Swim up or balcony

I can't make up my mind! My fiance and I will be staying at Sandals South Coast for our honeymoon (which also falls on both of our birthdays). We can't decide what type of room to get. He wants one of the new swim up rooms as he has never experienced one before. I prefer a balcony as I would like to sit outside and see the ocean from up high. Im not sure of the ocean view from the ground floor. Both rooms have a tub on the porch with a curtain that can be closed for privacy. The swim up room would cost an additional $740 for the week.


So here are our options. 1. Stay in the balcony room. 2. Upgrade to the swim up. 3. Do a combination of both. 3 nights in the balcony room for my birthday and 4 nights in the swim up for his ($473 more).
I have added a pic of what it might look like below. These new rooms will not be completed until December 2020. All rooms mentioned are butler rooms.