Otto Tomotto's is a wonderful little Italian restaurant (owned by a relative of mine!) Their food is very good and very affordable. We had a full buffet dinner for our wedding reception of around 140 people at a little over $10/person.
The two servers who staffed our reception were efficient and friendly.
Tim (the owner and chef) is a bit difficult to get a hold of and sometimes needs a little reminding to get things done (I've worked with him before though so I was used to that).
They did provide real dishes and silverware, which was nice, although we were expecting white dishes (and got a random collection of reds, browns, oranges, yellows). They clashed horribly with our dark purple, green and silver color scheme, so my mom had to run out last minute to buy disposable white dishes (being a guy, he probably didn't think that the color of dishes would matter)!
Everyone raved about the food though, and that's all that really matters!