About Muddy Paws Cheesecake

A cake they'll remember.......

General Information: Wedding Cheesecakes 

At Muddy Paws Cheesecake, Weddings are our specialty! It is how we started our business 17 years ago and created a name for ourselves in the Twin Cities. Today, we are #1 in Wedding Cheesecakes in the Midwest and weddings are still the core of our business. They are so fun for us to do and they make for a beautiful, decadent Wedding Cake…. AND the guests go crazy to be able to have Cheesecake! We take great pride our creamy New York style cheesecake. Made only with the best of ingredients: cream cheese, eggs, vanilla and cream…and no fillers. Our award winning Cheesecake is offered in over 200 flavors & is hand made in small batches from scratch with love:).

Below there are several great ideas listed for displaying our Cheesecakes as wedding cheesecakes. There is also some general Cheesecake information, wedding information, and pricing information: (It gets a little lengthy....sorry – but there are LOTS of options with Cheesecake!!!). We take great pride in working with each bride on a personal basis; we will work with you on all your individual needs and make your day perfect, memorable…and YUMMY!

Also see our web site (www.muddypawscheesecake.com) for flavors and wedding photos.


The Tiered Cheesecake
Cheesecakes can be tiered (three or four varied sizes of cheesecake) on a traditional looking wedding cake stand with the additional cheesecakes needed set around the tiers (or the side cakes can be 'put in back' to be served by reception staff.) This is our most popular display. Fresh flowers, fresh fruit and/or cake toppers all look beautiful on the tiered cheesecake.  (Note: a two tiered cake and cake stand is also available. Many brides choose this for the head table.) The tiered cheesecakes are usually pre-sliced except for the top tier, which is often used for the cake cutting or Anniversary cake. The tiered cheesecakes are a showstopper! 
*Chocolate ganachè covered tiers and/or Square tiered cheesecakes are also available for an extra cost.-inquire. Also see stacked cakes.

Dessert Buffet: You may also have a dessert buffet of cheesecakes in several flavors (in the 9" size). Most brides choose six to eight flavors but we've had others choose ten to fifteen flavors! We always get the question: what if we run out of a flavor? No worries, guests are just so excited to get cheesecake that it's never an issue! We recommend you pick a few 'safe' flavors and then throw in some 'crazy' ones for fun(pssst..hint: think of coffee flavored cheesecakes too...many people love them after dinner).(
**Note: Many times the tiered cheesecake and dessert buffet ideas are combined together on one big table).

Sauce Bar and the Stacked Cake (sounds like a mystery doesn’t it?!):

Last year one of our brides started a new trend at Muddy Paws. She did all New York Cheesecakes (plain) and did a big Sauce bar for them rather than choosing flavors. It was a huge hit! We have twelve choices of sauces/toppings to choose from including some candy bar topping crumbles, various fruit & berry toppings, chocolate, and caramel. Guests get a kick out of spooning on their favorite toppings. SO fun!

The Stacked Cake has been a popular new choice among brides. Some brides want something a little extra special for their head table or traditional looking for the cake table. The stacked cheesecake idea works great for that and may also be combined with a cheesecake buffet. Brides will usually have two cakes stacked at the head table or three-four cakes stacked on a cake table. Then they are placed on a pedestal stand or silver plateau. Flowers, vines, chocolate covered strawberries, and/or fruit decorate them beautifully. The stacked cheesecakes are also great for reception sites requiring you to have a traditional wedding cake, since it resembles a traditional looking cake. *Square or round.

 Cheesecake Centerpieces & Mini Cheesecakes
Two very popular "self serve" options are cheesecake centerpieces and mini cheesecakes. The centerpiece cheesecakes are a hit because the guests get a kick out of serving themselves right from their table AND they make for a beautiful centerpiece on the tables. Also, they not only save you money by “killing two birds with one stone” but they make for a great ice breaker by engaging guests in conversation, especially when guests go table to table to decide what flavor they want. Guests just love that they don't have to wait for dessert…even though they do have to drool over them through dinner! These are available in the 7" size or 9"inch size.(The 7" size serves 8 guests and the 9" size serves 12 or 16). Fresh fruit, flowers, flower petals, or just plain are all popular ways to display the centerpiece cheesecakes. We have several choices of pedestal stands as well for them. Samplers are also available. (See the albums at our shops for ideas) *All cheesecakes are pre-sliced.
The Mini Cheesecakes are available in any of our traditional flavors (and some specialty flavors). We have two sizes. Our cupcakes sized mini’s are approximately 2 1/2 inches and are very easy to serve (they are self contained in a silver or gold foil liner). Our petite mini’s are a little smaller but are a touch more fancy – each 1.75 inch mini is made in it’s own little pan! They also serve easily. Both options are very cute
J !  Most often minis are placed on a tiered stand to create a wedding cake/tree look, placed on trays or pedestals, placed on tables as centerpieces (10 on a silver pedestal etc.) or placed at each individual setting (for dessert, guest favor, or pre-meal treat). The mini cheesecake option is especially popular for appetizer  and/or ‘mingling’ weddings. * Some brides have us put fruit atop these and/or add a sauce bar.

Set Up & Delivery

The cheesecakes are usually set out about 30 min to 1 hour prior to guest arrival. That is usually when we'd deliver & set up. From that point the cheesecakes can sit out for 4-6+ hours. Ours are real cheesecakes ( J ) so there isn’t air in them like others you may find and they hold their temp a long time. They will still be perfectly cold when your guests are ready to dive in for dessert! (Note:They are baked at a high temperature so they are perfectly safe to display for multiple hours.) Our set up includes: delivery, set up, printed flavor tents (so guests know the flavor of cheesecakes displayed), extra boxes (for the rare leftover cheesecakeJ), cake table decorations*, fruit decorating, and any cake flower/petal  placement*. Costs: Delivery cost is mileage based – please call to get a quote.   You may also pick up your wedding cheesecakes (and any stands rented + free flavor tents) at our bakery & office in St Louis Park to save on delivery cost. They travel well and set up easily.

*Have all table decorations and flowers there for us on the cake table so we can easily locate them. Flowers can be pre-cut loose or pre-arranged.


Out-of-town wedding? No problem!  We handle LOTS of out of town weddings! Whether it is Iowa, Wisconsin, Other parts of MN, South Dakota, or Illinois… our Cheesecakes travel great. We place them in sturdy, stackable boxes for your drive and they stay cold in coolers for 8-12 hours or more.  Once you get there, they are easy to set up yourselves. We pre-slice the cheesecakes for you and include ‘flavor tents’ too! Though very tedious to make, cheesecakes are very sturdy and solid once done – making them “slam on the breaks” safe!

Fruit and SauceFresh Fruit is seasonally priced. Most brides choose raspberries, strawberries or blueberries but mango, kiwi and blackberries look very pretty too! Prices start at $6 for a cake to be covered with fruit or $3 for a cluster of fruit. Chocolate Covered Strawberries are $1each and are a great compliment to the cheesecake.


Bride and Groom Strawberries are $5 each. These crowd drawing; BIG strawberries are decorated in a chocolate ‘tuxedo and wedding dress’!  They make for great toppers on your cake and taste incredible. 

Sauces and Toppings: We have 13 choices!! Bowls are available but most reception sites will provide bowls and spoons for sauce. This is a fun addition for centerpiece cakes or cheesecake buffets.  It's always a hit with guests!

Cake Stands We have 22 designs of cakes stands/display options available for your cheesecakes (look on our website at past wedding photos for ideas: www.muddypawscheesecake.com). They are all beautiful and unique. You may also use your own cake stand if you wish. Rental prices range from $1-$35 for cake stands. Stands need to be returned to us by the Tuesday following your wedding or event. We have photo albums in our shop showing the various stands as well.

Cheesecake Cost
The average cost for our cheesecake is $2.75 per person/slice for the cheesecake (based on our traditional flavors @ $32 per 9" cake serving 12-16).  See Website for a full listing of flavors and prices of our 9” cheesecakes. The average cost for the cheesecake tends to stay in the same price range no matter what cheesecakes/set up option you choose. We will work with you and your vision (and your cake budget!) to create exactly what you wish for.  There are lots of options at Muddy Paws Cheesecake!

SAMPLING! and Other Info:

Call to set up a complimentary tasting and consultation *! We will have you fill out a short form, discuss various wedding cheesecake options, pricing, review photo albums AND eat cheesecake of course! You will meet with Owner, Tami Cabrera Weinmann or Wedding Coordinator Amy McMonigal. Tami & Amy oversee all wedding cheesecakes and coordination of our weddings.  For all wedding questions, more information or to schedule a meeting, please call Tami or Amy @ #763-545-7161 (leave a voice mail and we will call you back in 24 hours or less).  We usually meet weekdays or weeknights at our Bakery: Monday thru Thursday.  (* Limit: One free sampling session per couple)Email is great for discussing questions and recording details too: yummy@muddypawscheesecake.com

We need 10 days notice for your final order (flavors and quantities) but it's best to have your wedding date reserved with us in advance. Once you decide to go with Muddy Paws for your wedding, send a $50 deposit to hold your date (The deposit comes off your final balance, which is due 5 days prior to the wedding).   Send deposits to our St Louis Park Bakery & Office: Muddy Paws Cheesecake, 7600 W 27th Street, Suite B2, St Louis Park, MN 55426           Call #763-545-7161 or email us with any questions you have. We'd love to work with you!

Categories: Wedding Cake

Regions serviced: Minneapolis

Follow Muddy Paws Cheesecake on

97 Reviews for Muddy Paws Cheesecake

out of 5.0
User Photos
todo alt text
todo alt text
todo alt text
Filter reviews by services used:
All Reviews
Consultations (12)
Delivery (11)
Setup (11)
Cakes (5)
Dessert Buffet (4)
Gluten Free (4)
Cupcakes (1)
Groom's Cake (1)
Lactose Free (1)
Sort by:


oWe would highly recommend Muddy Paws Cheesecake for wedding receptions! The cheesecake was great and looked amazing! Putting a cheesecake at the center of each table was such a great alternative to expensive centerpieces. We were also able to provide our guests with variety by placing a flavor at each table and the cost was very affordable compared to numerous other bakeries we contacted. We worked with Meg and Tami. Both provided great customer service and were easy to work with. They also did an amazing job of setting up and coordinating with the venue without any work on our part. We have absolutely no complaints and will definitely recommend to others.

Photo of Muddy Paws Cheesecake in Minneapolis, MN
Photo of Muddy Paws Cheesecake in Minneapolis, MN
Photo of Muddy Paws Cheesecake in Minneapolis, MN
Photo of Muddy Paws Cheesecake in Minneapolis, MN
Profile Picture Kelsey, 8/26/17, 6 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake

This is hands down the BEST CHEESECAKE I HAVE EVER TASTED! All my quests were super excited that I was having cheesecake rather then regular cake. I loved the cheesecakes and so did everyone. There was none to spare!

Profile Picture joleen, 8/5/17, 4 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake
Services Used: Gluten Free, Cakes, Consultations

Muddy Paws Cheesecake FAQ

Dessert Buffet
Groom's Cake
Cake Pops
Custom Design
Private Tastings
Gluten Free
Lactose Free
Nut Free
Health License


22 Photos

Wedding Cheesecakes 1

13 Photos
220x220 sq 1213715957121 centerpiececakepretty3
220x220 sq 1213716026637 petiteminiswedding
220x220 sq 1213716209965 cheesecakebuffetmichael
220x220 sq 1274487521802 1557angwhi1
220x220 sq 1274487608599 img4116
220x220 sq 1490280338612 cupcake minis
220x220 sq 1490280372372 469556101505968126467751915287536o
220x220 sq 1490280381870 aeychymxkd6xeqenieait94txnk0e5kgpn9yr42mvya
220x220 sq 1490280393440 cepf1dkvw36s 3kl0fl2bwzrqztrojw4xuqh8pytozm
220x220 sq 1490280400389 5ppqhrpbbgbeysy p1r3d748gxsextihtiwkploi4me
220x220 sq 1490280405612 3 tier
220x220 sq 1490280415082 unspecified 11
220x220 sq 1490280422830 xpmx8gec8p2i1asylhhvxboitxa4edcssi8n5cubpg

Weddings 2

9 Photos
220x220 sq 1490280590790 gglzig9ztmynoqawk77pjzrjykixg2thwcx6 sg6bkobwfp9rp
220x220 sq 1490280603917 key lime rasp meghan doll
220x220 sq 1490280616832 mv1z0ltkxu4dwby71rnfpueaecvlsnwpobqscoxzefoce0nxzr
220x220 sq 1490280651027 camp cheesecake
220x220 sq 1490280676872 cj7jhzxaaaasor
220x220 sq 1490280683354 camp cheesecake 1st day
220x220 sq 1490280692913 0889
220x220 sq 1490280721611 0751
220x220 sq 1490280733835 0746

Professional Network & Endorsements

We love Muddy Paws Cheesecake! They offer a fun (and tasty) alternative to traditional wedding cakes. They are flexible with delivery and setup, and the cheesecake is always a hit with guests!

My daughter especially requested Muddy Paws for her own wedding, and we were entirely pleased with these magically melt-in your mouth, lighter than air flavors. This cheesecake, unlike any others I've ever tasted, "disappears" in your mouth while your brain is still asking, "Wow! What was that heavenly stuff!" It was a buffet of tastes that kept everyone happy.

Wonderful Cheesecake! Beautifully displayed wedding cheesecakes too! The fresh, authentic ingredients always make for a delicious dessert people rave about. -Diane Martinson-Vocalist

We get many unique clients and we LOVE when they choose cheesecake from Muddy Paws as opposed to traditional wedding cake! The only complaint we've heard is that there are so many delicious flavors it's hard to choose one!

I cannot get enough of their cheesecake, and neither can my clients. If I ate their cheesecake everyday for the rest of my life, I wouldn't be tired of it. Delicious, affordable, a ton of flavors and great customer service!



7600 W 27th Street, Suite B2, Minneapolis, MN 55426   See On Map
763-545-7161 (phone)
Open Weekdays and Saturdays. Call for an Appointment or Cake Pick Up Time.