Help! Which wedding band looks better??

#1, on green nails!

I'm loving the one on the left

I was leaning toward red nails lol I always pick something on this site then read the comments to find out I'm the only one haha!

I vote for the left one

I originally liked the one on the right too! But, after reading the comments I took a long look at both, and I think what is appealing to people is that the lines are straighter in the left option. It's more clean cut, no curves, so they 'match' in that way.

I think if it was me, I would maybe look for something that has the baguettes if you love them, but also includes some tiny pave/round stones to pull in an element from the e-ring. Like these:

Your engagement ring is so pretty! For the band I like the one on the left with your e ring.

I like the combination in the first photo better. It looks more harmonious