Mama Stortini's Restaurant - Puyallup Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
Lauren Sent on 01/20/2026
Absolutely amazing!!
We had an amazing experience with our wedding caterer from start to finish. The food tasting was incredible, and when my parents couldn’t make it, the team was kind enough to box up food for us to take home to them—such a thoughtful touch that meant a lot to us.
The staff was always so friendly and quick to answer any questions, which made the planning process easy and stress-free. On the day of the wedding, they went above and beyond. The manager personally brought us our dinner and even started us off with two drinks each, which was such a nice gesture and really helped us relax and enjoy the moment.
The bartenders were friendly, funny, and a huge hit with our guests—everyone loved them. Even now, people are still talking about how great the food was. We couldn’t recommend this catering team more! -
-
![Talisha]()
Talisha Sent on 07/01/2024Delicious food!!
Sooo delicious! We had chicken parm and noodles with three choices of sauces. I delicious salad and fruit. All the food was hot even though there were no kitchen hook ups. The caterers checked on us multiple times and their service was so professional and lovely! -
![Alex]()
Alex Sent on 04/20/2020Perfect!!!
Everyone at mama Stortini’s was so helpful and kind. Answering all my little questions and concerns. And of course the food was delicious!!! -
![Cassandra]()
Cassandra Sent on 08/11/2019Absolutely amazing!!!!
We got married August 2 of this year and booked this caterer last year so we had a lot of time to plan and coordinate. Meryl was absolutely AMAZING. She is knowledgeable, professional, and just an overall kind genuine person. She gave us really good advice and knew her stuff! To be honest, me and my mom felt like a deer in head lights and we don’t know what we would have done without her. She also recommended an amazing wedding planner for us. We had 250 guests and I am still getting compliments on how great the food was. I am Vietnamese so I was worried the food would disappointed my family because it wasn’t our traditional food and they were loving it!!!! They couldn’t stop talking about it! Very pleased with the staff and how much they helped make the wedding run smoothly. Thanks again!!! -
Alyssa Sent on 07/12/2019
Would recommend!
Very easy to work with, great food, plenty of options to customize your own menu! -
-
![JODIE]()
Jodie Sent on 03/14/2019Above and beyond
As the mother of the bride & wedding planner. Our experience was outstanding. I was able to enjoy the reception without having to micromanage, a few things were verified and that was it. Food was just like at the tasting. Just Perfect! -
![Nikaela]()
Nikaela Sent on 12/27/2018The Best Wedding Meal Ever
Mama Stortini's really hit it out of the park. We chose the tuscan chicken meal plan with 3 different kinds of sauces and I'm so glad we did! We were going to go with a more traditional steak & potato choice, but this option blew us away at the tasting. I worked with Meryl and Jade, who were SO incredibly responsive it made everything so easy. They worked to help us get everything we wanted while staying in-budget. The food was the most delicious food I've had at a wedding (yes, I'm bias!) and our guests keep raving over the Tuscan Chicken. they even sent us home with the leftovers and we've been eating off it for most of the week. We would absolutely recommend them to everyone! -
![Mrs.]()
Mrs. Sent on 11/11/2018Great food and service
Working with Meryl was seamless, the food was perfect, the service at the wedding was awesome! The employees were helpful, upbeat, friendly. We had many compliments and as an added bonus, the price was perfect! They do all the setup, supply everything, bartend, cake cut, we had nothing to worry about on our special day! Highly recommend! -
Merrilee Sent on 06/08/2018Meryl and Jade were absolutely amazing to work with! They helped me with not just catering but with other vendors I might need! So many compliments on the food and table settings!
-
-
![Kate]()
Kate Sent on 10/27/2018Above and Beyond Experience
We used Mama Stortinis as the caterer for our wedding but they did much more than just catering! They were an amazing one stop shop for rentals (linens, china, glassware, chargers, chandelier, food, desserts, drinks, bartender and bar) and brought support staff that helped my set up crew of friends and family and did an amazing job assisting with the flow of the reception. Stortinis had worked with Events on 6th (wedding venue) before and knew the place well. With Mama Stortinis and my own set up crew the day ran beautifully without a single hitch!! Getting to go to the rental place and pick out all the rentals and set up an example table was such a wonderful service and made it fun! Also getting to go to the restaurant for the food tasting and picking out which dishes was wonderful. Our guest enjoyed the food and desserts! And Stortinis set up and ran our bar with one of their bartenders. Even had several people who helped with the table set ups and keeping water glasses full and clearing up plates. They went above and beyond and even made us a cute wooden decor sign with our initials and wedding date inside a heart which we now keep in our house. Pleasantly surprised at there above-and-beyond professionalism and quality service. Would not have been able to do the wedding without them! Highly recommend!!!
-
-
![Danae]()
Danae Sent on 01/18/2014Mama Stortinis was wonderful! We used them as our recent wedding caterer and couldn't believe how great they were. Meryl and Jade were so flexible and quick on responding to my emails and phone calls. You can customize your menu to your liking and the rental place they work with is great as well. We had so many compliments on our food and how well the wait staff was. They also cleaned up and provided all the linens and china and did not charge us to cut our cake or serve at our dessert bar. Future brides you will not be disappointed with Mama Stortinins Catering Services. -
![Justin & Jamie]()
Jamie Sent on 08/31/2014Enjoyed the Milan room for our wedding party and parents for the rehearsal dinner. The fact that we got our own room was great. The food was wonderful. Waitress just didn't seem to be overly happy.
Are you interested?
Are you interested?