Okay-- well aware I'm going to get made fun of for this one. FH and I LOVE Michael Bolton irrationally (whatever, I'm aware we're the only ones). Like, listened to his audio book on a vacation and saw him in concert last year (youngest ones in the audience). FH was a child actor/singer (Chip in Beauty & the Beast on Broadway in the mid-1990s) and used to win karaoke contests with Michael Bolton songs. I don't sing, but "How Can We Be Lovers" is still my go-to karaoke song.
Anyway, I'm leaning towards "Now that I Found You" as a wedding song, but FH (as much as he loves it) is convinced that not enough people know it. I think our friends get the joke (even though it's not really a joke). Yes, I'm aware it's super cheesy, but I still love it. What do you guys think?
Also, FH's entire family drives Hondas. Just saying.
ETA: FH had an 80s radio show throughout college and as a community volunteer until last year. Yes, I know NTIFY is from 1991, but it still fits us.