Engagement Rings

View Quoted Comment He likes “whatever I like” which is incredibly frustrating xD.

View Quoted Comment You definitely don’t want a ring that can’t be sized down to your true size! Trust me, I’m actually a 4.5 too and I used to have a ring that was a size 5 and it was SO ANNOYING. Always worried it would slip off, and always spinning around on my finger.
This is good, the decision can be made for you based on that alone 😂 go with #4. Does the website allow you to order in half-sizes? If not, order it in a size 5 and bring it to a reputable jeweler and have them size it down to a 4.5 (it’s easier for a jeweler to make it smaller than to make it bigger) but definitely make sure it’s a ring that is meant to go that small. If you get one of the others, you’re either stuck with a ring that’s too big, or you could damage the integrity of the ring by sizing it smaller than it’s meant to go

View Quoted Comment Oh that doesn't help! Maybe try to narrow it down to 2 designs maybe making him pick between fewer options will help him by only giving him limited choices lol.

My advice would be to go to a jewelry store and find ones that are similar (pretty sure you can find these styles at a major retailer like Kay or Zales), and try them on. Only you can make the right decision for yourself.

I love number 4!!

If you want my opinion
#3, then #1
I'd say narrow it down to if you want white gold or rose gold and go from there.

I'd recommend going to a jeweler and trying similar rings on. You make one shape more on your finger than another. Another option is to show him what you like and have him make the decision! These are all beautiful, you can't go wrong with any of them. I do know the 3rd one pictured is definitely at Kay jewelers, or something very similar because a friend of mine has that ring.

View Quoted Comment They’re all from Zales. I’ve gone in before (3 times if I go in a 4th they might think I’m crazy xD). And I like all of the shapes on my finger so it’s a toss up. They’re all available in both metals as well. It’s a tough choice.

I personally like the 1st one plus I like rose gold! You decide... don’t let any of us sway your decision making let it speak to you from the heart ❤️ that may sound silly ... but out of the 4 which one speaks to you! Lol best wishes

My favorite one is the third one.

Why don’t you let him decide from here😊

They're all beautiful! Maybe let your FH decide?

Personally, #1 is a knock out!

I’m partial to the pear!!!

rings

I decided to go with the 1st ring in white gold

View Quoted Comment

It's beautiful!

I think you should let him pick.. Whichever one he thinks is nice between all these rings but you won't find out which one until he gives it to you. That way it's interesting

I love the 3rd😊

I like the fourth the best! So feminine and pretty.


I would show him these four specifically and ask him which he likes best. One of my favorite things about my ring is that my partner chose it, and loved it so much.

First one!!🤩