Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

M

sil wedding party

Mindy, on March 25, 2023 at 1:49 PM Posted in Family and Relationships 0 10

SIL invited other SILs in Bridal Party and I’m hurt to be excluded.


just want to first caveat that I acknowledge that a bride has the right to choose who she wants in her wedding party, should not be obligated to include anyone she doesn’t want to, and ultimately the decision is hers. I am thrilled for my sister in law to be getting remarried.


I’m curious as to others’ perspective. My SIL is getting married (2nd wedding for bride-her first wedding was 4 people and a destination wedding) and it is a backyard bbq event. She has one sister and i am married to her brother, have known her for 10 years, am godparent to her son. We have a good relationship, have shared fun times together, no history of any conflict. Her fiancé has 2 sisters. recently her fiancé asked my hubby if he’ll be a part of his wedding party (they aren’t “friends” but get along when they see each other at family events). He mentioned he’s also invited 3 of his friends, and that my husband’s sister is “inviting her sister and my sisters so its a family affair”. I know for a fact she is not “close” with her fiance’s siblings, and one sister she was not on speaking terms with until recently.


I am so surprised and a bit embarrassed as to how hurt and shocked I am not to be asked to be in her wedding party. I see a wedding party as a reflection on those who you love and support you and that there is meaning and significance behind it-of course, this is my belief that may not be held by them. To me, especially since other sister in laws are in it, i’m baffled that she would include 2 people she isn’t close to, one with a precarious past relationship, and not me. If a friend shared such a scenario, i would assume the bride likely does not get along with said sister in law (ie me). If she had just her sister in her wedding party, i get it but i’m hurt that she’s invited her fiancé’s sisters and not me. She is not the type of person who gives in to “obligations” and has put off the wedding in the past because of her issues with her fiancé’s family. I will get over it, won’t forget it though and makes me wonder if she just doesn’t realize the message it is symbolically sending me. My husband may or may not ask her in the future out of curiosity as to why— he finds it surprising but assumes she’s inviting her other 2 SILS out of obligation. I accept and validate my feelings although feel embarrassed at how sensitive I am being. I also feel this will change my dynamic with her in the future. Do you think it is something worth asking via message post wedding (eg “what a great wedding! I just wanted to makesure I haven’t upset you without realizing it? i wasn’t sure if not making me a bridesmaid with your other SILS was in any way a reflection on our relationship”. ) Thanks!


10 Comments

Latest activity by Mindy, on March 25, 2023 at 5:11 PM
  • Emily
    Dedicated August 2025
    Emily ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Oh man I’m so sorry! Like you said, it’s obviously her choice at the end of the day but I totally get why you feel hurt. I don’t know how you’d approach that with her though, that would be such an awkward conversation so you’re really in a pickle here. If I were you I’d bring it up in a semi-jokey way, that way it wouldn’t cause as much tension? Maybe that’s bad advice, but that’s probably what I would do! You know better than anyone that you’re going to have to make peace with it, so maybe going about it in a more lighthearted way would help set the tone for the conversation and in turn, your relationship going forward
    • Reply
  • C
    CM ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    How long ago did she ask the others? ? Any chance you are jumping to conclusions and she’s waiting to ask you in person? If not, it does seem odd considering the circumstances, especially given that (too) many couples seem to believe sides should be even and with you included it would be.


    Is it possible she has a friend in mind and refuses to have uneven sides, she intends to give you a reading, or is looking at it from the unfortunate perspective of who can afford to host the best parties? Does she think she’s doing you a favor due to unreasonable expectations on her end?
    There are endless possibilities, most of which are not a particularly good look for her. Unfortunately, there’s really not a polite way for you to ask, but if H is close to his sister I don’t think it would be too out of line for him to tactfully ask her if everything is OK .
    • Reply
  • M
    Mindy ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Thank you so much! I agree it be so awkward (although a healthy assertive way to communicate) but I’d doubt I’d end up doing it. Humour is always helpful so not bad advice! 🙂
    • Reply
  • M
    Mindy ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Thanks so much CM! I have no idea how long ago she asked the others—but when I saw her last (1 Month ago) she said they weren’t even doing wedding parties. I also wondered if I was being hasty- except it is odd — her fiance in his message to my hubby stated he planned to ask in person last weekend, but the event we were all supposed to attend got cancelled. So she knows I know about my husband being asked, we also have no upcoming plans where I’d see her. This is not an extravagant wedding and she is not the type to even care about even sided numbered parties, so I really don’t get it..it literally costs me nothing to be a bridesmaid because of the nature of the event. I’ve been told i’m taking it too personally, my head gets that but not my heart! Thank you for understanding! I doubt my H will end up asking her anything
    • Reply
  • C
    CM ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    Reading again, it looks like you had to be an actual sibling of one of them to be included in the wedding party. I think that may be why he specifically said a "family affair." To me that's a strange and arbitrary line since you are still talking about future sibling in laws on both sides.

    Are the sisters (his and hers) married? If so, I think the reasoning was the groom wanted his three friends and your husband (the bride's brother) but not three additional future brother-in-laws without blood ties. It's even possible the bride would have greatly preferred you, but felt it would cause hurt feelings on the other side.

    • Reply
  • Jacks
    Rockstar November 2054
    Jacks ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    I was thinking this too as I read the post. I wonder if she's placating her FI family or hoping to get closer to them during the wedding planning.

    I do understand that you're taken aback, but it's ok to still be excited and supportive of the wedding, despite the apparently arbitrary lines they've picked.

    • Reply
  • Natalie
    Super November 2020
    Natalie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    You mentioned there was an event you and your husband were supposed to be going to that got cancelled, and that’s when he was going to be asked. Do you think maybe you were going to be asked at that event too?
    • Reply
  • M
    Mindy ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Hello thanks for replying! Its possible for sure, I just think she would likely have asked by now-we aren’t scheduled to see each other again anytime shortly, and the wedding is 2 months away. Also not sure why her fiance would send a message and she wait in person but who knows!
    • Reply
  • M
    Mindy ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Thanks for understanding CM! It seems others are telling me i’m taking things too personally and reinforcing how much it’s bride choice-which I totally understand. I didn’t even think of that re “family affair” comment, so thanks for that! So to clarify-one of the grooms sisters’ is an adolescent (not married)- his other sister is married. I do not know whether his brother in law is one of the “three buddies” he mentioned (i kinda hope not, or else it would make this situation even more hurtful and odd). I know i wl accept and it is what it is, just my heart is taking longer than my head!
    • Reply
  • M
    Mindy ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Yes I completely believe that including them is an attempt to strengthen and improve their relationship, especially since it seems she’s had conflict and tension with one of the groom’s sisters. Yes i of course am still supportive of the wedding and the event, I will process and move on from my feelings. Thanks so much for replying!
    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×

Related articles

WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Learn more

Groups

WeddingWire article topics