Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Disney Bride2020
Dedicated September 2020

Concerned about photography contract

Disney Bride2020, on June 19, 2018 at 8:11 AM

Posted in Planning 40

So we have a contract and I am concerned there is this clause saying I should not write a bad review if the photographer does not provide service up to my expectations, below is what is in the contract, does this sound right? she is a professional from wedding wire NEGATIVE FEEDBACK PHOTOGRAPHER...


So we have a contract and I am concerned there is this clause saying I should not write a bad review if the photographer does not provide service up to my expectations, below is what is in the contract, does this sound right? she is a professional from wedding wire


NEGATIVE FEEDBACK

PHOTOGRAPHER has a stellar reputation. If for some reason you are unsatisfied with your service, PLEASE do not resort to bad reviews on websites, blogs, Facebook, etc. Please make sure the photographer is aware of your opinions, and I will do my very best to make sure that the end result is your satisfaction. No refunds will be given, nor will bride be reimbursed for any wedding expenses.





40 Comments

  • Munchkin9218
    Master September 2018
    Munchkin9218 ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    She's not outright infringing. The way it reads IN CONTEXT, because context is important, that you violate the clause if you don't give her a chance to satisfy you before leaving a review about dissatisfaction. And a negative review and an honest review are two different things, you can honestly speak about an experience without being negative or bad mouthing.


    At the end of the day it comes down to - THe photographer has chosen to write her contract this way to protect herself. If you have seen the work, trust them, and feel confident in your choice then it shouldn't matter that much that they want tp protect herself this way. Personally, if I had any inkling or anticipation I might need to leave a bad review I wouldn't want to work with that person whether they had the clause or not. So to me - thats the question OP needs to decide. Not if its okay to have the clause at all.

    • Reply
  • PBiazinha
    VIP May 2018
    PBiazinha ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    I agree with this. It would absolutely raise a red flag to me.

    • Reply
  • M
    Devoted September 2020
    Mona ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I would not sign a contract like this. I have a few issues with her "demands". If three brides before you had an issue... how would you know??? According to her forced positive reviews... you won't even know if she showed up late. Which in my opinion, is not a negative review... but would be a fact, if that happened. Second, her opinion of "negative" may not be your view of negative. Lastly, and MOST important... HOW can you fix or resolve an issue AFTER the wedding?? If she's late... she stays longer? If you don't like the shot... she photoshop the pics?? How do you fix it after...???
    • Reply
  • FutureMrsKC
    Master January 2019
    FutureMrsKC ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Sounds like she just wants you to tell her your issues so she can try to make them right before you bad mouth her on social media.

    • Reply
  • Kiersten
    Expert February 2018
    Kiersten ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    I'm right there with you. A clause like this would raise so, so many red flags for me.
    • Reply
  • Mcskipper
    Master July 2018
    Mcskipper ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Well, my main concern here is that her reviews are now, from my perspective, completely unreliable. Of course they’re good— they have to be. That would definitely make me anxious.

    My other concern is that this contract leaves you absolutely no recourse if you are unsatisfied with your pictures. Sure she will try to “make you happy” but she also says she will give no refund, so the ball is in her court. Is the best she’ll do offering a reshoot? If it went really badly the first time around, you might not even want that. So then you’re stuck. No refund. No bad review. Bad experience.

    THAT said, contract language is negotiable. She has clauses to protect herself, but the contract should protect you too— if there’s something you’re concerned about, address it, maybe add a word. For example this contextual ‘before’ subthread in this post. Let’s be clear: it absolutely does not say “before” and in a contract, language is everything. Personal interpretation due to presumed context will not hold up in court. So, if you’re concerned, be precise and add the word. I wouldn’t sign the contract as is but if I could change a couple words, I might. Clarity is key, and you should always be able to negotiate to add clarification. If you can’t— if she steadfastly won’t add the word “before” I would definitely be concerned.

    But, like I said, to me my concern is less with the wording itself than the fat that to me, this undermines her “stellar” reviews, since no one can leave negative ones. I’d just encourage going back and scouring existing reviews for details to make sure you feel very secure in their sincerity, and any details that might have subtle complaint snuck in there.

    In general I don’t think it’s a bad thing to offer resolution before negative reviewing— that’s how it should work although it definitely doesn’t always and some reviews are very emotionally motivated. But this specific language definitely rubs me the wrong way.

    • Reply
  • Allie
    Super September 2018
    Allie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    That sounds like to me, to give them the chance to fix it BEFORE you go bad mouth them on social.. which would probably work in your favor, they are willing to do anything possible before you ruin their rep..

    • Reply
  • Rachel Langerhans
    Expert October 2015
    Rachel Langerhans ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I'm a photographer and I do find that a bit odd to put that in a contract. I think what the photographer is probably hoping for is that clients will go to him/her with any concerns or disappointments before badmouthing or writing negative reviews. We all hope that; however, I've never heard of that being expressly added to a contract before. I wouldn't worry too much though, since he/she also says in the contract they will try to resolve any problems for you to the best of his/her ability.

    • Reply
  • Going to the chapel
    Master July 2017
    Going to the chapel ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Under the Consumer Review Fairness Act, contracts can not prohibit honest, negative reviews. Sounds like your photographer is trying to skirt the law because most couples don't have a legal background and might take her language to say that they can't leave a negative review. She doesn't prohibit a negative review, but it could be read that way by those unfamiliar with the law.

    • Reply
  • SRD
    Devoted June 2019
    SRD ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    I also agree. People will do this a lot. They have a bad experience with a person or company and before trying to resolve it with the company or person, they run to social media first. You will be surprised how much can be resolved if you talk to the company or person first. But if they do not resolve anything then I guess social media it is.
    • Reply
  • Shaunte
    Expert December 2021
    Shaunte ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    While I understand she is trying to protect her business, it is unrealistic to ask people to not leave negative reviews if the product is poor. Further, the word "before" doesn't appear in the clause so I'm assuming she could theoretically sue you for breach of contract if you leave a bad review before or after you speak with her about your concerns. This clause likely would not be upheld in court.

    I'm more concerned with this clause:

    SATISFACTION WITH PRESENTED IMAGES

    Should the couple decide that they are dissatisfied with the overall quality of the photographer’s work, the photographer (PHOTOGRAPHER Photography) cannot be held legally responsible. That is, no civil or criminal legal action (i.e. Claims of negligence) may be made to recoup payments made to PHOTOGRAPHER Photography.

    She's saying you can't sue her if you are dissatisfied with the quality of work. She also doesn't offer an alternative dispute resolution (mediation, arbitration, etc.) either. Essentially, once you pay her that's it. You generally can't sign away your right to sue (there are exceptions to everything). Not sure this contract would hold up in court.

    • Reply
  • thyia
    Super August 2018
    thyia ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    It sounds like she has dealt with some difficult people in the past. Contacts always bring out the salty side. Do you want to post a negative review?
    • Reply
  • Rachel Langerhans
    Expert October 2015
    Rachel Langerhans ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    After re-reading the statement and seeing it doesn't specify leaving the review before or after talking with her, it does sound like she's trying to hinder you leaving a negative review at any time (even if you talked with her about issues first). The no refunds given part is also a little touchy. As a photographer, she'll obviously have a lot of backup equipment and likely nothing will fail. But if a catastrophe did happen and her equipment failed and the second half of the photos from the wedding day were ALL blurry and therefore you were a dissatisfied customer, would she still not refund you anything (because the contract says no refunds)?


    As a photographer and someone in the customer service industry, I understand wanting to protect yourself and needing thorough contracts. That section does rub me the wrong way, but as others have said, if this gives you a bad feeling, I'd go with someone else. She's probably just trying to protect herself and her business, but it ultimately comes down to how comfortable you are with the terms. Talk with her more about the contract and any questions you have and decide from there.

    • Reply
  • Happy Hedgie
    VIP September 2018
    Happy Hedgie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I don't actually have an issue with the original clause you posted. Its not prohibiting you from leaving a bad review it just asks that you not do that without discussing with her first.

    I do see two major red flags though.

    Unforeseen circumstances clause

    If PHOTOGRAPHER or its assistants, cannot perform this agreement due to a fire, casualty, strike or other civil disturbances, Acts of God, including but not limited to, road closures, severe traffic, fire, terrorism or other causes beyond the control of the parties, or due to the photographer's illness, then PHOTOGRAPHER shall return any moneys paid by the client, less expenses, but shall have no further liability with respect to the agreement.

    This limitation of liability shall also apply in the event that photographic materials are damaged in processing, lost through camera malfunction, compact flash card malfunction, lost in the mail, or otherwise lost or damaged without the fault on the part of PHOTOGRAPHER.

    Essentially, if she gets sick on the day of your wedding she can just not show up and while you may get a refund she won't arrange any coverage. (This seems to be a contradiction to another part of her contract which is especially confusing). Also, if anything happens to the equipment or photos you are out of luck. I would fully expect her to have backup equipment and would want the right to my money back (plus extra) if something happened to the photos before delivery.

    SATISFACTION WITH PRESENTED IMAGES

    Should the couple decide that they are dissatisfied with the overall quality of the photographer’s work, the photographer (PHOTOGRAPHER Photography) cannot be held legally responsible. That is, no civil or criminal legal action (i.e. Claims of negligence) may be made to recoup payments made to PHOTOGRAPHER Photography.

    I'm not even sure this clause would be enforceable in court but, I would be extremely wary of removing my right to sue should something go wrong. If it is enforceable this removes your ability to resolve any disputes (especially since she says elsewhere that she won't give any refunds). So, if there is a problem with the photos, you can't get a refund, and you can't sue. It sounds like you will be out of luck and nothing will be resolved.

    I believe you mentioned you have a lawyer in the family right? I'd definitely have them review the contract before signing but, I'd be extremely wary of this photographer and I personally wouldn't sign this contract without major amendments.



    • Reply
  • Gen
    Champion June 2019
    Gen ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I would be nervous about this! I almost worked with a photographer with a similar contract and didn’t sign because of this. Additionally, we found out that if we left a 5 Star review, they would somehow be able to release our photos to us 2 weeks early. It REALLY sounded like they were manipulating people into leaving good reviews and not leaving bad ones, which really made me doubt the legitimacy of every positive review I read!
    • Reply
  • starsinwaves
    VIP November 2018
    starsinwaves ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    I completely agree. Just the language itself completely put me off. Who says in their contract that they have a stellar reputation? That makes me think she would be too full of herself to make any changes if requested. No thanks.

    • Reply
  • MrsD
    Legend July 2019
    MrsD ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I read that as you can write a bad review (if the service is bad), but only after you discuss your problems with her. I assume most people would do that anyway, hoping to find a resolution. I've never seen that in a contract, so it seems like a weird thing to include.

    • Reply
  • Disney Bride2020
    Dedicated September 2020
    Disney Bride2020 ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    UPDATE: After talking it with MY FH and reading all of the comments on here thank you lovely's we both agree that we will be looking elsewhere, I am not a sue happy person and usually never leave a bad review, however The fact that I can't trust her reviews has me concerned and was and is a big red flag, So back to square one with the photos, My venue recommended a photographer who is amazing and am excited to meet with her, Thank you again everyone your insight is appreciated

    • Reply
  • firstoneat56
    Master August 2017
    firstoneat56 ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    So glad you’re looking elsewhere. One thing I will point out for any photographer’s contract- they will always have language that protects their property (your photos) and you shouldn’t be able to profit from them without the written permission of the photographer or at all. However, what a lot of people don’t do is get “in kind” rights. Meaning, the photographer cannot profit from our images or use them for anything other than promotional purposes without our written consent. We negotiated that into our contract.
    • Reply
  • Disney Bride2020
    Dedicated September 2020
    Disney Bride2020 ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    That is a good idea as well, I am supposed to be getting a new contract from a photographer that my venue loves working with the cream of the crop best of the best according to them, so we will see what her contract says, I am thankful I have enough time to figure this out, maybe moving back the wedding to july 2020 was a blessing

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Explore how we embrace diversity

Groups

WeddingWire article topics