I have 5 girls in my BP. My FH has 4 guys. He has 3 sisters. In my family, its expected to have future sibling-in-laws in the BP regardless of how close you are, to show respect to the new family, but 3? I asked my FH to talk to the 3 sisters and scope out how they felt. See if 1 wanted to "represent" his side. Long story, all 3 are in the wedding party. Now 8 girls? I asked FH if he had any more guys he would like to ask to add to his 4 or suggested he ask some of my guy cousins whom I'm close with. He said no because he only wanted his closest pals with him that day. I guess I can see where he's coming from. I feel the same about his sisters as he does my cousins. It's not that I don't like them, we're just not close. There's a big age gap, etc. So, Groomsmaids? (Continued in comments...)