Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Kelsey
Savvy December 2021

Sister's Plus One

Kelsey, on December 16, 2019 at 2:18 PM Posted in Etiquette and Advice 0 8

Hello all! So I know giving your bridal parties +1s is the most polite thing to do, but my older sister has me in a pickle. Let me explain...

My older sister tends to not only date questionable men, but to cater to their every whim, putting them before everyone else. At my college graduation, her boyfriend at the time did not like seafood, and I had chosen a seafood restaurant, so rather than eat with us and find something on the menu, she agreed to go with him to a different restaurant, completely skipping my graduation dinner. She was also recently a BM in a cousin's wedding and literally LEFT while the bridal party was getting ready so she could go pick up and drive her date (not boyfriend... just a date) to the venue so he "didn't have to travel to the venue himself and feel alone". Something like this will give me soooo much anxiety on my wedding day, as our venue is a good 30+ minutes outside of our city.

We recently sent out save the dates for our wedding next fall. At my mother's advice (and she is paying for 90% of our wedding) she suggested that we did not give my older sister a plus one, as she is currently single. She is a BM and both my mother and I could not think of a situation where she wouldn't be distracted by her date in some way or another. My younger sister even agreed to not have a 1+ to ease the tension.

At the idea of not having an automatic date, my older sister went BALLISTIC, even telling my mom she will cover the cost of her date herself. She insists that if she is in my wedding, she should have a date, and I get it, but at the same time when my own mom is concerned about my sister's focus and behavior, I feel like I have a genuine point. Am I being too insensitive?

P.S. I should probably note that if she does have a boyfriend at the time of official RSVPs, he will of course be counted. Also, despite her being 30, my mother has purchased her entire BM outfit, will be paying for her travel and hotel and I am not having any bachelorette party, so she can't really use the money she is spending on this wedding as an excuse, as my mother is paying for most of her expenses as well.

8 Comments

Latest activity by Katie, on December 17, 2019 at 12:43 PM
  • Raphaella
    Savvy June 2020
    Raphaella ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    My fiance and I are firm believers in it is our day and we aren't going to set ourselves up for situations that are going to make us upset, anxious, or annoyed. We are not giving his siblings (all of which are in our bridal party) a plus one unless they are in a relationship at the time of final guest count because we do not want them inviting a certain cousin family that we do not want at our day. We explained this to them and although they weren't happy at first they understand.

    • Reply
  • Liza
    Dedicated September 2021
    Liza ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I think allowing her to only bring a plus one if she is in a relationships is perfectly acceptable! She will know plenty of people at the wedding and so isn't someone who needs a plus one in order to not feel alone/awkward.


    I had a BM ask if her sister could come as her "plus one" if her bf is not available that day. I said no. She has a ton of close friends attending the wedding and I made sure she will be seated with them all for dinner. Her bf is invited, her sister is not. I do not think that is how a plus one should work (though I actually listed her bf on the invite... so its not even technically a plus one....)



    • Reply
  • John Smith
    Expert February 2015
    John Smith ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    So I actually had the opposite thought process than you concerning "she's in the wedding so she should get a +1". All of my and my fiance's siblings are in the wedding and only one of them is getting a +1 because she's been dating the guy for 2 years and is likely going to get engaged soon. My thinking was that 1) they're in the wedding so if they had a date the date would be left alone a lot (during the ceremony, while photos are being taken, etc) and wouldn't know anyone, and 2) they'll have their entire family there so they really don't need "company". I'm also having a smaller wedding though, and 80% of the guests will be family members.


    In my opinion, do not give her a +1.

    • Reply
  • Kelsey
    VIP September 2020
    Kelsey ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I agree with you that she shouldn't get a plus one. I was in a wedding this summer and the groom's sister had a boyfriend at the time but for some reason the boyfriend couldn't make it. It turned into a huge mess, because the day before the wedding the groom's sister decides to make her ex-boyfriend her plus 1 instead. She hardly spent anytime with us getting ready, she literally left the salon to go spend time with her ex and at dinner was by him the entire time and then complained when her food got cold at the head table. My friend truly wishes that her now SIL would have just not had a plus one since she was difficult to find the entire time and didn't really help with the bride's stress level.

    • Reply
  • Kristen
    Master November 2020
    Kristen ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I would say if you are concerned then allow her a plus 1 but be real with her and say that this happened in the past and for the day of the wedding you need her to be there for you. I agree with a PP that the plus 1 should be a serious boyfriend and not just a date. I would even say someone you have met. He may not be the best but she's your sister so be upfront and real and say that the day of she is there for you and she can spend time with him of course but for getting ready and pics you need her there. What do you think? Although if mom is thinking otherwise she may have a point. I feel give her the chance to prove herself.

    • Reply
  • Kelsi
    Expert June 2020
    Kelsi ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I don't think it's necessary to give someone a plus one if they are not in a relationship. The single people in our bridal party didn't get one and guests who are single and not from out of town didn't get one either. Heck, one of my friends isn't allowed to bring her boyfriend. We didn't want random strangers at our wedding and have limited space. Your sister is being unreasonable.

    • Reply
  • J
    Master October 2019
    Jolie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    She sounds like a brat. It's your choice and if your mom is backing it well then that's also fine. Like you said, if she has a boyfriend at the time of the wedding he can be invited. I personally didn't give my wedding party plus one's because nobody at the wedding got a plus one. Two were married, their spouses were invited. Two had a SO, they were invited. Nobody else complained and they had a more than fine time dancing with friends and family! You don't have to give plus ones. The only poor etiquette is not inviting SOs which you're obviously doing so you're good! Smiley smile

    • Reply
  • Katie
    Devoted March 2019
    Katie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    An easy way to end the discussion with your sister is:

    "FH and I decided that only married couples, or those in a long-term relationship are having a plus one. This is a decision we made together for our wedding." ….this is essentially the "no ring, no bring" policy but is a statement that shows you and your FH are unified on this, and it is a firm decision that has already been made. When it is inevitably brought up in the future you can simply say "we already discussed this". If you tell her "oh if you have a boyfriend we'll let him come" or try and give reasons why she doesn't have a plus one she will either find ways to argue with you on your reasons or conveniently start calling mr. random her boyfriend a month before the wedding.

    You got this girl! Smiley smile

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Explore how we embrace diversity

Groups

WeddingWire article topics