Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

F
Just Said Yes October 2019

How to handle a future sibling-in-law getting married less than two months before you?

Francine, on April 4, 2018 at 2:21 PM

Posted in Etiquette and Advice 55

So, I'm new here and I apologize for the long post ahead but appreciate any help/advice you could give! I am recently engaged and I cannot wait to marry the love of my life. It took a long time for us to find the perfect venue that had our date available. We are getting married on October 5th of...

So, I'm new here and I apologize for the long post ahead but appreciate any help/advice you could give! I am recently engaged and I cannot wait to marry the love of my life. It took a long time for us to find the perfect venue that had our date available. We are getting married on October 5th of 2019 and we knew we had to have that date since it happens to be our dating anniversary. We thought it was perfect that it falls on a Saturday in 2019. Both of our families knew that was our ideal date and when we put our deposit down, I was over the moon. Come to find out, the day we put our deposit down was the same day his sister got engaged. Her and her FH have been dating for a while now but are still relatively young, only two years out of college. We knew they'd be getting engaged but had no idea that it was going to happen at the beginning of this year. My future SIL is extremely kind but can be very selfish since she is the youngest of four and the only daughter in the family. Here’s where the problems begin.

Shortly after SIL gets engaged, my FH and I went to dinner at our in-laws. My mother-in-law went on to talk about how her daughter was in a really hard place because she doesn't want to upset us if she gets married first and then she proceeded to ask us to change our wedding date. She knew how stressful the process was for us to find a perfect venue and she knew the significance behind our date... Even if there was no significance, that's not something you ask your son and future daughter-in-law to do. Obviously, I was very hurt by that but my FH handled it well. The conversation keeps going on about certain things we are comfortable with and addressing any of our concerns. My FH and I, his parents, and my future sister-in-law established that August and September were off limits for the two of them. This would give some relief to the family members that are in both or attending both weddings. I was not the most thrilled with that decision, I would have liked there to be more than just two months time but understand that I don't own the calendar and I cannot expect them to put their lives on hold because of our upcoming wedding. Future SIL is also a school teacher so I can understand why she want her wedding to happen when she does not have school.

On Easter Sunday, we went to my family for lunch and his family for dessert. We overhead his sister talking to his aunt and uncle (who they are not that close to) about a certain venue and how much she loved it. At first, I was excited that she appears to have found her perfect place but my fiance was not thrilled at all. She is in our wedding and knew of all of our details as soon as they came to be and we somewhat expected the same. She left to go to her FH’s side of the family and we spent some time talking to my FH’s parents to figure things out since she never clued us in on anything. Turns out, she wanted to get married in June because that would give a good chunk of time between our dates but was having trouble finding a venue that had any Saturday availability in that month. She falls in love with this one venue and although she hasn’t booked a date yet, she’s considering Saturday, August 10th or 17th even though the venue has all Saturdays available in July. We were dumbfounded and we didn’t even know how to process this information. When we got home, we started discussing the entire situation and identified what bothered us and what was information we wanted to find out.

Here are our major concerns that we do need to address with my in-laws but are somewhat struggling with exactly how we want to do that. First, we were under the impression that August and September were off the table. Maybe that was a misunderstanding but we don’t think it was and we would like to know why this has suddenly changed. Regarding school vacation periods, there are other times when school is not in session (We live in the northeast where kids get a week in February and April, there’s Thanksgiving break and even winter break). Why not pick another time? Without any reasoning from her or her fiance, it appears to the two of us that they simply want to beat us to it. I’m afraid that this entire process, which is supposed to be a wonderful time in my FH and I’s relationship, will be focused on her wedding and then everything regarding ours will be crammed into the less than two months in between. I’m not one for all of the attention on me but I’ve been looking forward to this process for a very long time now and I know neither my fiance or I want to be considered an afterthought. I also don’t want this to become a competition but his family is very competitive. I can see his sister wanting or doing certain things just to “one up” us.

I do have to say the biggest problem we have is that we found out about this through the grapevine essentially and there was very little consideration for us. My best friend got engaged about a month after I did and when I texted her our date, she was excited for us. All of a sudden, she is strongly considering November 2019 and asked me if I was okay with that because she did not want to “crowd” my wedding date or offend me in any way. This did not bother me one bit, I was even happier for her after she asked me because I thought it was extremely considerate. When I told my FH about this, the look on his face absolutely killed me because his sister did not do the same. They were very close growing up and still somewhat are.

At this point, I’m no longer mad about the situation on my own behalf but rather the disregard of my fiance’s feelings by his own family. All of this to say, does anyone have any experience with this type of situation? I’m open to any advice or suggestions.

*If any of this appears to be confusing please let me know. I understand this is a long post and does have a lot of information packed in. I easily could have left important information.

55 Comments

  • Morgan
    Savvy March 2019
    Morgan ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    My FH's brother and his fiance are getting married a few months before us and we were all just happy for one another. It's a celebration and it's your choice to be happy for your family or to let drama insert itself into the picture.

    • Reply
  • Susan
    Dedicated October 2018
    Susan ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I completely get this! Granted I had a 2 year long engagement, but one of my BM's got engaged last October. My wedding date has been set for October 2018 for almost a year and a half now. She gets engaged and decides we're going to get married in May 2018 , in Newport Rhode Island, on Memorial day weekend! (talk about expensive) At first I was super happy for her. I didn't even think of my wedding since I was engaged for 2 years. But she does have a brother who is getting married in September 2018. This has caused a little ruffle in everyone's feathers. My FH thinks its completely rude that they didn't even consider waiting until after ours OR her siblings. I agree that its a little rude and sometimes super stressful since I'm one of her BM's. But we just gotta stick it out, do only what we can and remember that you too have a wedding coming up!!

    • Reply
  • S
    Expert July 2017
    SaraBear ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I’m very confused why this is a big deal.

    You each get a day. It works for her schedule. It has zero effect on your wedding day. My husband’s friends set their date for less than a month before ours and we had tons of mutual friends, it wasn’t a big deal. I would be really put off if someone told me two months were off limits for my wedding because theirs fell in a third month after that. I would never ask anyone if it was okay with them if I could have my wedding the month after them so I don’t crowd them. So unnecessary. It’s one day.

    I get wanting to be closer to her and do wedding things with her but honestly, if you’re so worried about her being competitive and stealing all your wedding ideas to the point where you literally don’t want to do anything wedding related with her, you probably aren’t going to be that close anyways. Even if she had her wedding six months after yours, if she’s really that competitive and horrible, she’d probably tell you not to do some of your original ideas (colors, catering, decor, venue, etc) at your wedding and you’d walk into hers and it would have all your original ideas that you changed.

    • Reply
  • P
    Dedicated July 2019
    Pearl ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I 100% understand where you're coming from and feel like some people don't understand until they're in the same situation. One thing is certain though, everyone handles things differently. I'm currently in a similar situation where my FH and I got engaged first, put our deposit down and then found out that the future SIL got engaged that same day we put the deposit down. We were thrilled for her, we know how much she was looking forward to it but everyone in FH's family was caught off guard by this proposal. We set our date for July 20, 2019 after a long search. I was very close to my future SIL and considered her more to be a sister than a future sister. We did so much together and I was looking forward to the planning process with her. FH's parents offered to pay for about half of our wedding expenses a full month prior to learning about her engagement. Now, they are no longer offering to pay for any of our wedding unless we move our already secured date to accommodate her wedding, which she wants to have either in June or August.

    Perhaps their parents cannot afford to pay for both weddings in such a small time frame but I wish she had a talk with FH and I before running to her parents. Our interactions together have completely changed. We used to grab coffee and walk our dogs together at least twice a week. Once FH's parents broke the news, this all stopped. Would I have been the happiest if she set her date in June or August? Of course not, but I am so excited for her that I wouldn't even care. I posted a thread asking if anyone had advice and unfortunately, no one has responded and its probably because this is suck a sticky situation. Our relationship with both his sister and his parents is changed forever and I think less of them because of it. We have already put deposits down and are unable to get any of that money back. I wish none of this was happening in my life and I can only urge you not to do something that could cause major family drama. By marrying your FH you will be gaining a whole new family and that is a beautiful thing. You cannot expect to become best friends with your FSIL overnight and it definitely won't happen if you're holding a grudge against her. Worry about only things you can control and don't allow her to see that its bothering you or your FH because that might make her feel like she has complete control over the situation. There will be times throughout this journey that you are annoyed by her plans or actions. Vent to your FH or to a third party about it but never let her know how affected you are.

    Best of luck along your journey. May you find peace with the situation and have the best day marrying the man of your dreams!

    • Reply
  • J
    Savvy July 2018
    Jennifer ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Wow. I hope you get it straightened out. Best of luck!

    • Reply
  • C
    Devoted September 2020
    Caitlin ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Oh I really hope you didn’t change your wedding date for people like that
    • Reply
  • Cassidy
    VIP October 2017
    Cassidy ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    You are absolutely overreacting. She’s a teacher- she wants to get married in the summer when it works with her schedule. Like you want your wedding to work with YOUR schedule. There is no reason she should pick a cold month that’s busy and expensive to travel to because it is not convenient FOR YOU. 1.5 months before is absolutey enough time. Also- they can get married before you. It’s not a contest. If they want to, that’s their perogative. I had a lot of family members not make it to my wedding.

    nd you I think didn’t NEED to choose October 5 as your date, because your dating anniversary doesn’t matter when you have your wedding anniversary. I mean it’s all well and good that it works out that way, but it’s not like you had to have that date or you couldn’t get married. Also, it sounds awfully selfish to me that you think that you somehow deserve “the wedding process.” I didn’t have the whole “wedding process” like my sister did and she’s still not married yet. She was a little mad that I was getting married before her, but I didn’t have the 2 year engagement she did. I didn’t have the same proposal she did, I didn’t have the same dress shopping experience, venue experience, dc or photographer experience.

    You each get one day. You don’t get to be hurt for her picking a date that works for her.
    • Reply
  • dancingwiththekumars
    Expert May 2018
    dancingwiththekumars ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    My future BIL is getting married 3 months after us. We set our date first, they've been together for years and have a kid, but decided to also get married this year. It's been okay so far with the simultaneous wedding planning, his fiancee & I had an argument last year (related to fam/wedding) and aren't close. We don't discuss much about our planning. But my FH's fam hasn't really helped us much at all either. They have too much going on with both weddings, and doing full renovations on their house. You don't have much choice here except to just focus on your own wedding. Keep the date you have.

    • Reply
  • Vicky
    VIP January 2020
    Vicky ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    "You have to share this precious moment that is supposed to be so special between you and your fiancé."

    That doesn't even make sense. If you don't want to share "this precious moment" with anyone other than your fiance, elope. You don't get to control what anybody does just because you're getting married, and it doesn't matter who gets engaged first. Like everyone else in this thread said, you get one day. You don't get to control the days, weeks, and months around that day.

    • Reply
  • A
    Super September 2019
    Anna ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    You didn’t leave anything out. You’re over reacting. A month and a half between dates is more than generous. There shouldn’t be off limit months. Let it go
    • Reply
  • S
    Beginner September 2025
    Sarah ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I don't really agree with everyone else here... im dealing with the same right now... cool everyone gets thier day... but its a huge financial burden, hugely stressful, some guests will be able to attend one n not the other, puts people in awkward positions.. perfect example.. Yesterday sitting with my mom n SIL brother, FH and Dad.. we started talking about my wedding, SIL started talking bout hers my Mom in the middle... looking side to side.. just overwhelmed at all the ideas hitting her... and this is just the beginning!!! I've been planning since February of this year for Sept of next year... we just got hit with hers last weekend.. Why?? N in all this my parents 50th wedding anniversary is in August.. I find it ridiculous!!
    • Reply
  • LM
    Super December 2022
    LM ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    This post is 5+ years old, but . . . it's okay to have your feelings. It's also understandable for FSIL to be excited being newly engaged. But, before you start to panic about guest travel and money, FSIL's date is still TBD until they book an available venue. In the future, speak about wedding planning with your Mom privately so there's no weird rivalry or competition brewing. I hope your families work it all out and everyone feels celebrated.

    • Reply
  • S
    Beginner September 2025
    Sarah ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Yes we are working on it.... I frankly have little hope... she's horrible!!! Not in the slightest interested in everyone being happy... she's first n foremost... I plan on keeping My distance n focusing on my brother.. period
    • Reply
  • Michael
    Master October 2023
    Michael ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    Did your FH notice any related sibling rivalry beforehand? I think most of the time that the guest lists for one wedding is pretty different from the sibling's wedding. Also, is your FH bothered by this? If not, just try avoiding discussing wedding plans around that FSIL.

    • Reply
  • S
    Beginner September 2025
    Sarah ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Yeah.. husband knows.. we've been together for 17 years.. just finally getting married. I'm only doing this once!! Im 46 never been married.. a couple purposals..but like run away bride i find a way out.. thankfully long before 1000 s are spent... After this.. ill never remarry!! I'm still trying to be nice... Yes he's very bothered.. but we are all just rolling with the punches.. Guest list... well I heard some yesterday while cooking dinner for the whole family... many matching names.. n many miles for those names to travel. We will see.. I have just reserved myself to... whatever will be will be!! If nobody comes.. nobody comes.. we will have tons of food n booze left over I guess 😃😃
    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×


WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Learn more

Rockstars

  • D
    Getting married in 07/03/2025

Groups

WeddingWire article topics