Petonito’s Pastry Shop is a specialty wedding cake service and bakery in East Haven, Connecticut. As one of the very few authentic Italian pastry shops in New Haven, this bakery is ideal for unique, unconventional wedding cakes and desserts. Since 1954 they have made over an estimated 25,000 wedding cakes, and continue to treat couples with delicious, beautifully designed cakes. Choose Petonito’s Pastry Shop for a wedding treat that will make you and your guests’ mouths water.
Petonito’s Pastry Shop offers custom-designed wedding cakes and delicious Italian pastries for all tastes and budgets. Their custom wedding cakes can be made from fondant or buttercream frosting and with a variety of flavors. Tastings are provided for all wedding desserts and cakes. Petonito’s Pastry Shop also offers cupcakes, cannoli and cookie trays, and a variety of Italian mini pastries.
Other couples have also viewed
54 Reviews for Petonitos Pastry and Cupcake Shoppe
Recommended by 98% of couples
2 User photos
Kristina B. · Married on 08/17/2019
Most delicious cake!
I had an idea in mind of what I wanted, which changed when I found out they don't do fondant cakes. But they were still able to do the colors I wanted, the ombre design, and the most delicious cake! We had one layer of chocolate cake and one layer of confetti cake (which is my absolute favorite). It was so personalized and no fondant meant everyone got to enjoy every last bit of cake on their plate! This bakery is part of wedding traditions in my family and they were so flexible, affordable, and easy to work with.Sent on 09/03/2019
Carolyn · Married on 05/25/2019
Excellent service and great taste!
Petonito's was FANTASTIC!! We booked Petonito's as part of a package with our venue and it was so nice having a vendor that was so familiar with our venue. Our cake was made exactly how we had envisioned and the staff was so kind (they gave us complimentary cookies when we booked!). We had two different flavors in our cake and our guests really loved both! Additionally, we had bought two birthday cakes because we had a couple of birthdays at our wedding and those were also beautiful and special. The cakes were great and the service was attentive; I would highly recommend Petonito's!Sent on 06/16/2019
Cait · Married on 11/10/2018
Delicious and beautiful
Upon seeing our wedding cake for the first time, I was incredibly pleased to see how beautiful it looked. From the purple ribbon wrapped around the bottom layers to the white roses scattered throughout, it was stunning. Once we opened up the cake, the funfetti cake and strawberry filling took it over the top! Thank you for a delicious addition to our wedding day!Sent on 11/16/2018