As soon as we scheduled our wedding, my husband and I knew The Goodie Shop had to be a part of it. They are our favorite neighborhood bakery, and their cookies, cakes, and other sweet treats never disappoint!

The process of ordering and designing our wedding cake with Debbie was a lot of fun, and the cake tasting was delicious!! It was wonderful to see Emilie and Miranda on our wedding day, as they delivered the cake and arranged the flowers so beautifully. It looked exactly as we had envisioned. Several of our out-of-town guests exclaimed that it was the best wedding cake they’ve ever tasted — our local guests already knew how delicious it would be, since The Goodie Shop is a longstanding favorite among our friends :)

We selected their vanilla cake with almond icing, and it was so yummy, as is everything else from The Goodie Shop!!

We ordered two small cakes for our wedding and they came out beautifully. They also provided great advice on storing and transporting them to our venue.

My wife and I were determined to have the best cake possible at our wedding, and tried several places around Columbus. Tremont Goodie Shop was hands down the best of anything we tasted. The cake was moist and the frosting was excellent. Not only that, the prices were some of the best that we found as well. Debbie was great to work with and made sure we got exactly what we wanted. We would absolutely recommend Tremont Goodie Shop to anyone looking for a wedding cake.

My sister and I both had the Goodie shop design our cakes. Hers was traditional and very elegant, mine was non traditional and unique in its own way. The design was flawless. They only do one wedding a weekend to allow them to dedicate themselves to their customers. The cake was really good and was everything I had asked for. They assembled it on site to make sure that it was not ruined in transport. They arrived early to make sure that everything was in place. I highly recommend The Tremont Goodie Shop to anyone looking for a wedding cake or any other cake for that matter. The best quality I could have asked for.

They made a beautiful and tasty cake exactly to my specifications.
No complaints, can't wait for my 1 year anniversary to eat the rest!

My venue provided our wedding cake, but I had the Groom's cake done by the Goodie Shop. I showed them a picture I found on pinterest and they managed to recreate it perfectly AND with buttercream frosting. Plus it was DELICIOUS. We also bought Buckeye candies there to compliment our dessert table, and they are SO much better than the pre-made or packaged ones from Anthony Thomas (nothing against them, their other stuff is fantastic).

My husband grew up in Upper Arlington and was always drawn to the Goodie Shop. We met with several cake people and we found that they either had great cake or great frosting...until we went to the Tremont Goodie Shop. We did cupcakes with a small topper. I provided them with ideas of decorations and they went from there. The cupcakes were absolutely gorgeous, and tasted amazing. Our guests absolutely loved them.

My mom used to work at the Tremont Goodie Shop when she was in high school, and she always has such great memories of it. Debbie and her daughter Emilie are amazing people, and they are so kind! My husband and I walked into the shop one day, as we were just initially inquiring about wedding cakes. We had an idea that we wanted to use the Goodie Shop, as my family used them for getting every birthday cake. When we walked in, Debbie greeted us and met with us right then. She had a cake ready and explained all of the options. It was just great to know that she was willing to meet with us without an appointment and that she really cared about our needs. When it came time to talk about the cake characteristics, Emilie was so helpful, and it was all conveniently done through E-mail! I wanted a woodgrain pattern, and I was unsure if she was going to understand the exact look I was going for, but she did, and I was so shocked when I saw the cake! It was perfect! They also had made a cake stand out of logs, and it was perfect for my wedding theme. She even spent time dying the cake plate a vintagy brown color, as she thought the white did not match the theme, and this is definitely not something she had to even think about, but she did. I would highly recommend the Goodie Shop to anyone!

I loved my cake!!! it was absolutely gorgeous, and tasted wonderful! I would highly recommend them. They helped me to figure out a good style, and were honest if they didn't think something would look right. Great people, and I am so happy we were able to work with them!

I grew up getting donuts and treats from The Goodie Shop, so it just made sense to have them bake my wedding cake! Doreen was nice to work with - kind and very thorough. I certainly trusted her with our cake. I took in a picture of what I wanted and she was happy to oblige! Delicious, gorgeous cake!