Vista Print or Shutterfly for Invitations?

Firstly, congrats and welcome!

I agree with Susan. I've used both websites for quite a few things (magnets, invites for FH's 30th birthday earlier this year) , and all of them have turned out well. They look nice and arrive in a timely fashion. Just make sure to nail down all the details as Susan said.

You dont even need to be worrying about invites right now, but vistaprint does a semiannual sale. The one in July would be perfect for your timeline

I have been ordering stuff from vistaprint for years. They have amazing customer service. Once I screwed up my address on address labels (typing too fast, didn't realize I'd made a stupid typo). I contacted their customer service and even though I told them it was 100% MY fault, they still gave me credit to use toward reordering. Plus they do good quality work and have sales pretty frequently.

I don't have experience with invitations with these companies, but bought other items from each of them. I used VistaPrint for my seating chart and not only is it gorgeous, but the packaging was amazing to insure the foam board wasn't damaged. I used Shutterfly for photo enlargements and was disappointed with their packaging. My prints arrived damaged when the postman forced the package into the mailbox. Stronger cardboard would have helped protect the photos.

I love love love Vista Prints!

Shutterfly is awesome.. I used a 50% off coupon. Here are ours.. they have really pretty options