Overstock.com Rings?

They have beautiful jewelry. I ordered some home decor stuff and a ring a few years ago. They were all true to description (the ring was just as pretty as the pic) and I don't remember them taking a long time to deliver. So, when I think of Overstock, I think of "good experience". Hope that helps.

Just be sure to really read the return policy (I didn't need it, so I don't remember it). But with something that has the longevity of a wedding band, you're going to want to be sure that you can return it if it isn't what you thought it was going to be.

I've ordered jewelry from Overstock in the past (only earrings) and it's always been true to description. I ordered some sapphire stud earrings for my BM's and they're beautiful. Centerpiece makes a good point about the return policy though. That's something I need to take into consideration as I was also considering buying FH's band from there.

I have jewelry from there and my sister and BIL got their wedding bands from there as well. I always filter the results by the reviews. I don't buy anything that has fewer than 4 stars and there has to be a substantial number of reviews, not just a few.

My bridal set of rings is from overstock.com. We opted to get the protection plan, and to this point have not had any issues. Honestly, I feel that the set was even prettier in person than it was online. The rings arrived within a week. I did have the shipper send me notifications along the way, because I was terrified they'd end up in someone else's mailbox, but in the end we had no issues.

We're planning getting my wedding band from overstock for the time being. Much easier on the wallet, and we figured we can always upgrade it later, so I'm not too concerned about longevity. Just make sure you find one that has good/legit reviews.

We always get the protection plan when ordering from overstock.com but the jewelry is true to description. Beautiful jewelry. I'd recommend it

Thanks so much everyone! I will definitely continue to look through the site.