Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

J
Just Said Yes July 2020

Getting Out of Control?

Jacob, on September 14, 2020 at 10:41 PM Posted in Planning 0 11

Hello everyone,

I am recently engaged, and we are looking at a summer 2021 wedding in Denver. We would like to do a Sunday. We had been together for four years and have lived together the past two. One of my hesitations in getting engaged was that the wedding would get out of control. I do not want a big wedding, and I always thought secretly that she did. We are both 40 years old and getting married for the first time. She comforted me, and said that she would keep my fears in mind and that we could have a really nice wedding without it getting out of control. I come from a small town with blue-collar (and wonderful) family. She comes from the city with wealthy parents that are attorneys. She is also Jewish, and I am Christian. This is the first wedding for her mom (her two sisters never married), and I was afraid it would get out of control and too big. They have unending financial resources, and I think want a big fancy wedding. I told my fiancee many times that I had this fear. I want my family to feel comfortable at the wedding too. I didn't want a big wedding and would have been just fine with family and 10-20 friends, but I knew this was important to her so I backed off. We talked about around 100 total people at the wedding. I have a small family, and since I have only been in the area for a few years, I do not have a large group of friends that I would invite. I thought I would maybe have 20-25 friends and family attend. I told her I thought it could make my family uncomfortable if her guests were 3 or 4 times the number of mine. It was also important to me that we honor both of our faiths in the wedding, but it was important to her to have a rabbi officiate which was ok with me.

Fast forward to our engagement, which was really nice. Both of our parents were very excited and happy. Then, just two days after the engagement, she tells me that "Oh, I emailed my mom a list of venues". I was under the impression that we would look at venues together and discuss, again because I wanted to be sure it wasn't over the top and so my family would feel comfortable. I see the list and it is all high-end $100 per guest-plus places, Four Seasons Hotel, etc. Again, one of my fears. Then a couple of days after that she tells me that her mom has forty of HER friends flying in to Denver for the wedding. She had called all of them the day after our engagement and invited them. What happened to 100? And, my fiancee has probably 40-50 friends that she will invite. So, now I worry that my guests will be dwarfed by her number of guests. I just love my family and I want them to feel comfortable. Is it asking too much for me to want a wedding where my family will fit in?

We are supposed to look at venues this weekend then set a date once we find one. Am I crazy for feeling as if my fears are coming true? I had a feeling this would happen and I repeatedly told my fiancee prior to our engagement that this was a fear I had. I also wanted us to pay for some of the things, as we have the financial resources to do so. She keeps imply that her parents want to, and her parents have no limit to what they will spend. I am afraid that once things get going with the planning, they will start paying for this high-priced things and it will turn in to "well, they're paying for it." We have money, but we cannot afford a $150 per guest reception. But her parents can... And, I think since they're bringing so many of THEIR friends in, they'll want to spend big $$$ to impress...

Any advice, and has anyone else encountered this? I love my fiancee and we have so much in common, we just come from completely different backgrounds. So far, I have been really disappointed that she hasn't respected my wishes at all. She says, "I have envisioned this for years." Am I asking too much for things to be a little more down to earth so my family and friends feel comfortable? Thank you all in advance.

11 Comments

Latest activity by Laquita, on September 15, 2020 at 4:24 PM
  • H
    Master July 2019
    Hannah ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    You and your fiance need to sit down and discuss your visions for the wedding and come to a compromise that will make both of you happy. Discuss budget, venue, time of year, size, etc. It is you and her getting married, not her and her mom. When I was planning my wedding, my now husband and I made sure we were planning the wedding that we wanted and would not book a vendor unless both of us agreed on that decision.
    • Reply
  • mrswinteriscoming
    VIP December 2021
    mrswinteriscoming ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    You and your fiancée have two different ideas of what your wedding should be. You want something small and low-key, she is now envisioning a big white wedding with all the trims. I think you need to talk to your fiancée and both verbalise what your non-negotiables are with the wedding; set the middle ground that you can both agree on.

    I am in a *slightly* similar boat to your fiancée. I come from a big, loud, Jewish-Russian family who go all out for special occasions like this. We have about 120 invited on my side, and 30 on my humble Australian fiancee’s side. On this occasion, my fiancée doesn’t care much about the planning, he wants me to do whatever I need to make the day special, but here, you have an opinion that you clearly want to voice. I don’t think that either of you should miss out on the day of your dreams, but you definitely need to talk things over and find your compromise.

    For example, I don’t think she should be required to cut her guest list purely because she will have more guests than your side (imho). Perhaps as a trade off, you can decide the location and she can invite whoever she wants. (This is just a suggestion).

    The other thing is, if her parents want to contribute, I think you both need to lay down the law (no pun intended) that if they want to contribute, it does NOT give them an entitlement to dictate how the money will be spent. It is their daughter’s (and your) wedding, if they want to contribute, that is fine, but they cannot use it to orchestrate a wedding of their choosing.

    • Reply
  • A
    Super September 2020
    Alli ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Eeks... you definitely need to be on the same page! It’s important for the big day vision to be on one accord. Best wishes.
    • Reply
  • Mcskipper
    Rockstar July 2018
    Mcskipper ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    This is an odd semantic thing but I want to suggest reframing the way you’re talking about this with her. You keep saying you’ve said what you fear it becoming. I think you should be more specific . This isn’t about what you fear, it’s about what you WANT. You WANT a more intimate wedding. I think you have to be kind of direct. This is about both of your wants. You’ll likely both have to compromise some. But you both have to sit down and find the common ground of what you want and don’t want— because it is both of your day. You both need to figure out what each of your individual priorities are and how they can work together.


    For what it’s worth, an uneven guestlist doesn’t have to mean anyone should feel dwarfed. I have a huge family and my husband’s is very small. But we were able to plan and arrange so that everyone was comfortable and all guests felt equally welcomed and important. But this does come from planning. It’s important to be vocal about what you want. And what your fiancée wants. It’s a good way to approach the conversation. “I want to make sure we do what is important to you, but I also want to make sure we do what is important to me. Here are my priorities ___ . How can we make ours work together ?”
    • Reply
  • Yasmine
    Master October 2020
    Yasmine ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    If they are paying for the wedding then I don’t see a problem with them inviting people. However I would sit down and have a talk with my fiancé because it’s you guys wedding.


    It seems like her parents are very excited and living through you guys wedding which is okay, but at the end of the day you two can make the final decision not her!
    • Reply
  • Jai
    VIP May 2020
    Jai ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Sit down and talk with her about how you feel
    Because you guys should compromise since it's both your wedding. Even make a list of what's important to you and what's important to her
    • Reply
  • Mrs. Spring
    Master April 2021
    Mrs. Spring ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Woah I am so sorry. I agree that your wishes are being disrespected and dismissed. I don't think sitting her down and talking will work bc you've talked to her several times already. Is it possible you could have two celebrations? One with her friends and family that is lavish? And then another one that is a microwedding and lowkey with your friends and family?
    • Reply
  • Krista
    Dedicated April 2020
    Krista ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I am so sorry! Wedding planning can definitely get out of hand, especially the more people involved. As far as a lopsided guest count I think if her family (actual family) is large than ok, but inviting her parents friends sounds a little rough. I wouldn’t want my wedding to be a day that strangers critique. I think a common rule is if you haven’t seen or spoken in a year then cut. I also wouldn’t take money from her parents at all, but maybe a compromise is her parents buy a dress and maybe host a fancy bridal shower in her hometown. It’s going to be about compromise and your feeling matter too! Best wishes
    • Reply
  • Meghan
    Master October 2019
    Meghan ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I think the best thing to do is sit down and have a very serious, heart-to-heart conversation about this. Let her know exactly how you are feeling. I would suggest the option of you and your fiancee paying for the entire wedding yourselves. This eliminates the 40 guests her mother wants to invite. When you take 100% financial responsibility of your wedding, you and your fiancee get to make all of the calls. Not her parents. You can both have your dream weddings on a budget that works for you two.

    • Reply
  • Molly
    VIP September 2020
    Molly ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I just got married this month and my husband was worried about not having many people from his side at the wedding. 8 out of 50 of our guests where form his side. He has a very small family. All of his guest had a great time and did not fell over shadowed or over whelmed by the number of guest from my side.

    • Reply
  • Laquita
    Expert July 2021
    Laquita ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I'm in the camp where I feel like just because parents are helping to pay for things, doesn't mean they can invite whomever they want. It's still not their wedding & as parents, they're only supporting their child. That's all. Paying=/=getting to make major decisions.

    Since you and your fiance come from two very different backgrounds, her opinion on what's small/modest is far different from yours especially since her family is wealthy. You also have to take into account the fact that she's their only daughter to get married so her mom may just be overly excited. What you need to do is have a sit down with just the two of you, not her mom or dad or whoever....JUST YOU TWO. You need to discuss a budget & list what you both want in a wedding, things that neither of you will budge on & things you can compromise on. You keep saying you have this fear of a the wedding becoming too big, but it's just your personal preference....you'd rather keep it modest & you need to tell her that. Just like it's her day, it's also your day & you want to be involved in the planning. Let her know that while you're happy her family is so involved, you'd appreciate it if you guys made major decisions like the venue & vendors together before telling her parents.

    My FH also doesn't want anything too large & as I have more immediate family than he does, I'm scaling my list back because that's what he's expressed to me. As much as I would love to have a lot of my family there, it's not feasible & I respect his opinions on this.

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×

Related articles

WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Learn more

Groups

WeddingWire article topics