If you’re going for a natural look, all of these colors are pretty dark (definitely darker in person than in that app). I would try to go to Ulta, you can’t sample products but at least you can see through the tube the actual color. You could also buy a lip sample set that has a few colors to try out.
I'm all for the 1st and 3rd one. Although, as one who has just spent $100s on lipstick for much of the same reasons - despite the app, I'd buy the color and try in person. I thank one of the members here who turned me onto Kiko for the long-lasting, kiss proof lipstick and NON bleeding (The color I'm ultimately going with is Sangria, not too red, but not too nude)...
As for makeup remover... Ulta's eye and lipstick remover is the absolute bomb! No problems on removing the lipstick.
I love the 1st one! Seems like a lot of brides tend to go for the more natural looks for wedding makeup, but you don’t have to! Also may I recommend too faced melted liquid lipstick! It lasts all day and is pretty much transfer proof! Literally can eat, drink, fall asleep in it and it’s the same haha. Seal it with Charlotte tillburry’s setting spray and it’s 100% transfer proof. I got the mini holiday collection and there are 4 shades you can try for $25 including a red. There’s also more of a ruby red, a nude color, and a orangey color. 100% would recommend! I was going to do a nude color until I found those!