We couldn’t be happier with the wedding cake from Cake Fiction! It was absolutely delicious—moist, flavorful, and beautifully designed. Every guest raved about how amazing it tasted, and many even went back for seconds! Paula is professional, accommodating, and truly passionate about her craft. From the initial consultation to the final product, she exceeded our expectations in every way. If you’re looking for a bakery that delivers both incredible taste and stunning presentation, look no further. Highly recommend!

Cake fiction gets a 5 star review all around from us! Not only did they go above and beyond with our cake but they provided us with cupcakes that were AMAZING !! They were a pleasure to work with from the cake tasting to the set up at our ceremony. I would and plan to recommend them to anyone and everyone I come in contact with because Paula and her husband are AMAZING

From the moment I placed the order, the customer service was exceptional. They were responsive, professional, and really took the time to understand exactly what I wanted for my event.The cake itself was an amazing . The flavor was just as amazing—moist, perfectly balanced, and not overly sweet. I opted for orange blossom and it was a huge hit with my guests. It’s clear that this vendor uses high-quality ingredients, and the attention to detail really set them apart.

Loved working with Paula! She and her husband are the best. Cake making is a passion project for them and it’s evident in the quality, execution and care they take in creating your wedding cake. The cake tasting at their beautiful farm home in NJ was my favorite wedding planning activity. They were so warm and welcoming and excited to have us. The cakes are all 10/10 delicious. I wish they made cakes for all occasions.

My wedding cake was absolutely perfect—beautiful, delicious, and rustic, just the way I envisioned it. The design was simple yet elegant, with a charming rustic touch that fit our theme flawlessly. Each layer had amazing flavor, and every bite was a delightful combination of moist cake and rich, creamy frosting. The cake wasn’t just a feast for the eyes but for the taste buds as well. It added a special warmth to our celebration, and our guests couldn’t stop raving about it. A perfect centerpiece for our special day!

Cake Fiction was the perfect choice for our summer wedding in NJ. We had dealt with many bakeries that told us our desired design was "too much" or even "not possible," but Cake Fiction was confident that they could make our vision a reality. The result was a GORGEOUS three tiered cake with bold colors and all our design ideas represented. We were proud to take photographs with the cake all throughout the wedding. Some guests even stole away with the top tier of the cake (which featured an elaborate fairytale castle) into the photo booth for more cute shots. Aside from the design, the cake itself was delicious - all the combinations of filling and cake made perfect sense together. It was enjoyed by all.
From the tasting to the big day, Cake Fiction was 100% dedicated to making our vision a reality. Thanks!

This past October my partner and I worked with Paula at Cake Fiction for our wedding at Jack’s Barn in Oxford, NJ, and were so impressed! We initially set up a tasting at their kitchen/shop, which was so much fun. Paula and her husband were so lovely and their shop space is too cute! We booked them on the spot, and worked with them to design a two-tier wedding cake and a dozen cupcakes. So delicious! They were a hit at our wedding and we still receive compliments on the cake/cupcakes. We’d recommend Cake Fiction to anyone who’s looking for a tasty and unique cake/dessert for their event!

I am so glad I choose Cake Fiction
The cake was beautiful and EXACTLY what I wanted.
Thank you so much!!!!

I am so happy with choosing Cake Fiction for my wedding day! Paula did an amazing job and made the cake of my DREAMS for my Alice in Wonderland theme wedding. Our wedding cake was great, followed by some Eat Me cupcakes for our guests and best of all the Mad Hatter Tea Party Clock display cake we get to keep and cherish for years to come. Thank you again for adding the special touches to my wonderful wedding day!

Paula did such an amazing job for us. She is super responsive and the cake was perfect. And she got it all done with a last minute ask on a holiday weekend. Truly a great professional and you can see the pride in her work. Highly recommended!!!