Oh my gosh, I see why you are having a hard time deciding! I usually have a clear preference on dresses, but both of yours look beautiful on you! I love the bodice of the first dress, but the train of the second dress is a showstopper! If I were in your position, I would keep them both in mind and continue shopping. There is probably a dress out there that you will love ALL aspects of!!
Thank you all! I instantly loved the second one (the 1st one I tried on). The only downside is that it is $1800 and the other is on sale for $699. The $1800 would put me over my limit with alterations buuuuuut it might just be worth it!