Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Rissachu
Dedicated August 2019

First wedding planning disagreement over guest list

Rissachu, on December 29, 2017 at 9:02 PM Posted in Etiquette and Advice 0 26

My FH and I have had our first wedding planning disagreement and it is over the guest list. I don't want children at the wedding, because toddlers have a tendency to just start crying and throwing a fit at any moment because they do not have the social skills yet necessary to realize how they should conduct themselves in certain situations. This presents a problem because at the time of our wedding, FSIL will have a two and a half year old toddler, and my own sister will have a one and a half year old, and two other children under teenager years. I mainly do not want my sister's children there because she has a tendency to not make them mind very much, however my FH thinks we can't not allowed children because of FSIL. I know FSIL would make her child mind, but there's still that nagging fear that a child will start screaming in the middle of the ceremony or some other important moment. FH says I am thinking too much into this and that we don't need to worry about screaming children because it'll "be a non-issue."

Am I worrying about this too much? Would I be taboo to simply have my sister's invitation be just for her and one guest and leave it at that? She lives out of state anyway and I don't think she would travel with all of her children (she possibly might not even come at all for non-children related issues, I am sure).

I know my sister has a tendency to be drama-prone and she over-reacts. I am afraid that if I make her invitation +1 only and she comes and sees FSIL's child that she'd cause an issue.

We aren't going to have a wedding party, but do you think I could get out of this my making FSIL's daughter a flower girl of some sort? At two and a half years old though, I have my doubts that she'd be able to properly navigate her flower girl duties without assistance of an older person.

My FH and I just do not agree. He said I could make it adults only if I want to but he says that he thinks his FSIL might not come then because they wouldn't want to find a babysitter. I am a total loss of what to do.

26 Comments

Latest activity by Maggie, on December 31, 2017 at 10:29 PM
  • Susan
    VIP December 2017
    Susan ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Regardless of anyone else, you are allowed to have a child free wedding if you wish, but you and FH need to be in agreement on this.
    It is fine to invite kids in circles, ie wedding party only, nieces/nephews only, etc. But I wouldn't include his sister's child and not your sister's, because that is likely to cause a lot of drama. Honestly, there were tons of kids at our wedding and we didn't have issues, so you may be over thinking it a little. But this is still your decision and it is fine to say adults only (18 and up).
    • Reply
  • E.V.
    VIP November 2017
    E.V. ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I had one small child at my wedding and regretted it. He is the only small child in my family, my 3 year old nephew, and I knew it would be a big deal to my family if I left him out. I decided to avoid the drama and make him my ring bearer. He did fine as my ring bearer but his parents didn’t make him behave during cocktail hour. When we came back from taking our photos he had moved most of our decorations around. During dinner he kept getting into things he shouldn’t, as well, and I felt like a lot of focus was on him. Was it a HUGE deal? No, not really, and he was SUPER cute, but having small children- even one- does present possible issues. Especially if the parents don’t have much control.
    • Reply
  • BohoRN2017
    Expert November 2017
    BohoRN2017 ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    If you allow your FSIL to bring her kids, you really should allow the same for your own sister. Otherwise there will be lots of drama. I totally understand because we have people in our family who do not make their kids behave. I attended a reception where my cousin's children ran around the dance floor screaming during the speeches...


    I was bullied into inviting my 1 year old nephew. I did make my SIL bring her mother to watch him. The maternal grandmother actual has some dang sense (unlike my brother, SIL, and my own mother). My mother claimed he is such a "quiet" child. They would give him a bottle and he would just go right to sleep. Well that didn't happen at all. As soon as the organ started playing he perked right up and started babbling very loudly. Luckily his grandmother took him out right away. My mother and I got into a huge argument at the rehearsal because I had insisted that my nephew and his grandmother sit in the back near the door. I'm glad I stood my ground, it made it much easier for her to leave with him.

    • Reply
  • Nikki
    Devoted October 2018
    Nikki ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Either all kids or no kids. It's fine to do it in circles but to purposely only exclude your sisters children isn't okay. We're allowing children who are nieces and nephews but aren't inviting the children of some guests we aren't extremely close with only due to number issues.
    • Reply
  • L
    Expert April 2018
    lindabelcher ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Yup. This is the way. You aren't being ridiculous but neither is he. One of you will have to compromise, OP.
    • Reply
  • O
    Master October 2017
    O ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Excluding some family members kids and not others will become an issue. We didn't invite non family children to our wedding because of how our friend disciplines. We didn't want to subject other guests and family to her behavior.
    • Reply
  • Rissachu
    Dedicated August 2019
    Rissachu ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    See, I don't understand either. It seems to me that a lot of people feel very unfairly inconvenienced when asked not to bring their children.

    • Reply
  • Sara P.
    VIP October 2018
    Sara P. ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I think it's rude to invite your sil's kids but not your sister's kids. Agree with PP about inviting circles. I preferred a childless wedding except nieces and nephews but we compromised on inviting children of family but not children of friends.
    • Reply
  • J
    Expert May 2018
    J ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    It’s not really fair for him to tell you it’s a “non-issue” because children certainly can cause problems at a wedding, especially since it sounds like your sister’s children might not be well behaved. If this is really important to him then maybe you should invite the kids, but from the way you’ve described it I’m not sure he’s really thought this all the way through. So I think you should stand your ground when you talk to him again and hopefully he will try to see your side rather than just dismiss your concerns like that.
    • Reply
  • J
    Expert May 2018
    J ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I just typed in “kids ruining weddings” into Youtube and there are several results, maybe show him some of those videos, lol!! 😆
    • Reply
  • Alforev
    VIP August 2018
    Alforev ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    You need to figure this out with your FH and come to an agreement. It’s either you allow big to bring kids or neither. My nephew will be 3 at the time of my wedding and I look forward to having my brother and sister in law walk with him as Ring bearer. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with having an adult help if the child is young.
    • Reply
  • Mrs.hays
    VIP April 2018
    Mrs.hays ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    One of you will have to compromise. I think not being able to find a sitter is a bogus excuse if given enough time beforehand. If you’re really that worried about children interrupting your big day then I suggest convincing him to do a child free wedding.
    • Reply
  • MarchMadness
    Dedicated March 2018
    MarchMadness ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Maybe because I’m a mom and my son will be 1 at the time of our wedding I’m sort of side eyeing this post. I have to think about my pre-mom self. But then I just think of my social worker self and how you never know what kind of neurological issues a child may have and it may not be the parents fault a child can’t “mind” (?).

    That being said, it’s your wedding. Make it kid free if you want. BUT if you have no kids,
    you have to exclude ALL KIDS, not hust
    your sisters.
    • Reply
  • Rissachu
    Dedicated August 2019
    Rissachu ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    Ooh this is a perfect idea!

    • Reply
  • stephanie
    Super October 2017
    stephanie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    We had about a dozen kids at our wedding under 10 and it was no issue. In my family most people take their kids to church and whatnot so kids know there are times they need to be quiet for a bit and entertain themselves. My niece was our flower girl and she was one week shy of 2. She did fine. I had just told my brother if she walks out and isn't feeling flower girling, just pick her up and take her down the aisle, no big deal. Also I couldn't care less if she doesn't drop a single thing from her basket. My day won't be ruined by not having enough flower petals to walk on.

    Kids are people too and I always loved going to weddings as a kid, and had so much fun at wedding receptions. So what if kids run around and yell at the reception - it's a party, it's supposed to be loud and fun. Most kids can keep quiet for 20 minutes for a wedding ceremony. I also knew it absolutely wouldn't ruin the event for me if, heaven forbid, a kid made a little noise at some point. An adult also might sneeze or have a heart attack or something, I didn't exclude elderly people or anyone with health issues just because there is some chance they will have a medical issue mid-ceremony.

    Another option you could consider is to provide babysitting so people can bring kids to part of the event, ex. Babysitting available during the ceremony and dinner, but kids can join for the dancing and fun, loud stuff if they want. I have a lot of family and friends with small kids, so I had told H that if it was important to him to not have kids at the ceremony we could provide babysitting during that part and just have kids at the reception. He ended up being okay w allowing kids at everything, and like I said above, we had no issues. Since we had many out of town guests, I didn't want babysitting to be an issue keeping any of our loved ones from attending.
    • Reply
  • GoodMOB
    April 2018
    GoodMOB ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I was at a wedding ceremony that really was pretty much ruined by toddlers making noises & the Parents Not Removing Them! I believe in the idea of having a babysitter or 2 available in a nearby room during a wedding, so parents can leave little ones there if they need to nap, or blow off energy, or whatever.

    My brother did that for his wedding when we had 2 very young children, and it was wonderful. Our toddler napped in the nursery for the ceremony, and woke up refreshed to make a small appearance at the reception. And while we were waiting for things to start and so on, the kids had a "home base" and toys to play with.

    • Reply
  • E.V.
    VIP November 2017
    E.V. ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    It was. “But his parents didn’t make home behave” “Especially if the parents don’t have much control.” Not his fault. He is three.
    • Reply
  • JerseyGirl
    Master May 2017
    JerseyGirl ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    We had a child free wedding. No one had an issue finding a babysitter. Our only issue was DH’s SIL who gave birth the week before. We gave her the option to bring the baby but understandable she declined and did not attend. There should be no problem finding a sitter especially if no one is OOT. (We also got married Saturday of Mother’s Day weekend and had no issues with people getting sitters)
    • Reply
  • Rissachu
    Dedicated August 2019
    Rissachu ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I appreciate all of the input. I don't really think it's my responsibility to pay for, find, or provide a babysitter for someone else though.

    I have options to consider.

    • Reply
  • Jess
    Dedicated October 2018
    Jess ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    We are only inviting in circles. The only kids we will have are FH siblings (there's a 20 year age gap between him and his brother and sister, they're 4 and 5), my godchildren who are in the wedding, and my God children's siblings.
    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Explore how we embrace diversity

Groups

WeddingWire article topics