Bridesmaids shoes

All the same color is fine. If they’re wearing long dresses, no one is going to see their shoes anyway.

I think it’s always nice to let them pick their own within the color you specify. That way you know everyone is comfortable and purchasing items within their budgets. (Plus, to be honest, none of your guests will be paying attention to your bridesmaids shoes, unless they are wearing short dresses)

Some girls like heels vs flats, or vise versa. Also, if the dresses are really long, they wont be seen much. So to maybe ease your stress, allow them to pick the shoes according to the color you wish, like silver.

I would definitely let the girls pick their own shoes, but in whatever color you would like. I just asked my girls to wear silver shoes. I didn't care what they looked like as long as they were comfortable and the right color. All but one choose to flats.

I let my bridesmaids pick whatever shoe they wanted in "nude". I figured everyone probably already had a pair of nude colored shoes, and if not, they could definitely wear them again if they had to purchase some.

I recommend letting your bridesmaids pick them out.

I didn't want to pay, so I asked them to pick shoes they liked in a color that went with their dress. I think I would have preferred/do prefer nude, but I didn't want to be too demanding. In hindsight I might have asked them to do nude.

All my bridesmaids are wearing the same shoes but I offered to purchase them all. They're doing navy dresses with silver shoes.

Silver sounds really nice for that color dress

My girls had long dresses and I told them to pick their own. I told them as long as the were nude, black, or silver I didn’t care. And honestly I can’t remember what they looked like and you can’t see them in pictures.
Let them pick their own and don’t stress over this.

No one is going to see their shoes so in my opinion I would just let them wear whatever they wanted

No one will see or care what they look like. Just tell them to find a comfy pair of silver shoes. Anytime you pick something out, you need to be prepared to foot the bill.