Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

S
Savvy July 2018

Bridesmaid problem

Sarah, on May 15, 2018 at 1:09 PM Posted in Etiquette and Advice 0 21

So, here's what's going on. FH's sister is one of my bridesmaids. I'm not very close to her, but it was pretty much implied that since my brothers are groomsmen (he is actually friends with them) that she will be very upset if she wasn't included, and since she is family, I didn't have an issue with asking her to be a bridesmaid.

Well, here is the thing. Pretty much from the get go of any planning, she always needs to find a way to get attention on her, or she has a reason why it won't work for her, or she knows something that would be better. For example, I asked my girls to just get a gray style cocktail dress that was knee length. She complained that the only dresses that she could find that looked good on her were floor length. Finally her mom talked her into getting a long dress altered. However, when she got it, she made all the attention on her.

Right now the issue is the responsibility of chipping in on the shower and bachelorette party. Because my MOH is from 5 hours out of town, I decided to make it easier on her and only have her drive down here twice (once for the parties and once for the weddings). I also decided to make it easier on my girls by saying that I wanted to have the shower and the bachelorette party in an awesome hotel that used to be a retirement home (so all the rooms are like small apartments, which can fit a lot of people). This is how much it was going to cost the girls to pay for the room.....ready....this is a room for both the bridal shower and the bachelorette party.....$53

Ok, the hotel is local, so not all of the people that are going to the bach party are going to be staying, especially those who are not bridesmaids. But as a bridesmaid she has said that because she isn't planning on staying (she's the only one who is not) she doesn't think she should have to pay the $53.

The other girls are doing everything in their power to get her to understand that this isn't for her to stay, this is party of her duty. Now they are working on the food and decor for the parties and they have all agreed to split the cost evenly, except for her. She is MIA. No one has heard from her since that conversation about the $53. She has complained to her mom about how it's not fair that she is expected to pay that, her mom think's she is crazy.


Ok, sorry for the long rant type backstory. Question is, I can't necessarily ask her to no longer be a bridesmaid. I mean she is family, and I view asking someone to step down from such role as pretty much saying you want to cancel whatever relationship you have with that person. But to me, it seems as if she wants all the honor of being a bridesmaid without any of the responsibility. I'm really just at a loss of how to deal with this. I'm afraid that she is just going to basically "ghost" us until it's time for things to happen then show up as if she is just as responsible as everyone else.

21 Comments

Latest activity by FutureMrs.L, on May 15, 2018 at 4:05 PM
  • LB
    Champion November 2016
    LB ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Did she offer to contribute to the party? If not, she is in no way obligated to just because she is your BM....

    The only responsibility she has is to get the dress (which she did) and show up the day of the wedding to stand next to you.

    • Reply
  • FutureMrs.L
    Master September 2018
    FutureMrs.L ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I wouldn’t want to pay for a hotel room I’m not staying in... why should she have to?

    If she offered, that’s one thing. She shouldn’t be forced or shamed into paying if she doesn’t want to.
    • Reply
  • MrsMcK
    VIP September 2017
    MrsMcK ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    The thing is, you can’t force her to contribute money. The rest of the BMs agreed to split the cost, but she didn’t. I understand being disappointed that she doesn’t want to be as involved as the rest of your girls, but there’s nothing she is required to do as for as pre-wedding parties. You are correct that you can’t ask her to step down.
    • Reply
  • MrsMcK
    VIP September 2017
    MrsMcK ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    *as far as
    • Reply
  • J
    Expert September 2013
    Jay ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    HI Sarah,

    Our WeddingWire forums do have many threads with great advice on this.

    There is no good way to get around it and all of your assumptions, in my experience anyway, are correct. - Since you admit that she was more of an obligatory addition to your wedding party, it will show through. Meanwhile, you have fun with and take advantage of the more supportive members of your party!

    • Reply
  • Alina
    Expert May 2020
    Alina ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Hi Sarah! This is a tough situation but from the sounds of it you seem to be handling it the best you can. Other couples have been in similar situations and conflicts with the spouses siblings and many feel it is because the sibling is resentful that someone is coming into the family and "taking" their brother or sister from them. I would recommend having your FH talk to her and clarify that her behavior is not acceptable and what exactly is expected of her for the wedding. If she does not want to partake in the bachelorette party she does not have to but on the wedding day she needs to be respectful. As well if your FH feels she is acting like this because she is resentful of the relationship maybe he should re-assure her that he will always be her brother no matter what and maybe take her out for dinner or something along the lines of sibling bonding.

    • Reply
  • Mandi
    VIP May 2016
    Mandi ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    She is not required to attend, contribute, etc to any pre-wedding events if she doesn't agree to. And I would advise against asking your FH's sister to step down. This is someone you will have a relationship with for many years to come and starting it off this way is not a good idea.

    • Reply
  • MrsD
    Legend July 2019
    MrsD ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Can someone else pay her $53? It doesn't sound like its worth it to have her stay, and she probably would just ruin the night. It is annoying to ask to be a bridesmaid, then not understand the work and money it requires.

    • Reply
  • V
    Super April 2019
    Valerie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I have never been asked to pay for a hotel I wasn't staying in and I would also be very put off by it and say no. Also please never say 'only $53' - at one point in my life $53 would have been more than I could have afforded. Also, you are also saying it is money to be split for food and decor. What is that cost? Did anyone ask her budget for this?

    And since you seem to have a great contempt for your FSIL, have you made this attitude known to her? My exSIL hated me but it was my brothers wedding and I wanted to be involved. I was a bridesmaid and I definitely took a step back because she always gave me attitude. Every time I tried to help with ideas (which if you are talking about your wedding I would assume you would want some opinions) she would shoot me down like I was trying to ruin her wedding. In fact, I did get accused of trying to ruin the wedding because I put the label for the M&Ms on the wrong part of the mason jar when I was given no direction where the label should go. (I wish I was kidding)

    Also lastly and most importantly, your bridesmaids have NO DUTIES! They are your family and friends not your employees. She has gotten a dress and plans to stand next to you on your day. That is the ONLY thing that she needs to do. It is great that some of your friends are more involved, but no one is required to do anything.

    • Reply
  • P
    Super January 2019
    PalmTrees ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    If I was told I needed to pay $53 for a shower and bach party I wouldn’t be too thrilled. This is the type of thing that should be discussed and offered, whoever is planning can’t just assume all the bms will equally chip in. I was told that once by a MOH, that I must contribute xx dollars to the shower. Little different situation there as I was going to be across the country and not even at the shower. But a couple other bms felt uncomfortable that they were told to give this amount. The MOH had planned it and then split up the cost and told us all you owe this and you’re all co-hosting. So I can see how that’s not sitting well with her. As for her other behavior idk, maybe she feels like she was an obligatory addition and is acting out because of it?
    • Reply
  • Yolande
    Beginner May 2024
    Yolande ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    You can't force her to participate in the wedding events if she flat out refuses to. It seems like its mainly an attitude issue if her even her mom is trying to get her on board with planning . I know its supposed to be a great way to bond but not all family will be easy to get along with. Plus with all she's done until now I can't imagine her being much help in planning without making everything about her. At this point the most you can hope for her is to show up on time for your wedding.

    I really hope you don't let her attitude get in the way of the amazing wedding you will be having. It sounds like your other bridesmaids have been very supportive of you Smiley heart

    • Reply
  • S
    Savvy July 2018
    Sarah ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Well, now I feel awful for expecting that. It's just always been the norm with my group of people that the bridesmaids (even just the good group of friends of the bride) contribute to the planning and cost of pre-wedding events. So I thought nothing of it, as well as my friends thought nothing of it to have these expectations.

    I do know that part of the reason for her behavior is because there is resentment towards me because she feels like I have stolen her brother from her. This is because he won't let her come over to our house and hangout on a weeknight because I have to go to bed early. Not my request. I would never try to cause a problem between them. She is just having a hard time understanding that he and I are now becoming our own family unit. I have tried to initiate occasions where we go out for dinner , but she never accepts.

    So I was honestly so surprised that she made such a big deal about wanting to be my bridesmaid. Unfortunately, her skill of constantly turning the subject to her during most conversations and now caused me to resent asking her to be a part of our day. Those on my FH side of the family are so worried about her ability to keep herself together that day. It's like everyone is waiting for that inevitable explosion of emotion.

    Now, I'm my defense (I should have mentioned this in OP) she did take it upon herself to invite some people on her own to both the shower and the bachelorette party. So, I do think that if she is taking on a role of hosting and adding to the number of people attending, she should contribute. It's not fair of her to expect that others pay for her guests.
    • Reply
  • Jen
    VIP July 2018
    Jen ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I don't understand why it is a "duty" for someone to pay $53 when they aren't staying at the hotel? It seems like the cost to stay there should be divided by all those that choose to stay there (including the bride). Though if she invited some friends then she needs to pay for them.

    • Reply
  • Sarah
    Master June 2016
    Sarah ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Even if it is normal for the bridesmaids in your social circle to throw the shower/bachelorette, it should never have been assumed that everyone could afford/would want to contribute to these things. It might be only $53 to you, but for a lot of people that’s too much money to spend on an extra activity, especially when the cost is just the hotel room and she isn’t even staying.
    • Reply
  • S
    Savvy July 2018
    Sarah ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    Oh trust me. I am actually paying for the majority of the room. Mostly as a treat to my bridesmaids as a place to stay after a late night. It was their idea to pay for at least some of it as their way of hosting the shower and party. When she took it upon herself to invite people on her own, imo, that means you're taking on a responsibility of hosting and therefore contributing in some way.

    • Reply
  • EML
    Dedicated June 2018
    EML ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    Personally, before you mentioned she was adding people to the guests at these events I was in agreement with PP that no one can make her contribute or attend pre wedding parties. I think it's inappropriate for her to be adding to the guest list at all but then she's not helping pay for it so it will create a greater burden on the BMs who are willing to contribute to and throw these extra parties is not right. Do you even know the people she's adding? I could understand if she saw the list and asked if you had forgotten someone who she knew you would want added....but to just add people randomly is pretty bold of her.

    • Reply
  • S
    Savvy July 2018
    Sarah ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    They are someone I know, and someone that will be invited to the wedding, but not someone that I am close with or that I have ever hung out with outside of obligation. These are not necessarily people that I would want around me during my state of being when I am in bachelorette party mode. I was asked for the guest list of people that I would like to spend a bridal shower and bachelorette party with, and I gave that list. She added these other girls, and now has backed out of all planning conversation since the topic of price has come up.


    • Reply
  • Jennifer
    Master September 2018
    Jennifer ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I don't believe that whole "all bridesmaids are required to do is get a dress and show up" that's bull, if I am close enough to you that you asked me to stand beside you I am going to be excited for your wedding, lend a shoulder or an ear when needed and help in whatever way I possibly can. As a good friend that is what I do and what all of my best friends do for each other. The diff here is the obligatory BM - one you feel obligated to ask because of family or FH or whatever. I would not expect much from her and I certainly would not be happy if she invited people on her own and was not hosting or contributing in any way. If I were you I would have a chat with her, perhaps it's immaturity and she just doesn't know any better? Maybe explain your feelings to her, open up the lines of communication and let her know how you feel. Good luck!

    • Reply
  • Red Queen
    VIP May 2018
    Red Queen ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    If she isn't staying, I don't see why she should have to pay. These parties are optional. As long as she has her dress and shows up relatively sober, she's done her job.

    • Reply
  • EML
    Dedicated June 2018
    EML ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    Have the invitations gone out already? If not I would speak to your MOH or one of the other BMs and have the additional guests removed. If invitations have already gone out then I believe your FSIL should contribute enough to cover the costs of the guests she added to the list that you never wanted there in the first place. If the invites have already gone out did your MOH or another BM confirm the additional guests with you first?

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Explore how we embrace diversity

Groups

WeddingWire article topics