Want my Diamond Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
Featured
Austin Sent on 01/07/2020Amazing Experience With Tony!!
Words can't describe my experience with Tony!! I was looking for a custom engagement ring to propose to my girlfriend and I had been to what felt like every diamond dealer in the jewelry district before I found Want My Diamond, and it straight up felt like I was dealing with skeezy used car salesmen all trying to rip me off. By the time I met Tony, I was already so apprehensive and just waiting to hear another aggressive pitch. EXACT OPPOSITE!! I guess he felt my nerves or something, but within 2 minutes of telling him about all the details I wanted, he said something like "This is a time to celebrate, not stress" and it really felt like he wanted to make this a happy process for me.
He gave me a crash course on diamonds, made me a computer design that was almost spot on to what was in my head, and he made me a ring that had my new fiancé feeling like a queen. Best of all, his price ended up being waaaay less than all the jerks downstairs claiming to give me their "cost pricing." Even after I paid him, picked up the ring and left, he remembered that I said I wasn't sure of her ring size, texted me, and told me he would resize it for free if I needed him to, tooootal class act. I'm so glad I found this guy!! I can't wait to see what he comes up with when I send my fiancé to him to make my wedding band HAHA. -
-
Steph Sent on 02/16/2026
Triple Excellent Jeweler
Best diamonds! Best craftsmanship! Best value!
Tony procured the perfect GIA certified natural 10 carat triple excellent round brilliant diamond of my dreams and then helped us to design the perfect platinum setting to maximize the diamond’s beauty.
From beginning to end, Tony listened and guided us through every step of the process making our shopping experience flawless!
Thank you Tony for making my dream of being in the 10 carat club come true!
-
-
![Paul]()
Paul Sent on 09/22/2025A professional who wants to create a lifelong masterpiece
From start to finish, Tony was incredibly professional, making the entire process smooth and stress-free. He communicated clearly and consistently, which made a huge difference. He took the time to really understand what my wife was looking for in a ring and made sure every detail matched her vision perfectly. We felt like he genuinely cared about getting everything just right-it wasn't just a transaction, it was a personalized experience. The pricing was very fair and transparent-no pressure, no surprises. For the quality and service, we couldn't have asked for a better value. High -quality craftsmanship without the inflated prices you often see elsewhere. Tony followed up-sending previews and updates so we always knew what to expect. The final ring exceeded our expectations-beautifully made and exactly what my wife had imagined. If you're looking for someone who combines skill, transparency, and genuine care for your vision, this is the jeweler to go with. -
![Cathy]()
Cathy Sent on 05/16/2025Tony is the best!
Tony designed my engagement ring to my exact specifications. He was very responsive throughout the entire process. He is knowledgeable and very professional. I highly recommend his services. He is the best in the business! I will definitely be using him to design my wedding bands to match my engagement ring
-
-
Scott Sent on 01/09/2025
Great Custom Jewelry Experience
Wanted to thank and recommend Tony for all the time and effort in my wife's custom ring. By far the best jewelry purchasing experience I have had. Tony was responsive at every step. Rare combination of ensuring my wife got what she wanted and making me feel comfortable with the purchase. Absolutely ZERO pressure and operates very transparently and shared progress at every step and turn of the process. Couldn't be happier with the amazing ring or the service and integrity from Tony. Couldn't recommend higher! -
-
Theo Sent on 11/01/2024
Beautiful trinkets
I recently connected with a friend I always crushed on. 30+ years later we are together. She is deserving of a beautiful ring. I will buy from Tony again. -
-
Shelley Sent on 09/13/2024
Phenomenal Experience
I cannot give this company and Tony Tala enough accolades. I was extremely nervous sending Tony a lot of money to create an 8 ct eternity ring. He called every day and answered my calls promptly when I got nervous. He sent pictures during every step of the process. I had my eternity ring in record time - just a few days. I was so happy I bought a 4ct yellow diamond that is stunning from him. I sent him my setting and he set the diamond within a week (which included shipping). I am over the moon happy with my decision to go with Tony. -
-
Jean Sent on 07/14/2024
Diamond wedding ring
Beautiful custom ring for 30th anniversary 4.2 carats, cushion set with nice complimentary baguettes -
-
Troy Sent on 04/16/2024
Wedding Set
Working with Tony was a pleasure. Service, Quality and communication exceeded our expectations. I highly recommend Wantmydiamond to anyone in the market for fine jewelry.
Troy J. -
-
Misty Sent on 03/17/2024
Flawless Transaction
Tony walked me through picking out the perfect diamond and perfect setting. Working with him was amazing. He made me feel confident and relaxed. I will definitely be a lifetime customer. Thank you Tony! This was a very special and very personal purchase. I appreciate all of your time and attention. Even the box is beautiful! -
-
![Jay]()
Jay R. Sent on 01/03/2024The perfect experience!
Crafting the perfect engagement ring is an art, and Tony truly exceeded my expectations. His attention to detail, exquisite craftsmanship, and impeccable service made the experience exceptional and unforgettable. From selecting the finest materials to understanding my preferences, Tony orchestrated a ring that symbolizes love and commitment beautifully.
I highly recommended Tony for his professionalism, skill, and the personal touch they bring to such a significant milestone.
Thank you so much Tony! You have a customer for life and I will certainly recommend you to anyone looking for the perfect engagement ring! -
-
Austin Sent on 05/07/2023
Want My Diamond
Very transparent jeweler. Responsiveness and professionalism excellent also -
-
![Candy]()
Candy Sent on 04/13/2023Beautiful experience
I chose Want My Diamond from the internet. I had no idea who or what I was dealing with but I went with my instincts and I am glad I did. It was not an insignificant purchase but it was worth the gamble. The service was excellent and the diamonds are of a high quality. Let me just say I dealt with a local dealer and I ended up getting a ring that was not what I wanted. My advise is buy from Want My Diamond and you will hub get excellent service and a piece of jewelry you will be proud to wear.
-
Dianne Sent on 12/02/2022
Great treatment
Tony is knowledgeable and patient. He outdid himself and understood 100% what I was looking for. My ring has had many many compliments. -
-
D B D. Sent on 09/09/2022
Widower’s next chapter
After losing my wife of 35 years to cancer 4 years ago I needed a very special symbol to express my love and commitment to the 2nd great love in my life. I wanted the next link in the chain of my life to be very special, not a ring between young people starting a life together but instead a clear connecting point between 2 established families. Tony provided a stunning piece that says we will spend the rest of our lives together. -
-
![Joshua]()
Joshua Sent on 06/08/2022The most amazing quality and value for money
The ring and diamond far exceeded my expectations, the quality, price, and overall process were on par if not better than the commercial jewelry companies. 5 stars and highly reccomended. -
-
Joe Sent on 03/13/2022
Great experience
This was so easy and Tony was extremely helpful and communicative. Highly recommended! -
-
Vitaly Sent on 12/31/2021
Engagement ring
Wonderful experience in such important moment, my request was done amazing, good job and beautiful people. Thank you very much! -
-
Coury Sent on 12/23/2021
Excellent top notch sales experience
Being a luxury car dealer across the country I realize the importance of customer satisfaction. It was a top notch experience from start to finish. Any questions were a phone call away! I highly recommend Want my diamond, -
-
Michael Sent on 12/11/2021
Great communication - very prompt
Ring was absolutely gorgeous. Far better than I expected and pictures didn't do it justice. Seller bent over backwards to make it a very positive experience. Always willing to take call and chat about transaction. I highly recommend. Oh, and she said yes ;). -
-
Case Sent on 11/02/2021
Exceptional service from Tony! He went above and beyond to me create my yellow diamond ring.
Shopping online made us very skeptical. After talking to Tony and seeing all of his designs created for his other clients. We decided to trust his service to help create and design my yellow diamond. I could not be happier with my ring, even our friends love it too!
Give Tony and his company a chance to create your dream piece of jewelry. You won’t be disappointed. The craftsmanship and artistic skills are like no other. Not to mention how honest Tony is when it comes to explaining quality of diamonds, metals and designs. Every little details are very important. Tony and his company has the patience and skills for all clients needs.
-
-
![Jean]()
Jean Sent on 11/01/2021Upgrading wedding ring after 30 + years of marriage
WMD was great to work with every step of the way from initial discussions thru stone selections and settings and production to final (beautiful) ring. They were also helpful with financing options. -
-
![Konstantinos]()
Konstantinos Sent on 10/14/2021Tony is Amazing
My name is K. Gus Dimitrelos and I am a retired US Secret Service agent and CEO of Cyber Forensics. The reason for the background is I was skeptical of making an online ring purchase for our 10yr anniversary present. Tony is legit, trustworthy and the ring arrived today as promised and it is stunning. I am available via email to verify my purchase and experience and will use his services for life. gus@cyberforensics.com -
R Fox Sent on 10/02/2021
Amazing Ring for our 40th Anniversary
I found WMD and Tony via eBay and was drawn by the wonderful reviews. Let me say that if I could leave 10 stars I would. Tony worked with me every step of the way, helped with an amazing center stone selection and designed a breath taking ring. My wife will be speechless when she receives this as we renew our wedding vows. Highly recommend Tony and WMD. -
-
Donnie Sent on 09/14/2021
One of a kind Bracelet fit for Royalty
Tony custom made this stunning bracelet for my wife for her 65th birthday. When she opened the box it took her breath away. Tony kept me updated and involved (almost daily) during the production process and let me pick the jewels. His knowledge of precious stones and the art of jewelry is phenomenal. -
-
Jacalyn Sent on 07/09/2021
Cannot Say Enough How Wonderful This Vendor Is!
Tony at WMD was amazing to work with. He couldn't have been more helpful in designing my ring which I just received today and it was beyond my expectations. I actually screamed when I opened the box because the ring was so gorgeous. He is a professional and warm gentleman and I feel that I not only found a new jeweler, but also a new friend. He is absolutely wonderful!
-
-
![Jordan]()
Jordan Sent on 07/06/2021The Best Surprise!
I am so in love with the work of Want My Diamond! I received the most beautiful surprise for my anniversary with my boyfriend, the matching diamond and opal earrings and ring took my breath away. I am obsessed with both of them and truly admire the skill and talent that went into them. -
-
Svetlana Sent on 03/24/2021
Absolutely Super!
Great service. Very attentive and ready to answer all additional questions. The selection of diamond is approached very carefully, offering a variety of options for any budget. I live in Europe, I ordered a super ring with a yellow diamond. Goel was always in touch with me. After choosing a diamond, they helped me with the selection of the frame, responding to all my wishes! Thank you very much! I love my ring!
Update 16.10.2022
I ordered one more ring, it's perfect!
Thank you! -
-
![Thomas]()
Thomas Sent on 02/20/2021Excellent Product & Customer Experience
Amazing product. Beautiful craftsmanship. GIA certified diamonds at the highest quality for the price. Tony provides superior customer service. If you want diamond jewelry, this is the place to go! -
-
![Brittney]()
Brittney Sent on 02/15/2021Love my ring
I adore the custom engagement ring I designed with my fiance and Tony. I sent photos of different ring styles and eventually came up with the perfect thing. I'd highly recommend them to anyone looking to get the job done fast and right! -
-
![Mrs. E]()
Mrs, Sent on 01/18/2021Tony Rocks!!
We met Tony by chance and we’re so thankful we did! Tony is not only a diamond expert, he is also very passionate about his work and he makes his client’s satisfaction, his top priority. We purchased a stunning 5.52 emerald cut diamond eternity band. The ring was a little snug and because we live out of the area and we wanted to take the ring with us, Tony went the extra mile and sent the piece to his repairer to have the ring size enlarged. An hour later, the ring fit perfectly. Such a great experience with a delightful guy. Thanks again Tony! -
Nancy Sent on 12/30/2020
High quality, awesome vendor
I love, love this bracelet. It's beautiful -
-
![Dorothy]()
Dorothy Sent on 12/30/2020Tony and his jeweler listened to everything I said and turned it into the most magnificent ring ever. I didn’t even know how to explain what I wanted
I cannot speak highly enough of Tony with Want my Diamond! Omg I received my ring that they designed just for me today. IT IS Gorgeous!!! Tony and his jeweler listened to everything I said and turned it into the most magnificent ring ever. I didn’t even know how to explain what I wanted but somehow they knew. If you ever have a chance to work with these people, you will not be disappointed. Looking forward to my next adventure with them. -
-
![Dr.]()
Dr. N. Sent on 12/21/2020Want My Diamond "Outstanding"
Want my Diamonds is "Absolutely the Best Experience" for purchasing diamonds! Tony was very responsive, accommodating and had a great deal of patience! These are truly qualities you want from someone when purchasing diamonds! I would highly recommend him to everyone as he's been the best person I've dealt with for purchasing exquisite certified diamonds. I've attached a photo to view his quality of custom work and design! OUTSTANDING!!! -
-
Lewis Sent on 10/16/2020
Superb service!!
il oriented, and fair pricing company I have ever worked with. They quality of my wife and my wedding rings are top notch! Thank you for making day special. -
-
![Cate]()
Cate Sent on 10/08/2020If at first you don’t succeed...
I worked with Tony last Christmas on a combination Christmas, birthday, anniversary ring, a very important piece of jewelry, for reasons I won’t go into. He made me a beautiful ring but after wearing it for a couple of months, I realized I had made some mistakes in my design. I contacted Tony and asked for a “do over” and he graciously agreed to start over. Well, let me tell you, the ring we came up with, keeping only the large cushion cut canary diamond the same and replacing everything else, even the color of the gold, is absolutely stunning! I can’t stop looking at it! He was very patient with me and I am now over the moon about my ring. Thank you again, Tony, for making me very happy. -
![Pamela]()
Pamela Sent on 06/10/2020Beautiful ring!
Tony worked with us to provide the most beautiful diamond engagement ring. There is no one else I would buy diamond jewelry from. Excellent service...gorgeous ring! -
Denise Sent on 06/08/2020
Glad I found Want My Diamond
The reviews speak volumes, and I was confident having a ring made by Tony. We communicated regularly through the process, and I had exactly the ring I wanted in 10 days ! Thank you,
Denise M London Canada
-
-
Terry Sent on 03/01/2020
Exceptional Service, Price and Quality!
I am US military stationed in Italy and found Want My Diamond (Tony) on eBay. I was interested in a bridal set and men's band, and after a lot of back and forth with questions via email, ultimately decided to give my business to WMD. Communication was exceptional as was end product quality! Tony was patient and exceeded my expectations every step of the way as we worked together to decide every detail of these custom crafted rings. I was provided pictures along the manufacturing process and the final products are amazing! I'm grateful for the results and after having spent time comparing prices, I feel I was given a very fair deal. For anyone considering high-quality, fair priced, custom rings, I highly recommend you contact WMD! Terry W. -
-
![Michelle]()
Michelle Sent on 02/28/2020Va va voom ring!
I just wanted to let everyone know, that out of every Jewelry store in my hometown, doesn't even come close to this ring on my finger! I thought about how I would write this review, and nothing can compare to the SERVICE! When they ask for a 5 star review, I don't think even 5 Stars can give it credit! When I look at my ring, I see more then just a ring, and everything involved in making this! It should be a 10 STAR++++++++++ Across the board! I truly THANK-YOU GOEL! For taking the time to make sure everything turned out special! AND IT DID! Way beyond my expectations, I appreciate everything you have done for US! Thank you!! :-))) -
-
![Natasha]()
Natasha Sent on 12/10/2019Tony the man behind Want My Diamond is AMAZING!
I was visiting LA in search of a diamond bracelet for my birthday. After extensive research I ran across amazing reviews about Want My Diamond. I did not have an appointment and showed up to their office unannounced, yet Tony met with me and catered to my every need all while staying within my price range. Tony’s attention to detail is remarkable and his passion for the diamond business is impressive. Most importantly, Tony is an exceptional gentleman. My bracelet is beautiful and I’m so happy I found Tony. My boyfriend and I picked out some engagement rings in our home town but we changed our mind and will be designing our rings with Tony very soon. I’m so happy I found Want My Diamond as I’ll be using Tony for all my jewelry needs. -
![Glenda]()
Glenda Sent on 03/26/2019Dr. Glenda Memphis, TN
My experience with Tony, and Want My Diamond was beyond all I could have wanted. The quality of my custom diamond engagement ring met my high standards, and I received all of the GIA paperwork with my ring. -
Are you interested?
Are you interested?