Dedicated September 2017

Sam's Club CAKES!

Bailey, on July 29, 2017 at 6:45 AM Posted in Planning

Anyone here ordered their cake from Sam's Club??

They're so cheap and neither of us care for cake or icing lol

Good experiences?

Pros? Cons?



  • redhead06
    Devoted September 2018
    redhead06 ·

    We bought my son's first birthday from sam's.. it was lop sided and cheap.. didn't care because it was a smash cake but still...

  • Mary C
    Super November 2018
    Mary C ·

    Not sure where you are located. I'm in Florida. Haven't had Sam's cakes. Wal-Mart cakes are terrible compared to Publix cakes. I would suggest you try their smaller cakes or cupcakes as a tasting before buying.

  • Celia Milton
    Celia Milton ·

    Maybe you don't care for cake but other people at your wedding do. Don't do a cheap ugly birthday cake.

  • Marion
    Super October 2018
    Marion ·

    I looked into a cake there because it was so cheap for a 3 tier. Then I realized that they serve half the number of people a normal 3 tier would. So I think them must be much smaller.

  • TwistedPrincess
    Super May 2018
    TwistedPrincess ·

    I do not like Wal-Mart cake and Sam's owns Wal-Mart so I shy away from them. My sister used costco sheet cakes with the creme filling and they were amazing, I actually think we're going that route.

  • karen
    VIP October 2017
    karen ·

    I think Publix cakes are really yummy. I think one option is to get a smaller attractive cake for display, cutting, and have a nice sheet or two from publix in the kitchen.

  • S
    Devoted August 2017
    Shelena ·

    Sams has THE best cake to me..... I didn't order my wedding cake from there but that's the best

  • Celia Milton
    Celia Milton ·

    The concept behind having a cake at all is that everyone shares your cake with you. Don't feed them ugly 'cut in the kitchen' cake. For starters, it will look nothing like the nice cake you're having.

  • S
    Devoted August 2017
    Shelena ·

    Walmart cake I dislike and it has a different taste than sams

  • Jay Farrell
    Jay Farrell ·

    Why support the evil empire?

  • Jennifer
    Devoted August 2017
    Jennifer ·

    I actually ordered my wedding cake from Publix.

  • 033118
    Super March 2018
    033118 ·

    @Celia you are so right!

  • N
    Master December 2016
    Nancy ·

    No Publix in California.

  • M
    Dedicated October 2018
    Margo ·

    Wal-Mart cakes are awful! Sam's club is the same. Stay AWAY

  • Isabella
    Beginner June 2018
    Isabella ·

    Not sure about Sams club, but Costco cakes are cheap as well and very yummy! Great quality and fancy.

  • Talullah
    VIP May 2018
    Talullah ·

    I think Sam's has great cakes! (at least the one by me).

  • 24kMagicWed
    VIP May 2017
    24kMagicWed ·

    My SIL ordered a 3 tier for an event and it collapsed. I don't recommend it.

  • Cass
    VIP August 2017
    Cass ·

    If you wanted to go a cheap route I'd do publix. They have great cake for it being so cheap! They were at a bridal show I went to and have a few cake "designs" to choose from. They are generic, but look fine and taste good!

  • Francesca
    Devoted September 2018
    Francesca ·

    Publix is better

  • Mrs. Sitz
    Master July 2016
    Mrs. Sitz ·

    I dislike Sam's club bakery anything. However, check with your local grocery stores & ask for a tasting appointment. I ordered the cake for my first marriage from a grocery store. The price was very reasonable, the cake was delicious & they did an awesome job! They delivered too! No matter where you buy a cake, ask to see pictures of their work!

Comment on this discussion