Skip to main content
Weddings

About

About us:

Sugar Fetish Cakery is a custom cake design studio located in Piscataway, NJ specializing in wedding cakes, specialty cakes, cupcakes, cookies, dessert tables and more. Our mission is to transfer your vision into extraordinarily unique and delicious dessert. We will always bring special attention to your event and create the most amazing cakes and cupcakes that are sure to wow your guests. Whether you’re looking for a cake for a baby shower or a five-tiered wedding cake, you can be sure that the Sugar Fetish Cakery will be able to create an edible masterpiece for your special event.

Ordering:


We suggest placing your order 4-6 weeks prior to your event date. For short notice orders please call us immediately on the rare chance that we may be available. Our cakes require a minimum of two days to be baked off and decorated. When placing an order, please have an idea of how many servings you would like your cake to be, as well as your theme, colors, and any specific design ideas you would like to incorporate. Your order is confirmed, once a contract is signed and a 50% non-refundable deposit is collected. The remaining balance payment must be completed 14 days prior to cake pickup/delivery or the order is canceled.

Pricing:


Pricing is determined by unique variables, including- serving size and custom design. Our custom cakes start at $175 (approximately 10-12 servings). Since all of our cakes are unique and customized to our client needs, there are no set prices. Cakes are priced according to several different criteria. Our base prices per serving can give you a general idea of the estimated starting price of your cake. The base price includes the layered cake with filling, fondant icing, and very simple decorations. Other factors that add to the total cost of your cake include premium cake flavors/fillings, cake sculpting, gum paste decorations, detailed piping, hand painting, airbrushing, any other intricate design elements, and delivery.

Delivery and Shipping:

Delivery is typically within the tri-state area (New Jersey, New York and Connecticut) however, there is no limit to the distance we may be willing to deliver. The Sugar Fetish Cakery team can be engaged to design and assemble a cake in other states/countries when airfare and expenses are pre-paid by the client. Long distance or out of state deliveries may require special arrangements, so we ask that clients please contact us for detailed information and estimates. Due to the fragile nature of our cakes, we currently do not offer shipping. We can however, ship cookies, cake pops and chocolate covered Oreos.


Tastings/Consultations:

Tastings/Consultations are scheduled on Saturday and Sunday from 12pm-5pm, by appointment only. A non-refundable fee of $50 is required for tastings/consultations, which will be credited towards your order total of $400 or more if booked within one week of the tasting date. During your consultation you and one guest will be given the opportunity to taste our standard cake flavors and present ideas on your cake theme. You can select from four cake flavors and six cake fillings. Tastings are one hour in duration. Additional guests will be $15 per person.

  • Black-owned
  • Woman-owned
illustration popular

Vendors you may like

See other vendors that are popular with couples right now

Frequently asked questions

What is the starting price for wedding cakes with buttercream frosting (per slice, without tax)?

$9.75

What is the starting price for fondant wedding cakes (per slice, without tax)?

$9.75

Which of the following are included in the cost of the cake?

Top Tier of the Cake

What is the starting price for cupcakes (per cupcake, without tax)?

$4

What services do your prices include?

Consultation
Custom Cake Design
Set Up
Tastings - Private

What types of desserts do you provide?

Cookies
Cupcakes
Dessert Buffet
Groom's Cake

What services do you provide?

Consultations
Custom Design
Delivery
Setup
Tastings - Private

What cake items do you provide?

Cake Cutters
Cake Stands
Cake Toppers

What special ingredients do you use?

Fresh Fruit
Local
Organic

Are you licensed by the state health department?

Not Required

Reviews of Sugar Fetish Cakery

M
Marc Sent on 11/30/2025
5 out of 5 rating

Phenomal Service and Exquisite Cake Design

Sugar Fetish Cakery provided truly phenomenal service from start to finish. From the moment my wife and I met Latisha, we knew she was the one we wanted to create our wedding cake. She offered an impressive variety of flavors and allowed us to mix and match cake and icing combinations, which was a dream for me since I have a serious sweet tooth! Surprisingly, the cakes were perfectly balanced and not overly sweet at all.
Our family and friends absolutely loved both the cake and the frosting. For our design, we wanted something simple yet elegant to match our wedding theme. We sent over inspiration photos, and she blended our ideas beautifully into a stunning final design.
She is attentive, respectful, friendly, welcoming, and incredibly artistic, someone we would gladly do business with again. Her pricing is fair, her communication is excellent, and the quality of her work truly speaks for itself.
Our flavors were:
* Vanilla with Cookies & Cream(Top Layer)
* Strawberry with Cream Cheese Frosting
* Vanilla with Biscoff Buttercream
Every single flavor was a hit!
As a thoughtful bonus, she also surprised us with the most beautiful little cups of cake for us to take home and enjoy after the wedding. It was such a special and personal touch, and we truly appreciated being able to relive the flavors all over again.
We highly recommend Sugar Fetish Cakery to anyone looking for flawless service, breathtaking presentation, and unforgettable cakes!

Ruth
Ruth Sent on 11/21/2025
5 out of 5 rating

I love Sugar Fetish Cakery!

Sugar Fetish Bakery responded to me promptly and was a true collaborative partner in helping to make our day so special. She asked about the color scheme and we came up with a design that corresponded to our autumnal theme. We wanted a Lemon Elderflower cake and the bakery did not flinch. ( some other bakers did) I have recommended Sugar Fetish Cakery to many friends and plan to use their services again.
I
Ifedolapo Sent on 11/21/2025
5 out of 5 rating

Sugar Fetish Cakes

I'll recommend Sugar Fetish Cakes to anyone looking for the perfect cake. She was super amazing, very helpful with recommendations and always attentive. We went over the details together and she made sure I was satisfied with the design we came up with. Everyone gushed about how beautiful looked and how good it tasted!!! Thank you SugarFetish Cakes
Barbara
Barbara Sent on 08/29/2022
5 out of 5 rating

Incredible!

My daughter had a short time to plan her intimate wedding. I was introduced to Latissa through our wedding planner. My daughter shared what she wanted and Latissa immediately GOT IT! The cake was exactly as discussed. It was beautiful and delicious! The husband and Groom were thrilled and I couldn't have been happier with the OUTSTANDING service!

I would highly recommend them and will be using this service again for our October 2023
event!
V
Victoria Sent on 07/03/2021
5 out of 5 rating

Wonderful service

The owner is so wonderful and kind . My wedding treats were amazing and everyone loved them . Loved the customer service as well . I highly recommend her for any bakery needs!!
Osahon
Osahon Sent on 06/24/2021
5 out of 5 rating

Great experience

I can’t even put in words how great of an experience I had with Sugar Fetish Cakery.
I highly recommend them, you will definitely get what you ask for.
I was so impressed with the outcome of the cake from the beauty of the cake to the yummy taste.
M
M. Greer Sent on 05/19/2021
5 out of 5 rating

40th & 35th sisters birthday party celebration

Our cake was one of a kind...a floating cake! This cake was baked to perfection and the decor of it was completely unmatched to any other cake designer’s work I’ve researched. A true professional to say the least. I have found my go to bakery business. Anyone utilizing Sugar Fetish Cakery will not be disappointed!!! Great quality, great service, great professionalism equals A+ business.
Oriana
Oriana Sent on 03/30/2021
5 out of 5 rating

the best of the world!!🌈🌈

my wedding cake was more than I expected !! She was so attentive to everything I asked, it was inevitable not to cry with happiness when seeing the result, added to that the taste and texture of the cake, it was noted that it was made with a lot of love🥺 I will definitely contact her in my next events! Thank you for always❤️
L
Lee-Ann Sent on 03/28/2021
5 out of 5 rating

Excellence From Beginning to End!

From my very first interaction with Sugar Fetish Cakery, I knew I had made the best decision on who would be the vendor for our cake!! Planning a wedding during the global pandemic was a rollercoaster in itself but Sugar Fetish Cakery was honestly the easiest and best vendor to work with throughout the entire process! The ease of communication, the prompt responses, the pleasant personality and creative excellence made our day even that more special and sweet (literally). It was excellence from beginning to end and if I ever need a cake or sweet treats for ANY event in the future Sugar Fetish Cakery will be our choice, no doubt! 100% definitely recommend!
Salwa
Salwa Sent on 09/25/2020
5 out of 5 rating

Princess and the Frog Mardi Gras Cake

I was in a pinch and Sugar Fetish Cakery came through with NOT only a beautiful fun cake but a great tasting one as well. She took my MANY ideas and came up with a beautiful concept that tasted great too! I would def. use her again and most certainly recommend her!
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.

Awards

21
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2022 Winner

Professional Network & Endorsements

Preferred Vendors
The Brothers Gorman
5.0 out of 5 rating , 18 reviews
· Wedding Photographers
Finer Touch Entertainment
5.0 out of 5 rating , 77 reviews
· Wedding DJs
Pretty Posh Events
5.0 out of 5 rating , 18 reviews
· Wedding Planners
Create That Party
5.0 out of 5 rating , 5 reviews
· Wedding Planners

Map

Addresses map
Next Wedding Cakes: Sweet Tweets Cakery

Other vendors in Central Jersey for your wedding

Wedding Vendors