Three Tomatoes Catering

This caterer was the best value. Jacqueline was amazing to work with. She evaluated my choices for catering my wedding and showed me other menu options that would be a better fit for the amount of money that I wanted to spend. She explained why my first choice might not have been a good idea and suggested another option that gave us more food and other included items for less money. I would recommend Three Tomatoes to anyone that needs to save money and wants to see upfront pricing when considering a catering company.

Three Tomatoes catered our wedding of ~100 and did a phenomenal job. Our guests reported one of their favorite things at our wedding was the food and we couldn't agree more. Three Tomatoes not only made accomidations for all dietary restrictions (vegan, gluten free, soy free), they did so while keeping extraodinary quality and everything was so delicious. On top of their professionalism and excellent communications, they kept everything so organized and made our lives (which were chaotic from wedding planning) so much easier. We predominantly worked with Jacqueline, but everyone at three tomatoes has our gratitude and recommendation for life. 10/5 stars. If you're considering them, do it.

I absolutely loved working with Three Tomatoes! From the tasting to the execution everything was fantastic. The company overall was accommodating and flexible when we had to push our wedding date back 9 months due to COVID. They did not charge us extra, but simply moved the day of the event in their calendar. Our coordinator, Caitlin was beyond helpful and accommodating as well. She was able to help us change headcounts last minute due to family emergencies a few days prior to the wedding. The best part was their staff the day of – they were kind, considerate and quick moving to help us transition into cocktail hour, into dinner and then into partying. One of the catering staff would come out to clean up spills on the dance floor and was witnessed to dance and show off his moves in the spirit of the night – he was AMAZING and definitely one of the highlights of the evening. Overall, the food was delicious, and all of our wedding guests commented on how much they enjoyed it. 10/10 would recommend using their services.

If you are still on the hunt for a wedding caterer, please stop searching right now and hire Three Tomatoes!!! This full-service catering company is absolute PERFECTION. I cannot recommend them highly enough and can’t even begin to express my joy and gratitude. Their team is amazing and makes the whole planning process SO EASY on you, their custom menus and creative takes on traditional dishes are to die for, their vast array of food is absolutely delicious and the presentation is over-the-top gorgeous, their staff is professional and experienced, and their commitment to excellence does not go unnoticed. Their team’s creativity, attention to detail and perfectionism took my wedding to the next level. I promise you’ll be immediately impressed (and relieved!) from day one, and it only gets better as you embark on the planning process together. They aren’t kidding when they say they are a full-service catering company. We called them the ‘dream team’…they are seriously that amazing you guys! Our guests ranted and raved for weeks after our wedding about the food and how gorgeous the presentation was (not to mention, the custom craft cocktails 😊). And I didn’t have to stress or worry about a single thing on my wedding day—they executed everything flawlessly. My wedding wouldn’t have been half as beautiful, classy, fun and memorable if it weren’t for my Three Tomatoes team; in particular, Ashley Cunningham and Tabitha Hossfeld. I strongly suggest that if you do decide to go with Three Tomatoes, request to work with Ashley and Tabitha. Here’s why:

I could go on for days about how amazing Ashley Cunningham is. If you have the opportunity to work with her, jump on it as fast as you possibly can! I can confidently say that Ashley Cunningham is the most professional, put together, “with it” individual I’ve ever worked with. She is unbelievably good at what she does and she’s crazy talented. Since day one (our first phone call before I even hired her, actually), Ashley blew my mind and exceeded all my wildest expectations. Her personality combined with her skills, knowledge and experience makes for an absolute dream. Ashley is bright, insanely organized, kind, supportive, respectful, funny, creative, and ridiculously awesome in every single way. She is a blast to work with! I have to admit, I didn’t love wedding planning, but working with her was so much fun and by far my favorite part of the planning process. She respected all our wishes (and our budget constraints) and made adjustments to the menu and layout sooo many times to make sure we had everything we dreamed of. Also, her turnaround time is incredible—you ask her for help with anything, anytime, and she gets back to you immediately. Ashley made me feel like I was her only client, and the most important client in the world. She genuinely cares about you and it’s evident in everything she does. Even though I had a wedding coordinator whose services included vendor recommendations, I went to Ashley every time for advice on who to hire because I trusted her opinion and knew that she understood my vision. Because of her, I had the dream team at my wedding. She introduced me to my unbelievably amazing photographer, Mariana Ziegler (Mariana Ziegler Photography); my incredibly talented florist Julie Winje (Inspired Designs); and the best event designer out there, Tabitha Hossfeld (Three Tomatoes).

Tabitha Hossfeld is seriously the BEST! We brought her on as our wedding decorator—even though we couldn’t afford one. She was that impressive. Immediately after talking to her over the phone for the first time I knew we had to do whatever we could to find room in our budget for her. To say that she goes above and beyond for you is an understatement. As a self-proclaimed interior design fanatic, I knew exactly how I wanted our wedding to look, and let me tell you, Tabitha turned my vision into reality and blew me (and our guests) away! She would regularly meet me at our venue so we could walk the grounds and brainstorm ideas together; she’d meet me for happy hour to scroll through Pinterest pictures so she could ensure she’d achieve my vision; and to my surprise and delight, she would spend her free weekends hopping around different flea markets shopping for specific items that I had shown her and told her I loved. How amazing is that?! She did EVERYTHING in her power to cut costs for me, and I am beyond grateful to her for that. Tabitha is extremely talented, and she loves what she does. You can tell that she genuinely cares about you and making your wedding day everything you want it to be, and she makes you feel so taken care of from inception to execution and even afterwards. She’s insanely sweet and an absolute joy to work with. I can’t express how amazing and fun that experience was for me, and it was all thanks to Tabby!

I promise that catering and planning your wedding with the Three Tomatoes team of experts will be the best decision you make in your entire planning process! Thank you, thank you, thank you Three Tomatoes! You guys are the best of the best. With love and thanks, Brooke and Bobby Macauley

Our experience with Three Tomatoes Catering was excellent! We worked with Hannah who was an absolute delight! She was so patient with us as we were indecisive about our menu choices, and was quick to answer any questions we had throughout the entire process. She gave us honest opinions about all of the options we were interested in.. we were so happy with all of her recommendations! Hannah was also willing to set up any separate meal for those of our guests who seem to be picky eaters! We didn't end up needing to do that, but was really nice knowing that was something she could take care of. We loved everything we sampled during our tasting, but we were still blown away by the food at our reception- OUR FOOD WAS AMAZING! We had guests from all over the country, so we wanted appetizers that appeal to everyone, but also have a unique presentation. Three tomatoes nailed it! I highly recommend the "duck donuts." The chicken served at dinner was so flavorful and not at all dry which seems to happen all too often at weddings. Our steak was cooked perfectly!!! We were so pleased! Towards the end of our reception, "late night snacks" of chicken strips and french fries were served- these were a huge hit, and most likely life savers after an evening of partying! We received so many compliments on the food from our guests! The entire staff treated us with such kindness and executed the evening without a hitch. Our bartenders were open to creating any cocktail of our choosing, and made sure they had the appropriate mixers. They did such a great job and were very patient with our rowdy crew! Three tomatoes also provided meals for our vendors which also received positive feedback. Our photographers raved about Three Tomatoes saying they were treated better than they have ever experienced at weddings! You cannot go wrong with Three Tomatoes- they are professional, flexible, affordable, honest, and most of all, they make delicious meals your guests will love!

Three Tomatoes was the third caterer that me and my husband visited with. We were feeling a little down-trodden after meeting with the first two; one was super unprofessional and honestly rude and the other one was super expensive for what felt like not enough food. We worked with Hannah Teague and she was so wonderful. She was very friendly and up front about what we should expect. What is super cool about Three Tomatoes is their entire menu is custom! You basically built the dinners. This was a huge relief because at the other caterers we visited, you couldn’t make any substitutions. When we went to our tasting, we felt as if we were at a very nice restaurant. Their office is super cute and very clean. We were able to try out so many different food options. It was great to have so many choices! The other great thing about Three Tomatoes is they have there on baker, so we were able to order our wedding cake from them also. We loved the “one-stop shop” concept. It was just nice to be able to work with one vendor for all the food. And holy buckets, the cake was freaking delicious! We ended up doing two cake tastings with them because as we got closer to the wedding date we needed a reminder on the cake flavors. Hannah let us pick up a to-go cake tasting which was super nice. What may be hard to believe is Three Tomatoes ended up being the most affordable option for us as a caterer. We were so surprised we were saving money especially since we hand picked our menu and used them for our wedding cake also! The food was delicious, the cake delightful and we have no complaints. We highly recommend Three Tomatoes!

The experience working with Lauren for almost 9 months before my wedding was nothing but pleasurable. She was able to answer my million questions, always with a pleasant attitude and was able to turn around cost projections in a timely manner. Being that this was a destination wedding, we selected everything sight unseen and were quite nervous how everything was going to look and taste but we were pleasantly surprised. We, along with our guests, all thoroughly enjoyed the BBQ and the desserts. Everything was A1 quality! Thank you for helping make our dreams come true

They were willing to do whatever we wanted and made it taste delicious! We also did our cake through them and it was so moist, it was to die for! I think food is often hit or miss at weddings and I heard all my guests saying how amazing our food was.

Hannah at Three Tomatoes is incredible. I am a very controlling person and she always made me feel at ease and heard at our meetings. We crafted our own menu to reflect our tastes and the food was amazing. I am SO GLAD we were brought a plate of our appetizers because, let me tell you, I would have been really upset if I didn't get to eat them. They were amazing. Dinner was presented beautifully, in a timely manner and it was delicious. We were all set to have dinner outside and at the last minute had to move inside due to rain and they re-crafted the space to look beautiful without skipping a step. From our first consultation I never had any worry that it wouldn't turn out the way I imagined or expected. The food was delicious and we were very very pleased with their service!! I would hire them again!!

I can't rave enough about Three Tomatoes. They catered our wedding and it was truly a breeze to work with them and the food was so tasty. They worked well with our other vendors, made sure everything was good to go beforehand, and ensured the actual event went smoothly. I will definitely be considering them for all future catering needs and recommending them as often as possible!