Torn between 2 Dresses

I thought I was set on my dress decision! I made an appointment at a bridal salon that I’d visited 2 times prior to finally decide on a dress. I had the dress in mind pulled, but grabbed a few others just because. I was surprised by a dress that I randomly pulled that was similar to a style that I tried on and had in my top 4. I LOVED the dress when I put it on; I surprised myself because it showed a little more skin than I usually feel comfortable with but I felt covered enough.

Please help! I like both! The first dress photo is the one I had in mind and it totally fits my New Orleans theme. The 2nd dress photo that I unexpectedly loved is more romantic. The second dress is also $200 over my budget. The third photo is both dresses worn by the models. Any input is appreciated (and both samples were a size too small).

[Ignore my facial expressions as I was not paying attention.]