Best mascara?

My absolute favorites:

Maybelline Great Lashes (the pink and green bottle)... it's a basic but awesome choice. One that never fails me.

Stila Huge Lasha (gold bottle)... amazing. Stila is such a good makeup brand. I recommend anything they make.

Maybelline Colossal Cat Eyes Mascara (yellow and orange cat print bottle)... so, so, so good.

I get compliments on my lashes every time I wear one of these mascaras. The key is to apply two to three coats of mascara to get a fuller effect.

I love the Maybelline Big Shot (gold tube). It's like $7 or $8 at WalMart/drugstores. It makes my lashes look amazing and doesn't feel like cement.

Better than sex mascara by too faced. You can get it at ULTA. I love this mascara and will never go back to any other.

They're Real by Benefit. Seriously makes it look like you have false eyelashes on! My fiance even asks me sometimes "are you wearing those fake eyelash things?" but it's just the mascara

View Quoted Comment

They're Real is a really good one too. Benefit, in general, is awesome.

View Quoted Comment

I second this! Love this mascara.

They're Real is good too, but just be aware it's so hard to get off. I'm using it right now cause I have a sample size, and I use makeup remover at night and then have to again in the morning cause there's still mascara smudged around my eyes.

I would suggest a lash primer too, L’Oréal makes a good one. It goes on white then you apply darker mascara!

Hands down Too Faced Better than Sex or Benefit They're Real. I only use those two and typically buy them both because I love them so much. I also buy (depending on how much I feel like spending) the Benefit/Sephora/Lancome/Clinique eye makeup remover because you'll definitely need it.

I use L'Oreal Lash Paradise or Tart Lights, Camera, Lashes. Those are my absolute favorite at the moment.

Benefit does have good mascara. I have naturally long lashes, so I get mascara transfer from blinking before it's dry. Bad Gal has the least amount of transfer.

My go to waterproof mascaras are "Lights, Camera, Splashes" by Tarte or "Falsies" by Maybelline (purple with turquoise wording).

View Quoted Comment

I am usually in this same camp but just bought Benefit's new BadGal BANG!. I would rank it above They're Real but not Better Than Sex Waterproof.

Try the small trial sizes from Ulta and see which one you like. Benefit's mascara is amazing. I think they have a sampler pack you can buy.

Clinique or mary kay

I use Bobbi Brown smoky eye mascara. I always get asked if I have fake lashes. It doesn’t smudge throughout the day either, which is a problem I have with every other brand.

Benefit roller lash and It cosmetics superhero. I’m not a fan of the better than sex mascara, I found it to be really clumpy and flakey.

View Quoted Comment I second It Cosmetics Superhero! It's my favorite mascara ever! My lashes are so long and voluminous with that mascara!

View Quoted Comment

I bought the Better than Sex Waterproof and it was so clumpy and a mess I threw it away. I am not a fan of that one. I have not tried the BadGal BANG! yet so now I blame you for my trip to Ulta this weekend! :-)

I LOVE YOUNIQUE. It's 2 parts: the gel and the fibers you put on right after the gel. Adds length

L’Oréal voluminous in carbon black!

Better than sex mascara or IT cosmetics super hero... both are fab!

I love this 1. The primer really gives the false lash look.