Has anyone else had trouble finding the right ring size?? I went to the Castle and they sized me as a 4 but the worker gave me a size 5 ring to try on and said my fingers would swell anyways and if I didn't like a 5 we could always get it resized. We loved the ring and decided to go with it. However, after getting home with the 5, I realized it was not going to work as is it was sliding off my finger. We went back the next day and asked to have it resized to a 4.5. Another worker sized my finger and said she thought 4.5 was too loose and that I would want my ring to be tight so I should go with a 4. I expressed that I felt a 4.5 was a better fit but she convinced me to go with a 4! Now, after we picked the ring with a size 4 I feel that its WAY too tight and that I should have went with a 4.5. I can slide the ring on easily and off with a little resistance but it is hurting my finger to wear the ring and tingles after I take it off. Everyone keeps telling me I just need to get used to it first.
What should I do? I am considering going back and asking them to resize it to a 4.5 but I want to be sure before I do. We have to pay every time we resize and I don't wanna be without my ring for that long! But at this point, I am not even able to enjoy wearing it.