. I would have a conversation with your partner and come up with a plan. And no you do not need to let anyone know that you are already civilly married, except for your religious officiant so that they know they do not need to file any paperwork with the marriage bureau. Once your partner officially proposes, make the announcement and in a simple post, let everyone know you are excited to plan your wedding and to stay tuned for details. Once you have your date and when it’s time to send out your invites, you can ask everyone to we request the pleasure of your company at our religious wedding. No lies told here, perfectly legit and everyone is happy. Your family will come around and will be there once everything is planned and start coming together.
    • Reply
  • Vicky
    VIP January 2020
    Vicky ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Feel free to have a vow renewal, wear a white dress, throw a great party to thank people for coming. Don't have a shower or bachelorette party (both of which shouldn't be thrown by you anyway; they're gifts that should be thrown by someone else); it's no longer appropriate for that.

    • Reply
  • Vicky
    VIP January 2020
    Vicky ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    Then they didn't technically have a shower. A shower is by definition a gift-giving event, where you shower the bride-to-be with gifts to help her make the transition to married life.

    • Reply
  • C
    Dedicated 0000
    Chloe ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Thank you for finding the technicality and origin of the tradition.
    • Reply
  • Karla
    Super February 2020
    Karla ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Might be a crowd thing, but the last 3 showers I went to, the bride didn’t get gifts that were for meant to help her transition to married life. Most people in my circle of friends have already been living together so there isn’t much need for household items and they also didn’t have a registry. They were gifted things like lingerie, makeup, gift cards to Nordstrom/Sephora. I gave one of my friends a Dyson hair dryer and that was because I wanted her to have a gift that was for HER (if her husband wanted gifts, his groomsmen can throw him a shower). I saw one get a YSL bag and another Chanel shoes. I things people are definitely moving away from traditions and OP can have a shower not specifically geared towards helping her transition to married life.
    • Reply
  • Sasha
    Dedicated September 2021
    Sasha ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Also, another point on your shower, you can definitely have a wedding shower and maybe be surprised that a close friend or family member may surprise you with one. People are living together before they get married nowadays and showers are meant to gather and celebrate the bride to be, which is exactly what you would en at that time. You are welcome to create a honeymoon registry, a house renovations fund or whatever you want for those who wish to contribute. There is nothing wrong with that and is to be expected when hosting a wedding. Don’t let anyone talk you out of this! After all, depending on your budget and where you live, you’ll be coughing up $200 per head to invite each guest to your wedding and absolutely should give people the opportunity to present you with a gift you will find useful. Anyone who has a problem with this do not have to be invite or accept your invitation to any of your pre-wedding parties or your wedding. Most people who share these negative opinions do not have supporting and or loving people in their circle and are projecting their lack of support/love on you. My guess is if you have people who love and support you, the will show up and show out for you more than you think!! So go for it all!


    This is coming from someone who has a civil wedding first and was planning a religious wedding this year and now postponing due to covid. All those bullshit rules that people are complaining about didn’t matter once I made the announcement about our big wedding celebration, friends, families, coworkers were begging to be on the list and to attend. Further, people were calling and messaging me where’s my registry how can they contribute, asking for information about bridal shower and bachelorette parties. Friends who weren’t even in my bridal party were begging for details on bachelorette trips and asking to join. Let these haters continue to hate on this forum and move forward and go after what you want! Especially, in this post covid environment once it’s safe, people will be so excited, thrilled and honored to celebrate you. Good luck!!!
    • Reply
  • Renee
    Super June 2020
    Renee ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    You should first have a ❤️ to ❤️, put everything on the table, totally transparent conversation with your partner about your needs in life and where you both see your relationship going. As far as the wedding,
    I am going to be completely transparent with you on a forum full of opinionated people but that’s my choice. You are already riding the horse backwards and that’s okay. So, WHATEVER YOU WANT TO DO, DO IT!
    You want to have a bridal shower, have it! You want to have a wedding, plan it! You want to have a bachelorette party, send me the details and I’ll throw it for you! Celebrate YOU, LIFE and LOVE! Don’t let these worn out traditions and the mindset of unimportant spectators eat you up inside. Screw anyone else who says you can’t and minimizes you for wanting to have an experience in your life that makes up the chapters of your book.
    I believe every single person deserves to feel self-actualization. You are allowed to do whatever it takes, within in the means of society, to feel and experience it. I’m rooting for you!

    • Reply
  • Ashshaw2022
    Dedicated May 2022
    Ashshaw2022 ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    You had your wedding, you two decided to get married and so you got married if you wanted your real wedding then you should have waited, you are wanting the proposal the bridal shower etc but your missing the idea behind them a man proposes to a woman for marriage but your already married, you want a bridal shower but you have already been a bride, I think you need to move on and use the money that you would for a wedding proposal bridal shower and spend it wisely on your kids a house or a 10 year anniversary vacation,


    if you need to have a vow renewal no parites like bachelor and bachelorette no bridal party and just renewal your vows in front of your family and then have a small get together, I am not a fan of vow renewals the only exception I see is for couples who had to get married due to this darn virus,

    • Reply
  • Christine
    Dedicated October 2020
    Christine ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Sweetheart - I'm old enough to be your mother, and have 3 children, two of which are adults and one is a teenager. I was married in a civil ceremony with a stranger as a witness. And while I had proposals back when I was younger, those never got to the weddings. My then husband always promised me a proper wedding, but kept pushing it off. I was the breadwinner and knew I didn't want to exclusively spend my hard earned money on the wedding, which I knew he was wanting to for vanity's sake, but I kept dreaming that one day, I would get what every little girl dreams of.


    I've since gotten divorced from that four years ago and am now in a relationship with someone who now values my dreams of walking down the aisle. I got my proposal (simple due to the quarantine), and we're both excited in planning our "real" wedding (he's never had one, either).

    While our stories may be different, go with what you want to do... don't let other people dictate whether it's the wrong thing to do. Absolutely, go for it! I am rooting for you. And I know you will have a beautiful wedding! Have fun.
    • Reply
  • Emily
    Expert September 2020
    Emily ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Some of y'all in this thread sound *sooooooooooo fun* and suuuuuuuuuuper understanding. I'm sure you'd be invited to this wedding for all the really warm and empathetic advice. 🙄


    OP asked for kindness. What's that saying about if you can't say something nice? .... it'll come to me.
    • Reply
  • A
    Expert September 2022
    Allie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    Thiiiiisssss!!!!!!!

    • Reply
  • Sharunda
    Just Said Yes January 2020
    Sharunda ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Hi Catriona! You absolutely deserve every part of a wedding and more. I congratulate you both for being able to jump every hurdle you came across. I admit my first time getting married was in my jeans and at the county courthouse. Fastforward two years later, my husband and I renewed our vows. We had a beautiful wedding
    • Reply
  • Sharunda
    Just Said Yes January 2020
    Sharunda ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Indeed I encourage you to have a vow renewal ceremony. Decide your theme and special details of your wedding that is important to you. Good luck!!
    • Reply
  • D
    Dedicated February 2024
    Daniel ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    The long and short of it is you have been married for some time and just cause it was not ideal at the time does not mean it was not a wedding. It has been almost 10 years and your family is correct you are married it does not matter in a church or people but you signed the papers and filed them. You can call it what ever you wish to make you feel better renew vow lost wedding experience but the fact is not everyone will be onboard or get behind you. It is something you have to figure out with him and the kids. But having remorse and feeling left out of your dream is common when you have dreams and put on hold and then have time to think about them are common. Look at all of the seniors in high school that miss out on grad and prom. And even some in collage. Most will have a remorse of not going through and may even have something when over. But in the end it Is going to boil down to you and what will make you and family happy and satisfied.
    • Reply
  • Naikesha
    Super September 2020
    Naikesha ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I say have the conversation with you HUSBAND regarding your feelings. Communication is everything.

    Once you have the conversation then you guys can call it a vow renewal , official wedding, epic party, families uniting, whatever floats your boat. As far as the bachelorette party(sry) ummm you haven't been a bachelorette for 6 years (definition of bachelorette is a young unmarried lady) but.................... Bridal shower I can see. You are still the bride in this situation even if it's a renewal and can be showered with gifts or just have a large gathering with games etc. no gifts if like most people have outgrown their homes after 10+ years. Oh course usually someone throws this for you.

    I totally understand wanting your fairy tell day and you should go for it. Especially since you guys have overcome a lot in your relationship and are still together. Please keep us updated and stay strong and safe during these trying times.Also life is short so don't get overly consumed a lavish party (although you deserve) without remembering to celebrate Life and your Loved ones while you still can. tomorrow isn't promised to any of us and you never want Stress or pettiness to be your influencer and miss the good happy days.





    • Reply
  • A
    Dedicated June 2016
    Amazing Planning ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Girl due it!!! While I do agree it was a good move to courthouse it, weither it be military rules or medical situations or just incase something happens you both are legally set. That speaking, you could totally throw a wedding, because everyone can celebrate and its not like you dont deserve it after that long! Have your dream wedding, but again I live off the phrase "carpe diem-seize the day!".
    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Learn more

Groups

WeddingWire article topics