Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Claire
Just Said Yes September 2019

If you were asked to step down as Maid of Honor, would you still attend the wedding?

Claire, on January 22, 2018 at 4:03 PM Posted in Etiquette and Advice 0 26

This is long... but please bear with me, because I am in desperate need of advice!

My childhood best friend is getting married in September. Two months after she got engaged, she formally asked me to be her Maid of Honor. Last week (six months later), she called me and said that she'd decided the wedding party had gotten too large and she was only going to have her fiancé's sisters as bridesmaids. I was completely and utterly shocked by this announcement, especially because the sisters have been kind of disrespectful and pushy with her throughout this process. It was a short phone conversation, and when I tried to call her back later that night, she did not answer.

Two days after that, she sent me an email in which she wrote that actually, she was concerned about my wedding date conflicting with hers (side note: I am not even engaged yet. She knows I want to get married on my grandparents' anniversary, which is a week before her date in September 2018. Because of that potential conflict, but mostly for financial reasons, my boyfriend and I decided last fall to get married in 2019. There was never even any concrete discussion around me getting married in 2018). She said it would be "best for our friendship" for my boyfriend and I to also be able to get married sooner than 2019, so she wanted us to have the freedom to do that. I would still be an "honored guest" at her wedding.

Finally, I got a second emailing citing a THIRD reason for the decision. This one feels the most honest - it seems that because I have a more dominant personality than her, she feels uncomfortable sharing her wedding ideas with me because they may differ from my own. She wrote that she is "struggling with the boundary between distinguishing what you want for your wedding and what I want for mine", and says she is now preemptively choosing her opinions before she shares them with me based on how she thinks I will react.

Full disclosure - I am a direct person. I talk openly and honestly and when I'm asked for an opinion, I do give it. But I've been that way my entire life, and we've been friends since the age of 12. We've never had a dramatic friendship or had any major fights, we're both pretty tolerant people and are content to do our own thing. She also lives across the county now, so I feel like in some ways there's not even enough overlap in our lives to have many disagreements. I don't think this is the case, but it makes me wonder if she has always felt uncomfortable or unable to disagree with me? If that's really the nature of our friendship and I've actually been steamrolling her for our entire lives, I don't understand why she would even want to be friends with me, let alone call me her "best friend" and talk to me daily about her wedding.

I know wedding planning is stressful and often doesn't bring out the best in people. I've watched her withhold her opinions from other people because she wants to avoid confrontation. It's an active pattern right now, but I truly had no idea that she felt that way about me.

So what do I do now? Can our friendship recover from this? I suppose it's positive that she still wants to include me and make me feel "special", but I can't believe that we're now at a point where she doesn't even want me in her bridal party. I don't know why she would sit on these feelings until she decided that the best solution would be to remove me from the ceremony entirely. I can't imagine going to the wedding now and having it be an enjoyable experience. I don't really want to end our friendship over this, but I don't know how to get past it.

26 Comments

Latest activity by The Nuptials, on January 23, 2018 at 12:05 AM
  • Future Louie
    Super August 2019
    Future Louie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Wow. Personally, I'd probably go only if it's not a huge travel commitment and still try to enjoy myself with my FH. But otherwise, I'm not sure if I would feel comfortable attending after being 'kicked'. And while you claim her third reason is the most honest, I still feel she should've talked to you about any directness towards her ideas you may have had. Unless you were shooting down all of her ideas out of being blunt instead of constructive, I would be taken aback as well and feeling very confused and hurt.

    My advice to you, is if you can't see yourself having fun and enjoying yourself as a guest, I wouldn't go unless you believe you'll kick yourself later in life because you didn't go. Just send a gift if you're interested in keeping the friendship.

    • Reply
  • O
    Master October 2017
    O ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I wouldn't go. To me being asked to step down, and then given reasons for it is too much. Makes me wonder had she been honest about anything because she's afraid of confrontation?
    • Reply
  • ACD
    Expert October 2018
    ACD ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Yikes. I think this is more of a question for you- do you want the friendship to recover?

    If you want the relationship to continue, you go.

    If you don't want it to continue, don't attend. Good luck!

    • Reply
  • bluevelvet
    Devoted October 2017
    bluevelvet ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    I would attend either. Just....no. I am pretty easygoing but things like this would get to me, and I would skip it. Too much drama.

    • Reply
  • Sarah
    Master June 2016
    Sarah ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I honestly wouldn’t go and I wouldn’t continue being friends with someone who did this either.
    • Reply
  • Brianna
    VIP May 2018
    Brianna ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I probably wouldn't go, which would unfortunately end the friendship most likely. The fact that she gave you 3 different reasons for kicking you out on 3 separate occasions seems like a bit much to me. If you are already saying that you can't imagine going and having fun, I wouldn't go.

    • Reply
  • B
    Dedicated October 2018
    Blair ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    1. I am so sorry that this happened to you.
    2. Since you usually have no problem discussing things with her, ask her what's up. Face to face, not through emails. Too much gets misconstrued that way.
    3. Someone might be bullying her into doing that. (Only saying that since you said his sisters have been pushy.)
    4. As for the friendship, that's up to you and how you feel about it. Only you can decide what is going to happen with your friendship.
    5. Feel free to talk to me if you just want to vent. Or call me if you want to cry. (I know I would.) You can look me up on facebook: Blair Arrighi.
    • Reply
  • EngineerInLove
    VIP September 2018
    EngineerInLove ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Up until her last contact with you o was ready to write her off as a completely terrible friend and you should not attend as a guest. HOWEVER..... I think you need to take a hard look at what she's saying about you and decide what you want to do from there. I get being direct, I like to think I am but there are times I just roll my eyes and move along rather than arguing every differing opinion. Would you say the same, or do you debate everything or find yourself saying what you like and think would be better?
    I don't think you can not have a single disagreement with your friends from the time you are 12, it probably means one of you is holding back or you are only superficial friends. This doesn't mean your friendship has to be dramatic or prone to fights, just that you both feel safe voicing your differing opinions. It is hard to tell whether you really do steamroll her, or she's so conflict-adverse that she avoids saying anything you would disagree with.
    • Reply
  • Mrs. Fall Bride
    Master October 2016
    Mrs. Fall Bride ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Can you try to talk to her about it on the phone or in person, and not via email, before making any decisions? Was she implying that she thinks you're resentful of her for not having your own wedding until 2019?

    • Reply
  • An
    Super September 2019
    An ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I would definitely have a heart to heart in person (or by phone if face to face is not possible). You guys have been friends for a really long time and it would be sad for that to end over this. I would ask her why she felt that she had to lie to you about her reasons and try to see if it was about wedding planning (something that will be over soon) or something deeper. You have a while to think and discuss this so I wouldn't make any rash decisions. Good Luck, OP!

    • Reply
  • Kaylyn
    Super May 2019
    Kaylyn ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I probably would not attend if I were you. The fact that she felt that emailing you to talk about this is kinda lame. Her talking about your wedding date and “what’s best for your friendship”, not to mention not feeling comfortable sharing ideas with you, doesn’t sound like a very healthy and supportive friendship. Maybe it’s the wedding planning stress, but it seems like maybe you don’t need this kind of friend in your life
    • Reply
  • K
    Devoted September 2018
    kNrYwC ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I'd wait a week or so until the initial shock/pain/whatever eases away from her kicking you out of her bridal party .. and then have a conversation with her about the status of the friendship.
    Regardless of how shitty it is, if you're both committed to remaining friends, missing your best friends wedding is going to be a hard pill to swallow over the years, decades to come.
    If you don't go to the wedding, the friendship is over. I don't think it has to be over because she kicked you out of the bridal party.
    Good luck - sorry you're dealing with this.
    • Reply
  • GoodMOB
    April 2018
    GoodMOB ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Personally, having someone do this to me would be friendship-ending, and I would not be attending her wedding.

    If you are a stronger person, feel the friendship is worth saving, then go to the wedding.

    I have to say that this is one of the most rude things I have read about concerning weddings. Your bride friend is in the wrong here.


    • Reply
  • AugustBride
    Super August 2018
    AugustBride ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    This is a tough one. But honestly it seems like she's being a little selfish. I personally wouldn't go until there was some sort of an apology or conversation.

    • Reply
  • A
    Just Said Yes August 2018
    Angela ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    My question is why would she email you instead of just talking to you on the phone or meeting up in person to have a simple conversation. Wow im at a stand still with this one but I would still try to be at the wedding no matter what and always let her know you would always be there for her no matter what and let her if she needs help with anything she can always turn to u even though you are no longer part of the wedding. See if you can still mend the friendship there might be more to the story and she is prob hearing so much talk from other people. Signals do get crossed when theres a big wedding party involved. Maybe a nice conversation face to face or a phone one would do the trick you dont wanna end the friendship on a bad note or end up going to wedding with questions and feerl akward. Sry long post but keep us posted hope all goes well for you and your friends and congrats on your future nuptials....
    • Reply
  • BlueHenBride
    Master March 2017
    BlueHenBride ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I would talk with her in person about your friendship and where all of this is coming from before making any decisions about whether you want the friendship to continue and whether you still want to attend her wedding.

    For what it's worth, I would be very hurt if my best friend told me she wanted me out of her BP. That would make me reconsider whether this was a wedding I wanted to attend or a friendship I wanted to keep near and dear. I would be very confused by all of her reasons and not understand why this was all happening. I would absolutely need a face-to-face talk, not emails, to try to understand what was going on.
    • Reply
  • FutureMrsW
    VIP March 2018
    FutureMrsW ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Since you guys have been friends for such a long time and this is coming as such a shock, I would try to arrange a face-to-face or at least over the phone chat with her about what's truly bothering her. If you truly DO steamroll over her, or constantly shoot down her ideas in favor of your own, then I could see how she'd come to this. Is she a confrontational person? If not (and this coming out of the blue/over email seems to confirm she isn't), then maybe she didn't know how to tell you? I'd give it a few days and reach out to her and try to talk it out. If you guys have never had issues before and have been friends for this long, then I'd think it would be devastating to end your friendship over this.

    If she stonewalls you and refuses to talk, then you'll have to decide for yourself if you'll regret missing it. If that's the case, though, then I personally probably wouldn't want to try to maintain the friendship. Too much petty drama. Hopefully she'll be adult enough to have an honest conversation with you.

    • Reply
  • Denise
    Expert June 2018
    Denise ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Wow!!! I am having issues with one of my bridesmaids. She is my FHs brothers girlfriend. We were friends, but I did feel a little obligated to have her in my BP. She's been a sucky BM. She's canceled on almost all wedding related events. But even STILL, I won't kick her out of my BP. Your "friend" sounds like a huge B!!! I'm so sorry. If it were me, I would NOT go. Hell no. Who does that....
    • Reply
  • Jessica
    Devoted May 2018
    Jessica ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    There is a reason everyone here says to never kick anyone out of the bridal party unless you're willing to end the friendship, and this is why. I would be incredibly hurt by this, and I probably wouldn't go. Others have made valid points, though, and I can *kinda* see where this girl is coming from. It is much easier for me to write down my feelings than to have a face to face conversation, especially with someone who is a more dominant personality. If you'd like to talk to her, do it gently and without accusations, and see if she opens up to you. If she doesn't, then it sadly seems as if you were never great friends in the first place and it may be time to move on.
    • Reply
  • Newnoakua
    Expert June 2018
    Newnoakua ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I wouldn't go if it was me. This seems like too many excuses rather than just having an honest conversation with someone. Too much drama and BS for my taste.

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Explore how we embrace diversity

Groups

WeddingWire article topics