Cakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by FelicitationsCakes by Felicitations
Interested in this vendor?
About
Cakes by Felicitations is located in Friday Harbor in the beautiful San Juan Islands of Washington State. Owner, Felicity Milne has a long and exceptional reputation after more than 30 years in the culinary arts.
Felicity will meet with you personally and design a beautiful and unique cake that will look as wonderful as it tastes.
If you are wanting to WOW your guests with more than only cake, Felicitations also offers stunning dessert buffets, creative grooms cakes, party favors (of the culinary sort), delicious pastries for brunch and so much more.
Complimentary cake tastings are offered upon appointment.
All products are baked fresh from scratch and use quality ingredients. Don't settle for anything less!
Woman-owned
Vendors you may like
See other vendors that are popular with couples right now
Felicity curates amazing cake flavors and creates an amazing taste testing experience. It tasted amazing day of and was exactly what we had in mind!
Stephanie Sent on 10/02/2023
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Beautiful Cakes!
We were blown away by our cake for our wedding. Walking into the reception and seeing it made us so happy. Felicity worked closely with our florist to execute our vision and it couldn't have turned out better. My husband also loves key lime pies so she did custom mini key lime pie tarts for us that all the guests were raving about. They were so delicious. We loved working with Felicity and would recommend her services to anyone getting married on the islands.
Denae Sent on 10/13/2022
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Top notch service
Felicity did a spectacular job with our wedding cake and cupcakes. I wanted a local San Juan Island bakery to do our wedding cake, and she came highly recommended.
We didn’t have a tasting, everything was communicating via email and her forms. She nailed it! The almond cake was delicious and the cupcake decorating was gorgeous. They came and set up at the venue and took everything down afterwards without us even being there. We are planning on going back for an anniversary cake next year!
Katy Sent on 07/10/2021
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Amazing cake and smores cart
The cake was delicious and beautiful. I literally can't stop eating the leftovers! It was exactly what we asked for down to the smallest detail. The smores cart was a hit, and the homemade marshmallows were so good. Highly recommend adding the smores cart option to your wedding dessert options.
Hannah Sent on 12/29/2020
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Beautiful, tasty wedding cake
Felicity was very professional and accommodating to our many changes given a COVID wedding plan. The final product was not only delicious, but so beautiful and perfectly captured our vision! Even though our celebration was significantly downsized, the cake added the perfect wedding touch to an intimate lovely day.
Danielle Sent on 09/20/2018
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Our wedding was a party. It was the perfect combination of food, music, location, and people. But the weirdest thing happened once we cut the cake... EVERYONE got in line and then sat back down to enjoy. Seriously, everyone. I have never seen so many people take time to eat wedding cake! It was awesome! Felicity did an amazing job of both style and flavor. We also really enjoyed the tasting experience with her as she made it so fun and letting me dream big in all that I wanted... nearly naked, sprinkles, layers, colors, flowers, etc!
Molly Sent on 10/22/2017
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Wow, Felicity is amazing! We had a dessert bar at our wedding with a traditional wedding cake, assorted pies, doughnuts, and cheesecake. All of guests commented on how delicious everything was, and many went back for seconds or thirds. From the initial cake tasting consultation, Felicity was so friendly and easy to work with, and she really understood our vision. I would highly recommend Felicitations for any event you are planning!
Jarae Sent on 01/07/2016
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Felicity is a cake genius and artist. The cake she did was just amazing, and not to mention delicious. She is great at listening to your ideas and providing information and ideas. It was a pleasure working with her.
Julie Sent on 08/31/2015
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
I am still in awe over the cake that Felicity made for our wedding. It was so much more beautiful than I ever could've imagined and I was actually sad when it was time to cut it! And of course it tasted as good as it looked. We did two flavors and both of them were delicious! So many of our guests that I talked to the next morning couldn't stop talking about how good the cake was! And on top of that, Felicity was amazing to work with. We were lucky enough to make it up to the island for a tasting and it was such a great experience. And she was so helpful and flexible as we worked through changing guest counts. Thank you so much Felicity for making us such a gorgeous cake!!
Teresa Sent on 07/23/2015
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Felicity worked very well with me over the phone and even suggested things that I hadn't thought of. She made all our cupcakes in all our flavors in all of our colors. She added detail to our personal cake that matched the theme of the wedding. The taste of each flavor was so delicious! We were so so happy to have had her help us on our day!
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
