Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Claire
Just Said Yes September 2019

If you were asked to step down as Maid of Honor, would you still attend the wedding?

Claire, on January 22, 2018 at 4:03 PM

Posted in Etiquette and Advice 26

This is long... but please bear with me, because I am in desperate need of advice! My childhood best friend is getting married in September. Two months after she got engaged, she formally asked me to be her Maid of Honor. Last week (six months later), she called me and said that she'd decided the...

This is long... but please bear with me, because I am in desperate need of advice!

My childhood best friend is getting married in September. Two months after she got engaged, she formally asked me to be her Maid of Honor. Last week (six months later), she called me and said that she'd decided the wedding party had gotten too large and she was only going to have her fiancé's sisters as bridesmaids. I was completely and utterly shocked by this announcement, especially because the sisters have been kind of disrespectful and pushy with her throughout this process. It was a short phone conversation, and when I tried to call her back later that night, she did not answer.

Two days after that, she sent me an email in which she wrote that actually, she was concerned about my wedding date conflicting with hers (side note: I am not even engaged yet. She knows I want to get married on my grandparents' anniversary, which is a week before her date in September 2018. Because of that potential conflict, but mostly for financial reasons, my boyfriend and I decided last fall to get married in 2019. There was never even any concrete discussion around me getting married in 2018). She said it would be "best for our friendship" for my boyfriend and I to also be able to get married sooner than 2019, so she wanted us to have the freedom to do that. I would still be an "honored guest" at her wedding.

Finally, I got a second emailing citing a THIRD reason for the decision. This one feels the most honest - it seems that because I have a more dominant personality than her, she feels uncomfortable sharing her wedding ideas with me because they may differ from my own. She wrote that she is "struggling with the boundary between distinguishing what you want for your wedding and what I want for mine", and says she is now preemptively choosing her opinions before she shares them with me based on how she thinks I will react.

Full disclosure - I am a direct person. I talk openly and honestly and when I'm asked for an opinion, I do give it. But I've been that way my entire life, and we've been friends since the age of 12. We've never had a dramatic friendship or had any major fights, we're both pretty tolerant people and are content to do our own thing. She also lives across the county now, so I feel like in some ways there's not even enough overlap in our lives to have many disagreements. I don't think this is the case, but it makes me wonder if she has always felt uncomfortable or unable to disagree with me? If that's really the nature of our friendship and I've actually been steamrolling her for our entire lives, I don't understand why she would even want to be friends with me, let alone call me her "best friend" and talk to me daily about her wedding.

I know wedding planning is stressful and often doesn't bring out the best in people. I've watched her withhold her opinions from other people because she wants to avoid confrontation. It's an active pattern right now, but I truly had no idea that she felt that way about me.

So what do I do now? Can our friendship recover from this? I suppose it's positive that she still wants to include me and make me feel "special", but I can't believe that we're now at a point where she doesn't even want me in her bridal party. I don't know why she would sit on these feelings until she decided that the best solution would be to remove me from the ceremony entirely. I can't imagine going to the wedding now and having it be an enjoyable experience. I don't really want to end our friendship over this, but I don't know how to get past it.

26 Comments

  • MAMW
    VIP August 2013
    MAMW ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I'd be on the fence about going, leaning towards probably going, until I was sent two different emails explaining why I wasn't in the bridal party anymore. This incident would irreparably change the way that I view my friend, and at the very least I would be taking an extended break from them. I certainly wouldn't make any effort with her moving forward for a very long time.

    And also, the reasons she gave in the emails are so ridiculous I would have a hard time taking her seriously. So you could have the "freedom" to get married when you want? Because she's "afraid" to tell you about her wedding? Being afraid of confrontation is one thing, but I can't find a valid thing that she had to "confront" you with, making this a whole load of selfish bs to me.

    I'm sorry you're probably going to lose a friend over this.

    • Reply
  • AbeFroman
    Devoted October 2018
    AbeFroman ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I'm sorry this is happening to you. If you want to keep the friendship, try having a conversation with her about this and plan to attend the wedding. Otherwise, just don't go. I'm not sure how much a conversation will help any way since it sounds like she's afraid of confrontation.

    • Reply
  • Red Queen
    VIP May 2018
    Red Queen ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I would have an open and honest discussion with her and see if things can be resolved in a way that leaves you both feeling positive about the friendship.

    Life isn't black and white, and I don't think you should make a decision about anything before you really talk to her. And by talk, I also mean listen. Ask lots of questions. Use I statements and not You statements.

    • Reply
  • Mrs. Danihel
    Expert May 2018
    Mrs. Danihel ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Wow, if it were me, I would not be attending. Too much drama and bs for my taste.
    • Reply
  • The Nuptials
    VIP July 2018
    The Nuptials ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Were you the only one thrown out? Or were there other bridesmaids in addition to the sisters? Try to Skype her and get to the bottom of it. But to me she is putting off the vibe that she isn't interested in maintaining the friendship.

    Would there be any reason for her to feel threatened by your wedding? Would it be more lavish or something? Assuming she really though you guys were getting married in the same month. Thats my best guess..

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Explore how we embrace diversity

Groups

WeddingWire article topics