Nearby Vendors to Consider

About Frosted Pumpkin

A premiere specialty cake company in Atlanta and New York City

Our Story

Jeff and Karyn Schwerzler left New York several years ago having sold a thriving specialty cake decorating business for a chance to slow down their hectic pace and start a family. Years later, now living in a suburb north of Atlanta with two young daughters, Jeff and Karyn have taken their culinary talents one step further. As owners of The Frosted Pumpkin Gourmet - they design breathtaking wedding cakes for brides as well as Grooms cakes and special occasion cakes. 

Contact us at 770-205-7998 or


Categories: Wedding Cake

Regions serviced: Atlanta

124 Reviews for Frosted Pumpkin

out of 5.0
User Photos
todo alt text
todo alt text
todo alt text
Filter reviews by services used:
All Reviews
Consultations (23)
Delivery (23)
Setup (22)
Groom's Cake (6)
Cupcakes (1)
Sort by:


Frosted Pumpkin is AMAZING, and we LOVED our cake on our wedding day (so did all of our guests). We got married at the Georgian Terrace Hotel on April 21, 2018, and we had a 4-tier cake with alternating vanilla and chocolate layers to serve 200+ people. We met with one of the owners, Jeff, about 2 months prior to the wedding for 1.5 hours for the tasting and design meeting. He is so personable and fun, and he really took his time to get to know us and talk through details and different variations of the cake so we could get exactly what we wanted. You cannot beat the customer service, design, or taste of Frosted Pumpkin! My husband and I can't wait for our one-year anniversary to eat the topper ... but maybe we will dig in before that!

Photo of Frosted Pumpkin in Alpharetta, GA
Photo of Frosted Pumpkin in Alpharetta, GA
Photo of Frosted Pumpkin in Alpharetta, GA
Profile Picture Payton, 4/21/18, 6 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake
Services Used: Consultations, Setup, Delivery

Frosted Pumpkin cakes are not only beautiful, but they are delicious! We had a three-tier traditional wedding cake, and a two-tier grooms cake. I've had numerous guests comment to me after the wedding that it was the best wedding cake they have had - and I agree! Jeff is great to work with, and I recommend him!

Profile Picture Whitney, 4/7/18, 5 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake
Services Used: Groom's Cake, Consultations, Setup, Delivery

Jeff, the owner of the Frosted Pumpkin had us come to his house for a cake tasting. All of his cakes were delicious and he had many different different styles to choose from. He was very professional in our dealings and we didn’t need to worry about the cake after the tasting!

Profile Picture James, 11/4/17, 3 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake
Services Used: Consultations, Setup, Delivery

Frosted Pumpkin FAQ

Groom's Cake
Cake Pops
Dessert Buffet
Custom Design
Private Tastings
Health License


14 Photos

My Photo Album

14 Photos
220x220 sq 1250786655001 3
220x220 sq 1250786647658 2
220x220 sq 1250786712189 11
220x220 sq 1395168231504 img063
220x220 sq 1395168293157 frosted
220x220 sq 1395168382517 dscn076
220x220 sq 1395168476726 dscn096
220x220 sq 1395168615860 offset squarepurple abstract flowerswebre
220x220 sq 1395168638471 pipedribbo
220x220 sq 1395168714157 piped roseteswiss do
220x220 sq 1395173241223 dscn117
220x220 sq 1395173321722 dscn132
220x220 sq 1395173362533 emily and matt 141
220x220 sq 1395173454069 dscn095

Professional Network & Endorsements

Jeff and his crew at Frosted Pumpkin always exceed expectations for my clients. Their cakes are beautiful and delicious. The designs are exceptional. Thank you for your hard work and talent. I look forward to working with you again soon!

If you are looking for the most beautiful and absolute yummy cake EVER, Jeff at Frosted Pumpkin is your guy!!! We have had many wonderful opportunities to taste each delectable flavor he offers and they are all amazing!! For your wedding day cake needs, contact Jeff and you will not be disappointed!!

Frosted Pumpkin has absolutely incredible cakes that are not only beautiful but are well put together for cutting purposes and taste DELICIOUS!!! Jeff will work with brides until he gets exactly what they want and goes out of his way to meet with them and listen to them. Frosted Pumpkin is awesome!

Jeff at the Frosted Pumkin is nothing short of amazing! His Wedding Cake designs are sheer perfection and taste great! Cynthia Walton of WALTON WEDDING GROUP


221 Silver Birch CT, Alpharetta, GA 30004   See On Map
770-205-7998 (phone)