Skip to main content
Weddings
ARE YOU A VENDOR?
Guilty Bakery
Guilty Bakery
Milk Glass Effect
Milk Glass Effect
Nautical Trio Newport, RI
Nautical Trio Newport, RI
Fondant Rustic Wrap
Fondant Rustic Wrap
Painted Watercolor
Painted Watercolor
Smooth Buttercream & Blush
Smooth Buttercream & Blush
Dusty Blue
Dusty Blue
Fondant Ruffle
Fondant Ruffle
Naked Cake with Gold leaf
Naked Cake with Gold leaf
Rough Spackle Buttercream
Rough Spackle Buttercream
Beachy Buttercream
Beachy Buttercream
Glam
Glam
Chatham Bars Inn
Chatham Bars Inn
Small Gold bees
Small Gold bees
Gold airbrush
Gold airbrush
Dessert table
Dessert table
Simple spiral fresh floral
Simple spiral fresh floral
Simple spiral fresh floral
Simple spiral fresh floral
Ceremony cake & cupcakes
Ceremony cake & cupcakes
Nautical Cake trio
Nautical Cake trio
Clam shell accent
Clam shell accent
Cake trio Granite Links
Cake trio Granite Links
White with gold leaf
White with gold leaf
Blush accent cupcake table
Blush accent cupcake table
Gold ribbon & sequins
Gold ribbon & sequins
Gold sequins with stencil
Gold sequins with stencil
Spiral buttercream
Spiral buttercream
Simple Monogram
Simple Monogram
Large Ribbon effect
Large Ribbon effect
Simple Spiral buttercream
Simple Spiral buttercream
Day of the Dead Theme
Day of the Dead Theme
Best Day Ever
Best Day Ever
Bridal Shower Cake
Bridal Shower Cake
Ocean Cliff, Newport RI
Ocean Cliff, Newport RI
Small Tent Wedding
Small Tent Wedding
Waterfront Tented Wedding
Waterfront Tented Wedding
Bright Buttercream Piping
Bright Buttercream Piping
The Bohlin Newport, RI
The Bohlin Newport, RI
Spiral Buttercream 5 tier
Spiral Buttercream 5 tier
Groom's Cake
Groom's Cake
Nautical Gold Rope
Nautical Gold Rope
Bridal Shower Cookies
Bridal Shower Cookies
Small ceremony cake
Small ceremony cake
Monogram
Monogram
Groom's Cake
Groom's Cake
Omni Parker House
Omni Parker House
Omni Parker House
Omni Parker House
Gold & Floral
Gold & Floral
Four Seasons Boston, MA
Four Seasons Boston, MA
Clean & Simple
Clean & Simple
Squared cake
Squared cake
Cake table
Cake table
Display set up
Display set up

Interested in this vendor?

Cake table Omni Parker House

About

Guilty Bakery is a Plymouth, Massachusetts-based business that designs and produces customized wedding cakes and confectioneries. Amy and Krista are the partner-owners of this special establishment and are two down-to-earth individuals who love to get creative. They are proficient in baking a wide variety of delicious goods and can expertly portray a selected theme or aesthetic through their creations.

Services Offered

You can look forward to working with two friendly professionals when you acquire the services of Guilty Bakery. Known for producing a vast oeuvre of mouth-watering confectioneries, you and your partner are sure to find something scrumptious for your dessert table. Guilty Bakery offers tastings where you are able to test and compare until you find the perfect mix. Amy and Krista are committed to bringing a sweet touch to your big occasion with desserts that truly showcase your colorful personality.

  • Woman-owned
illustration popular

Vendors you may like

See other vendors that are popular with couples right now

Montilios
Wedding cupcakes
Wedding cake
Wood-fired pizza
Montilios
4.7 (492) ·
Brockton, MA

Award winner

Cake by Brenna
Classic white
Rustic eucalyptus
Classic wedding View 18 more photos
Cake by Brenna
5.0 (10) ·
Brewster, MA
Cafe Create A Cake
Cafe Create A Cake
Cafe Create A Cake
Cafe Create A Cake View 72 more photos
Cafe Create A Cake
5.0 (1) ·
Plymouth, MA
Sweet Sense Gluten free baked goods
Wedding cake
Wedding cake
Wedding cake View 17 more photos
Sweet Sense Gluten free baked goods
5.0 (1) ·
Plymouth, MA
Kiss Me Cakes
Ombre with starfish topper
Birch bark cake
Seashell Wedding Cake View 36 more photos
Kiss Me Cakes
5.0 (4) ·
Wellfleet, MA

Frequently asked questions

What is the starting price for wedding cakes with buttercream frosting (per slice, without tax)?

$5

What is the starting price for fondant wedding cakes (per slice, without tax)?

$5

What is the starting price for cupcakes (per cupcake, without tax)?

$2

What services do your prices include?

Consultation
Custom Cake Design
Delivery
Set Up
Tastings - Private

What types of desserts do you provide?

Cookies
Croquembouche
Cupcakes
Dessert Buffet
Groom's Cake
Pastries

What services do you provide?

Consultations
Custom Design
Delivery
Setup
Tastings - Private

What dietary needs can you accommodate?

Gluten Free
Vegan

What special ingredients do you use?

Fresh Fruit
Local

Are you licensed by the state health department?

Yes

Reviews of Guilty Bakery

Write a review
Write a review
Guilty Bakery - 1
Guilty Bakery - 2
Guilty Bakery - 3
+3 User photos
Guilty Bakery - 4
Jessica
Jessica Sent on 10/12/2022
5 out of 5 rating

Beautiful wedding cake!

Guilty bakery made us a beautiful cake and everyone loved the apple cider donuts and pumpkin whoopie pies! The cake looked exactly like the inspiration photos I provided. Would definitely reccomend them for your wedding needs!
Morgan
Morgan Sent on 05/20/2025
5 out of 5 rating

Beautiful Cake!

We were really happy with our wedding cake from Guilty Bakery! They were easy to work with and helpful in bringing our vision to life. They paid close attention to the details, and the final cake looked beautiful and tasted great. We chose two flavors—Lemon Berry and Carrot Cake—and both were a hit with our guests. Overall, a great experience and choice for wedding cakes!
  • Guilty Bakery - 5
  • Guilty Bakery - 6
Tyler
Tyler Sent on 12/23/2024
5 out of 5 rating

Incredible!

We loved working with the team at Guilty Bakery when looking to create our perfect wedding cake! The tasting process was professional, informative, and we walked out feeling like our voices were heard. We haven't gotten photos back yet, but the cake was gorgeous and delicious. Highly recommend!
D
Danielle Sent on 09/01/2023
5 out of 5 rating

We loved our simple wedding cake

We loved working with Guilty Bakery for our wedding cake for our reception at Granite Links. We went with something really simple and then had our florist add fresh flowers. Everyone raved about the vanilla with blonde Oreos flavor we picked. We worked with them to have Gf/DF cupcakes available as well. Would recommend!
  • Guilty Bakery - 7
B
Brooke Sent on 01/17/2023
5 out of 5 rating

Yummy and gorgeous

we just needed a small cutting cake with a topper. The carrot cake was SO DELICIOUS and they were able to make a gingerbread bride and groom as our wedding was in the winter. Adorable. SO easy to get in contact with and really listen to your needs.
Jason
Jason Sent on 06/11/2022
5 out of 5 rating

Delicious!

Amy and Krista helped us design our perfect wedding cake! We choose 2 flavors for our 3 tiered cake, Coffee Oreo and Carrot Cake which were delicious! We got so many compliments about how amazing it was! We would definitely recommend Guilty Bakery!
  • Guilty Bakery - 8
J
James Sent on 10/15/2019
5 out of 5 rating

Fantastic and Fun Cake

Amy and Krista at Guilty Bakery were fantastic to work with. They were very flexible with some changes throughout the process and able to give suggestions and take our recommendations to make them our own. They have so many flavors to choose from that it was hard to narrow it down. They added flowers to the cake and were able to let the florist know how much they needed and complete it day of. Everything was taken care of for us day of, so there were no worries!! An amazing cake that made our day!!
Nicole
Nicole Sent on 08/18/2019
5 out of 5 rating

So Delicious!

We chose Guilty Bakery on the recommendation of our venue, and good thing we did because our wedding cake was possibly our favorite part of our day! Not only was it super delicious (light, not too sweet, the perfect amount of frosting), but it was so gorgeous. I couldn't stop looking at it all night! We only wish we got to eat more of it, but we will definitely be going back to Guilty Bakery again and again. Amy and Krista were so easy to work and completely understood what we were looking for. They went above and beyond, and they were so responsive via email which was great, and really put us at ease. Can't recommend Guilty Bakery enough!
Kristen
Kristen Sent on 06/08/2019
5 out of 5 rating

Delicious Cake!

The girls at guilty bakery were fantastic to work with! We were thrilled with the design the drew up for us. The cake received rave reviews from our guests!
C
Caroline Sent on 08/09/2018
5 out of 5 rating
We used guilty bakery for our 7-14-18 wedding at Granite links. I would choose Guilty over and over again. Their cakes are works of art! They were a pleasure to work with and worth the hour drive. This was the best cake I’ve ever tasted in my life and we repeatedly heard this from our wedding guests. I look forward to using Guilty in the near future!
Thank you!
Caroline and Nick
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Read all reviews

Awards

26
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2015 Winner

Explore other vendors in your area

Find the most recommended vendors and Couples' Choice Award winners.

See vendors

Map

Addresses map
Cakes Cape Cod
Cakes Plymouth
Next Wedding Cakes: Crazy for Cookies

Other vendors in Cape Cod for your wedding

Wedding Vendors