Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Samie
Just Said Yes July 2022

Bridesmaid will not compromise. i need help.

Samie, on February 14, 2022 at 9:47 PM

Posted in Etiquette and Advice 28

Hi, I am in need of some help. One of my bridesmaids is making me compromise more than she is willing to. I changed the style of the shoe we will all wear because she said she would absolutely not wear the shoes I wanted because she doesn't like them. Also, said it does not matter what shoe we wear...

Hi, I am in need of some help. One of my bridesmaids is making me compromise more than she is willing to. I changed the style of the shoe we will all wear because she said she would absolutely not wear the shoes I wanted because she doesn't like them. Also, said it does not matter what shoe we wear we will be in a long dress. So now I compromised and am giving 6 options of shoes, all different price range and included the shoe style she prefers.

Now we are having dress issues... I am letting everyone pick their own dress from David Bridal, a long, juniper Chiffon dress. This BM went on her own to try on a dress and showed it to me. She wanted a dress that has lace on it. I said directly to her that I would like to see it on her so I can decide because I am not sure the lace look fits what I am wanting. I go shopping with her to try dresses on. She only tries 4 on, is very rude to the stylist, will not let her size her and decides she is done. Also did not put the lace dress on. When we are leaving she finally tells me one dress was nice. I asked if she was still thinking about the lace dress and she said no. She then goes shopping next weekend with my sister (BM)...acts the same way. The following week we have made plans to go to two davids bridals with my other BMs. She cancels on us very last minute for both appointments. After the appointment I texted her saying, "I understand you couldn't make it today, we still have time to go shopping. We can go this week together.... Also, I am going to tell all the BM this but I don't want anyone to get the type of dress with lace on it. I think it will stick out too much with all the other dresses for the look I am wanting. More flow, no lace."

She write back "welp, wish you would have said that sooner." Turns out she went behind my back and bought the lace top dress two weeks ago without telling me and still went dress shopping even after buying the dress. Then I tell her I would like to sit down with her in person the next day.

This is where things get bad. I explain to her how I am not feeling supported and how I already had to compromise on the shoes and I really do not want to compromise on the dress and it upsets me that she lied to me. I ask if she will exchange the dress, (you can do this at davids bridal at no extra cost). My BM response.. "this is the only dress I will wear, this is my money I am spending and I LOVE this dress. I will not change it." She also says... "it's just a dress everyone is still going to be looking at you, you shouldn't care what dress I am wearing when I am spending my own money." After this I was very upset and said I needed time to think.

Before I asked her to be my BM I explained how much a dress, shoes and alterations would cost. My MOH also had a conversation with her too and my BM agreed to being in the wedding. I even offered to help pay for the dress if she needed it. She also just last month told me how excited she was and that she has saved so much money already.

As a bride, I am not feeling supported and I am feeling like nothing will make her happy. She has not had fun with any of the things we have done together so far as a bridal group. She is not going to the bachelorette trip (which I understand because of money). When I asked if she would like to plan something for us to do in town for a little bachelorette celebration night she said no I don't want to do that. I said ok...

I have been friend's with her for over 10 years, we knew each other since HS and were roommates in college. She is also my and my fiancé's roommate for the last 3 years. She needed a place to stay and we had just moved into our house together so we offered her a room. She knows after the wedding she will need to move out. We have been upfront about that.

I am at the point where I can either let her wear the dress (which I am very upset about) or ask if she will just come as a guest. I am worried if I let her wear the dress there will just be another issue that comes up. I am trying to be accommodating and understanding but she is not willing to compromise at all. I also wish she never lied to me.

At this point I feel like she is wanting me to kick her out of the wedding party.

28 Comments

  • Michelle
    Champion December 2022
    Michelle ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Agree. If you ask her to step down because she is unsupportive, you are ending the friendship, so be aware of that. Also, unless the dresses are short, the shoe choice doesn’t matter.


    But the only requirement that a bridesmaid has is purchasing a dress you choose and showing up on time on the wedding day to support you and have fun at the reception. None of the other duties are required.
    • Reply
  • Samie
    Just Said Yes July 2022
    Samie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    I think what I’m most upset about is that she felt the need to hide that she purchased a dress already and still went dress shopping with my sister and lied to us about it needing a dress.

    As for the shoes I thought it would be fun to all wear vans. I wasn’t asking for a crazy heel. My venue is steep to walk down and I wanted everyone to feel comfortable. I am going to be wearing white vans with lace on them and I originally thought it would be fun if all the BM and flower girls were in black/white vans. She only wanted me to change the idea because she hates vans and wants to wear converse… so I said ok and change the idea and now all I’m asking for us to wear black shoes.
    • Reply
  • Jacks
    Champion November 2054
    Jacks ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    To require someone to purchase a specific shoe like vans is above what is expected though. If it's that important to you then you would need to buy the shoes.

    • Reply
  • Samie
    Just Said Yes July 2022
    Samie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Iv been to a lot of weddings where they all wore the same shoe even in the long dresses but I understood and adjusted and gave a lot of options where one shoe is $15 so I feel like I was very open about that.
    • Reply
  • Jacks
    Champion November 2054
    Jacks ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    If specific shoes are required, it's the responsibility of the wedding couple to cover the cost for it. Same if you're requiring professional hair and makeup.

    The bridesmaids only have to cover the cost of their dresses.

    • Reply
  • Teasha
    Beginner June 2023
    Teasha ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    She’s not being considerate of your feelings, it’s your day, and if she can’t get with the program then “BYE BYE”. I know you may wanted her to be in the wedding party but she’s making it about her when it’s not supposed to be! Don’t accommodate no one that’s not doing it for you. 😘
    • Reply
  • Tina
    Dedicated January 2023
    Tina ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Let me start with wow! I think you are being very understanding and accommodating about what you were looking at as well as your thoughts about things. Unfortunately, your friend seems to be acting out. I do not know her so I can not say for sure. Perhaps there is a deeper issue here and she is using this as a way to possibly get you to kick her out of your wedding. I am having an issue with someone and that thought has crossed my mind. That perhaps they are giving me accuses or reasons behind why they do not want to do something, though I have not asked for anything, her to be my Matron of Honor. She has no responsibility unless she would like to do something. Though recently I have been met with similar situations.

    With that being said this is your wedding. I have stood up at weddings before and worn/done things I didn't want to because it was what the bride wanted. I had to buy cowboy boots which I am not a fan of, sorry for anyone who is, just to wear to the ceremony and be in pictures. The purpose of the role is to support you. It was kind of you to give her more options and think about her finances. If you are feeling like this is an issue and your talk with her did not really resolve anything then it might not be a bad thing to consider asking her to no longer be a part of the bridal party.

    Hope everything gets worked out and you are able to enjoy your wedding!

    Tina

    • Reply
  • tania
    Dedicated February 2022
    tania ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Wow sounds like she is very hurt about something with the wedding. You think she was upset that since you ladies were friends since high school she not the MOH? I'm just asking because my SIL which is also my BM was upset that she wasn't my MOH but we aren't that close. Look it's your wedding you want it a certain way she needs to respect that. If you want her to be part of you party still just have her hiding in the middle of all the photos so they can hide her dress. Shoes is right if it's long no one really gonna see it as long as they are comfy that what i told my ladies. Trust me i was like you i wanted a certain style of the dress and shoes but all my ladies have different sizes so i just came to realize that they have to be comfortable in what they are buying. If she is truly your friend she should understand your concerns and if she continues to give you stress let her come as a guest. My SIL wasn't buying her BM dress for awhile and i told her she is wasting time. If she doesn't find a dress by the time our wedding starts (this Saturday) she will be a guest. She JUST got her dress last weekend. And she didn't have money issues she just showed me that she has no respect for me so unfortunately since she my SIL i gotta put up with her but i don't have to deal with her. With your friend if she is choosing to act up and ruin your friendship than she needs to live with that. Don't stress over the little things with what other causing you because now you know where their heart lays with yours.
    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Explore how we embrace diversity

Groups

WeddingWire article topics