We got a 2 tier cake, cupcakes, and cookies. They set up for us and it looked great! But what was even better was the food!! To die for!!

Bittner's Bakery and Amy were fantastic to work with! We asked for Bittner's to create a sweetheart wedding cake for the bride and groom and then cupcakes for about 160 guests for our wedding reception. Amy promptly answered all of our questions (in person at our initial meeting and frequently by email), including helping us select the perfect cupcake to-go boxes for our guests. They also delivered the wedding cake and cupcakes to our venue without issue and even provided the cake and cupcake displays for these items. Not only was our sweetheart wedding cake the exact design we asked for, but it looked even better than expected and was delicious! Also, our guests loved the four flavors of cupcakes provided for our wedding so much that we had none leftover to take home at the end of the wedding reception! Bittner's Bakery provided us with high quality baked goods that everyone loved and we will definitely be using them again for our future bakery needs.

We couldn't have asked for a more professional bakery. We had a cookie table at our wedding and it was all anyone could talk about. It was delicious and adorable. I highly recommend Bittner's!

Best bakery around! The cake with cupcakes looked awesome and tested even better! Also purchased cannolis, mini eclair sand cookies for rehearsal dinner and donuts and muffins for guests who were visiting for several days. These folks are helpful, creative and deliver a delicious great looking product! Would use them again in a heartbeat!

We had a 3 tier marble cake with raspberry creme filling and butter creme frosting and I can not rave about it more. They also did an sweet assortment table that everybody has just raved about. I would recommend this bakery to everyone I know. We also make this bakery a stop for us every time we go through Lake Geneva.

Amy Bittner at Bittner's Bakery did an absolutely amazing job on my wedding cake. I asked for almond flavored cake and although it was not on their usual menu, she was happy to help. She even coordinated with the florist to ensure the flowers for the cake were delivered before she delivered the cake to the site, and she arranged the flowers on the cake herself. It was stunning. And pricing was incredibly reasonable. But beware...you can't go to this bake shop without filling up a box or two of sweets from behind the glass! It's a magical little place with truly wonderful people. Couldn't have been happier with their service.

Very accommodating with the change of plans from an April 2020 wedding to a May 2021 wedding.

Bittner's Bakery did an amazing job on our wedding cake!!
We went with a beach theme and Amy knew exactly what to do!! Our cake was perfect!
Bittner's is so good we even stopped in the day of our rehearsal dinner and purchased cookies to have at our rehearsal dinner!

Bittner's did the grooms cake and the wedding cake and they both turned out great! The grooms cake turned out to be more than I would have imagined with the design and flavors, it was awesome! My husband loved it! The wedding cake turned out beautiful as well and it tasted very good!

Loved Bittner's and I'm happy we went with them for our wedding cake. I showed Amy a picture of a cake that I found on Pinterest (a small round cake covered in gold sparkles that vaguely resembled sequins), and she was able to re-create it pretty well. We opted for a small two-tier cake to cut for pictures and then just had a sheet cake in the back that the staff at our venue cute. The two-tier cake looked beautiful, but more importantly, everything tasted amazing. We got so many compliments from people saying how moist it was, which is somewhat rare for a wedding cake. During our tasting, we ended up buying some other baked goods and those were also really great. I'm not a big coffee-cake person, but we got one that was delicious. My only issue with Bittner's was that a week or so passed by with no response when I emailed them to double-check that they were going to deliver the cake to the venue and to give them our last payment. When Amy did contact me, though, she was super apologetic and said they had been swamped, so I didn't really mind.