Dress decision dilemma

I much prefer the first one on you ... very flattering

I actually like the second one more. The shape and the pattern is lovely

Hi Sarah, and welcome to the WeddingWire community!! Your family and bridal party are both right: you look beautiful in both of those dresses!! But if I had to choose one, I would have to go with the floor-length one. It's classic and I love how the shoulder straps lay! I'd be really interested in seeing the back of it if you have any pictures!

Just remember: in the end, you're the one wearing the wedding dress, so whichever one makes you feel the best is the one you should choose Have you thought about any jewelry or accessories you might want to wear?

I prefer the first one, it's so flattering on you!

I like the first one better it is more unique and the back is beautiful.

I like the second one more maybe without the straps? I totally bought that same sash in the first picture. Love it!

You look beautiful in both, but the first one looks amazing on you!!!

I prefer the second one better. Both look beautiful on you, but the first one kind of shortens you and the second one gives you long lines

If you go with the first, we will be dress twins! That’s the dress I picked as well. 😊💖

I do think both are beautiful in their own ways, but if I had to choose one I do like the floor-length. I am partial to the elegant styles though

I like the second one on you better. For some reason when I saw the first one on you it reminded me of a flower girl's dress - maybe it is the sash and the way it is tied in a bow in the back.

The second is really pretty but the first one makes me think wow!

I like the second one more. It looks more grown up, for lack of a better term. It flatters you more than the first.

I like the second one more!

I love the second dress on you!

I prefer the second. Not sure how you feel about strapless, but have you tried it without the straps? I think without the straps it will elongate your figure even more. But it’s still a elegant, classic look either way. Agree that the first looks more like a flower girl dress.

They are both beautiful dresses! I think the first dress has beautiful back detail and flatters your figure so much! Love the buttons down the back! It would help to get the whole picture if we could see you wearing a pair of shoes you would walk down the isle with. With shorter dresses the dress is only part of the equation.
the second dress does give you beautiful long lines but I keep getting hung up on the straps. They look a little awkward and uncomfortable, strapless may be a way to go. The thing I like about the first dress so much is that it accentuated you waist! Maybe try a belt on the longer dress and see how you feel.

I love that first one on you, but they are both beautiful!

The first one I feel compliments your body perfectly! Good luck and let us know which one you choose :-)