Girl Meets Cake Reviews
Reviews
4.9 out of 5 rating
4.9 out of 5 rating
128 Reviews
97% recommend it
Awards
-
Sameen A. Sent on 03/20/2023
Spectacular
Extremely sweet Baker.
Delicious cake. -
-
Jacquelyn K. Sent on 10/18/2022
Awesome Wedding Cake!
We loved working with Girl Meets Cake! Misty made us a dozen cupcakes so we could try multiple flavors before we decided on our final three. She delivered the cake right on time, decorated with the flowers and cake topper we asked for and was really responsive to our venue coordinator's needs. Highly recommend! -
-
![Meghan]()
Meghan H. Sent on 06/29/2022Beyond accommodating vendor & delicious cake!
Misty was suggested to me by my planner Katie of Tilly & Teal. I’m so happy she was! We first connected via zoom to talk about my husband & I’s favorite flavors for our future wedding cake & I just LOVED Misty. She was so sweet. She made us the most gorgeous cake complimented by tiny marzipan mushrooms (mushroom foraging is one of our favorite things to do together). We picked her “lemon lovers” flavor which is a lemon cake with raspberry filling & vanilla buttercream. It was the best cake I’ve ever eaten in my life. On top of Misty’s amazing baking & decorating work, I found a pig cake topper on etsy & it tied everything together so well! Our pet pigs couldn’t attend the wedding so this was the best we could do 😂 We love you Misty! Thank you for being so accommodating & remaking our anniversary cake after our catering team cut & served it 🤦♀️ You rule! Love, Meghan & Finley. -
-
Meghan H. Sent on 05/18/2022
Amazing Cake!!
A beautiful cake with amazing flavor and the best baker! Misty was very communicative and really listened to what we envisioned our cake to be! All of the guests loved it and are still raving about it!!! -
-
Will C. Sent on 05/19/2022
Amazing! Must hire!
Girl Meets Cake went above and beyond our expectations with our wedding cake and desserts! Misty was so fun to work with and her passion for what she is doing really shows!
Our guests had nothing but great things to say about them! Not only did everything look beautiful it tasted amazing! She even was able to pull off personalized husky cookies to make it extra special as our two dogs were a part of our big day! We highly recommend Misty and Girl Meets Cake for you wedding or dessert needs! -
-
![Rebecca]()
Rebecca T. Sent on 04/21/2022My Dream Cake
I planned my wedding out of state and didn’t have time to meet any vendors before the day. When I say that my cake was beyond my dreams I mean it. From the taste to the look I was beyond happy! I couldn’t believe how perfectly my dream cake was created. Absolutely amazing. -
![Lola]()
Lola A. Sent on 11/07/2019Creativity at it's finest
Misty was a delight during our cake tasting. She was super excited to work on our two cakes after we gave her the details of our multicultural two day wedding event. Misty is a joy to be around and that energy shows in her work. I can't wait to see her final creations. Misty is an amazing, quality, and professional baker, you wouldn't be disappointed. -
![Angel]()
Angel Sent on 12/25/2021Perfection
Misty is amazing. She is so kind and was helpful and patient with us from the very start. She worked with us to make a cake that matched our wedding theme and she NAILED IT! We absolutely loved our cake and so did our guests. She is such a talented and warm person. We are so happy we went with her for our special day. Thank you for making our wedding just perfect, Misty!!!Girl Meets Cake's reply:
Thank you so much Angel - this review seriously made my day!! The great feelings are absolutely mutual - it was an absolute pleasure to make your cake.
Can't wait to see you for your 1st Anniversary! I wish you both a lifetime of love and happiness. ~Misty -
-
![Ashley]()
Ashley Sent on 01/08/2022Great customer service!
Misty at Girl Meets Cake was phenomenal! We did a pickup tasting during the pandemic and we loved what Misty put together for us. We decided to go with cupcakes for our wedding so everyone could pick their favorite flavor! She had some awesome flavor combinations with the cake, icings and fillings. You could seriously get whatever your heart desired! Misty was super professional, responsive and flexible. There was a little hiccup with the payment (as I sent it to the wrong address), but Misty still held our date and was reassuring during the entire process! She was so easy to work with! Everyone loved the cupcakes! My only suggestion would be to ask her if she could supply some sort of cardboard or plastic container for extras the day of. Our caterer didn't have any extra containers and Misty didn't provide any, so the leftover cupcakes had to be tossed. Super super sad about that since the groom and I didn't get to have one at the reception. Misty also did the cupcakes for my bridal shower, so I know they are delicious. I would recommend her and certainly buy cupcakes or a cake from her again in the future!Girl Meets Cake's reply:
Hi Ashley,
Thank you so much for the great review! I loved your cupcake display so much - that stand was amazing. It was an absolute pleasure to work with you.
I'm so sorry that you had to throw the extra cupcakes out! I always leave boxes at the venue so that doesn't happen, usually under the skirt of the cake table. I did tell one of the catering staff but also should have let you know that ahead of time - what a bummer! If you get a craving for your flavors anytime just let me know & I will be happy to get you some goodies, on me, during a tasting weekend.
I wish you guys all the best - hope to see you for your 1 year anniversary. ~Misty -
-
User2326656 Sent on 09/21/2015Misty was a delight to work with. The bride and groom picked out a combination of cake designs and flavors.
The cake came out gorgeous! It was delicious as well! Misty is very accommodating.Girl Meets Cake's reply:
Thank you so much! My most favorite thing to hear is that the cake was delicious & gorgeous - that is always my goal!! It was such a pleasure and I am so glad everyone was pleased. -
![Sarah]()
Sarah Sent on 11/21/2019Misty was a life-saver!
Misty at Girl Meets Cake saved the day when I called her just 11 days before my wedding needing a new wedding cake since my other vendor fell through. We spoke on the phone and within a few minutes we had a plan for her to make my wedding cake. She was so helpful and delivered the most gorgeous cake - it was exactly as I had dreamed it would be. My guests at my wedding couldn't stop talking about how good the cake was *especially the Carrot Cake layer*! I highly recommend working with Girl Meets Cake - you won't regret it! -
-
![Natalie]()
Natalie M. Sent on 10/05/2019Elegant, custom-flavored cake, great value and service
We loved working with Misty! She did a custom flavor for us - cardamom-orange with amaretto buttercream and a cherry filling. The cake was four-tiered and elegant. It was our only dessert (we ordered extra sheet cakes to feed all 300 guests). We loved it, felt great about the value, and enjoyed the process.Girl Meets Cake's reply:
Thank you so much for your review & the gorgeous photos Natalie!! I am so happy that you guys loved your cake. Thank you for opening my eyes to the amazing flavor combo of cardamom-orange! It will absolutely be added to my flavors list next year. I wish you both the best - it was an absolute pleasure. ~Misty -
-
Caroline Sent on 10/28/2019
Beautiful Cake
I would highly recommend Misty for your wedding. She did such a great job and very affordable! I loved the way the cake turned out and it was classic yet gorgeous! And it tasted amazing! One of my family members who is really into wedding cake said it was the best wedding cake they have ever had! You won't be disappointed in Misty, she really does such an amazing job!Girl Meets Cake's reply:
Thank you so much Caroline!! I enjoyed meeting you & making your cake. It makes me so happy to know that you loved it & I will take "best wedding cake" every day of the week!! Thank you again & I wish you both the best. ~Misty -
-
07265870F625773D9C9388F0219307E99E6132Ce Sent on 07/21/2019
Amazing cake!
I called around 20 cake places and Misty was by far the most responsive, enthusiastic, but most importantly - the cake was absolutely delicious! We had cake enough for 125 people and only 110 guests, and ALL of the cake was gone by the end of the wedding. The value of her cake is also the best you will find. She is fair with her prices (actually she's generous haha), cake tasting is so easy and great, and her flavor options are awesome. We had a vanilla cake for one tier, chocolate for tier 2 and 3, buttercream frosting, raspberry puree, and a buttercream outer frosting. All of our guests specifically came up to me to say how much they enjoyed the cake. 10000000% recommend. You will not be disappointed. -
-
![Ginny]()
Virginia F. Sent on 04/30/2019Delicious and perfect cake!
Not only were Misty's cake the most delicious cakes I ever tasted, it was absolutely beautiful! She even made a custom cake topper that I couldn't find anywhere and it was perfect. I had a last minute request to add some cupcakes and she was so easy and accommodating. I couldn't speak more highly of Misty and her delicious cakes! Absolutely perfect in every way!Girl Meets Cake's reply:
Thank you so much for your amazing review Ginny! I am so glad that you loved your cake & cupcakes. I enjoyed making everything, especially the cute bunny toppers! ~Misty -
-
Rita S. Sent on 05/15/2019
Amazing Wedding Cake
Misty was amazing!!! the cake was beautiful and the flavors were amazing! Misty went above and beyond to make sure she delivery the cake of our dreams. -
-
Stacy Sent on 08/28/2018I loved working with Misty at Girl Meets Cake. She took our ideas and helped us build them into something magical. On the wedding day, people were awed by our cakes, and they tasted great, too. I would love to use her again for other parties. She's not just a great baker - she's fun to talk to as well!
-
-
Nancy Sent on 08/05/2018First off, I want to say that Misty is super sweet and was so accommodating to what we wanted! My then fiance and I were super surprised by how much wedding cakes cost when we first started doing research for our budget. It was shocking and we really didn't know if we could afford a cake. So we then decided to stick with only cupcakes because they were less expensive. I joined a wedding Facebook group for my area and I kept seeing Girl Meets Cake pop up as a recommendation. I went on her website and reached out to her telling her my vision of a cake and cupcake combination for our wedding that was within our budget. She set up a meeting with us and her presentation was very professional, we were really impressed with the set up. Not to mention we got to taste 5 different flavors of very yummy cake with leftovers to take home! What she charges is very affordable and the designs of the cakes/cupcakes are beautiful. Our guests loved all the flavors so much that they went back for seconds. Not only did we end up with deliciously decorated cupcakes on our wedding day, we were able to have a 2 layer octagon cake with a separate anniversary tier to take home! Everything turned out fantastic and I would definitely book with her again!
Girl Meets Cake's reply:
Thank you so much for this incredible review Nancy! I enjoyed working with you so much & these positive words were just the "icing on the cake"!! Congratulations & I'll see you for your anniversary!! -
Are you interested?
Send a message
Are you interested?
Send a message