Honeymoon in Punta Cana or St. Lucia???

I’ve been to both and I liked both preferred St. Lucia! For luxury I would say St. Lucia hands down, for adventure/cost

Whoops hit reply too early! I’ve been to both and liked both but preferred St. Lucia by far. In my opinion it is way more interesting and better if you’re looking for luxury. I never left the resort in Punta Cana. St. Lucia has black sand beaches and mountains rather than the turquoise waters and flat white sand beaches.

I haven't been to Punta Cana but I loved St. Lucia!!

It feels super tropical and remote, and you can laze on the beach all day or be more active and hike the pitons, visit the mud springs, go zip-lining, ride ATVs, etc.!

Here are some guides you can check out with recommended activities for each destination:

St. Lucia Honeymoon Guide

Dominican Republic Honeymoon Guide