Skip to main content
Weddings
ARE YOU A VENDOR?

Wedding Cakes in New Albany

illustration clipboard
Build your team 0/14

1 result

  • Carrie’s Sugar Buzz
    Carrie’s Sugar Buzz
    Carrie’s Sugar Buzz
    Carrie’s Sugar Buzz
    Carrie’s Sugar Buzz View 11 more photos

    Carrie’s Sugar Buzz

    5.0 (8)
     · New Albany, OH

    Setup Delivery Custom Design Dessert Buffet Dietary

Other options near New Albany, OH

  • The Pastry Bar
    Wedding cake
    Wedding cake
    Bridal shower set up
    Cake shooters
    Bridal shower set up
    Initial cookies
    Cookies
    Bride and groom pretzels
    Wedding cake View 42 more photos
    Popular with couples

    The Pastry Bar

    5.0 (10)
     · Columbus, OH

    The Pastry Bar is a home bakery in Columbus, OH, offering a variety of desserts for any event. We specialize in wedding...Read more cakes and provide a line of wedding and bridal party desserts. From cookies to cake shooters, we are your one-stop shop for all your sweet tooth needs. We offer cake tastings in...

    Setup Delivery Custom Design Dessert Buffet Dietary
    $100 starting price
    Responds within 24 hours
  • Jan Kish la petite fleur
    Halloween Made in Heaven
    Where Fondant Rosettes Began
    Austin Scarlett Wedding Dress
    Rear Window View 10 more photos

    Jan Kish la petite fleur

    5.0 (11)
     · Columbus, OH

    Choosing Jan Kish La Petite Fleur makes a statement! It says you believe in love, elegance, and the art of creativity....Read more Let Jan create and inspire a wedding cake of distinction that reflects the unique love you have for each other, or the memorable event you are about to celebrate. The cake Jan will...

    Setup Delivery Custom Design Dessert Buffet Dietary
    $350 starting price
    Responds within 24 hours
  • Capital City Cakes
    Tiered cake
    Wedding cake
    Floral cake
    Cupcakes
    Beautiful design
    Silver accents
    Unique cake
    Capital City Cakes
    Capital City Cakes View 14 more photos
    Award winner

    Capital City Cakes

    4.7 (53)
     · Grove City, OH

    Capital City Cakes is a family-owned bakery located in charming downtown Grove City, Ohio. Owned and operated by Sue and...Read more Gary Baisden, this business has been creating dream cakes that make clients smile since 2009. Not only do they offer a variety of flavor options, but they also customize each cake...

    Setup Delivery Custom Design Dessert Buffet
    Responds within 24 hours
  • Our CupCakery
    Lacey Sweetheart cake
    Cake and cupcake display
    Mini cupcakes for days
    Buttercream cake, fresh flower View 70 more photos

    Our CupCakery

    4.8 (79)
     · Dublin, OH

    Our CupCakery is a bakery in Dublin, Ohio, that specializes in wedding cakes and custom designs. This family...Read more owned-and-operated business offers a variety of desserts such as cakes, cookies, cupcakes, cake pops, and other sweet treats. From custom tiered wedding cakes to unique cupcake towers and...

    Setup Delivery Custom Design Dessert Buffet Dietary
    $400 starting price
  • Sweet & Shiny
    Buttercream cake with piping
    Fondant ombre
    Dahlia cake
    Invite matching View 9 more photos

    Sweet & Shiny

    5.0 (9)
     · Columbus, OH

    Based in Columbus, Ohio, Sweet & Shiny is a wedding cake company. Owner Elaine has more than 20 years of experience in...Read more the wedding and events industry and first opened this business in 2011. She has a degree in glass blowing, which influences her baking. She specializes in uniquely sculpted,...

    Setup Delivery Custom Design Dietary
    $350 starting price
  • Sogno Sweets
    Sogno Sweets
    Mini Sandwich
    Toppings
    Sogno Sweets View 18 more photos

    Sogno Sweets

    5.0 (3)
     · Columbus, OH

    Sogno Sweets is a brand new, women-owned wedding catering business serving the Northeast Ohio, and beyond, areas, that...Read more launched in the summer of 2024. At 24, co-owners, Adriana and Syd, quickly learned that life was about being whole-heartedly present with the people and moments that matter most,...

    Setup Custom Design
    $500 starting price
  • Sauer Cakes, LLC
    Sauer Cakes, LLC
    Sauer Cakes, LLC
    Sauer Cakes, LLC
    Sauer Cakes, LLC View 27 more photos

    Sauer Cakes, LLC

    4.7 (55)
     · Gahanna, OH

    Sauer Cakes, LLC provides customized cakes for all your special occasions. We work hard to provide unique and artful...Read more creations that taste as good as they look! We are located in Gahanna, but services all central Ohio couples. We pride ourselves in working closely with couples to design exquisite...

    Setup Delivery Dietary
    $250 starting price
  • Cookie Momster House
    Custom Sugar Cookies
    Cutting Cake with Cupcake Towe
    Textured Cutting Cake
    Rustic Floral View 9 more photos

    Cookie Momster House

    5.0 (7)
     · Blacklick, OH

    Cookie Momster House is a bakery in Blacklick, Ohio that specializes in customized cakes and cookies. This skilled team...Read more can go outside of the box to design a unique flavor profile for your desserts or help you create the traditional cake you have envisioned. Services Offered The talented bakers at...

    Setup Delivery Custom Design Dessert Buffet Dietary
    $250 starting price
  • Gigis Cupcakes
    Wedding Cake
    Red velvet delights
    Chocolate treats
    Fun cupcakes View 16 more photos

    Gigis Cupcakes

    Hilliard, OH

    Operating out of Hillard, Ohio, Gigis Cupcakes is a wedding cake company that offers a selection of sweet treats for all...Read more kinds of special occasions. The business employs a team of talented bakers who have been crafting delicious treats for over a decade. More importantly, you'll get to add a touch...

    Setup Delivery Custom Design Dietary
    $65 starting price
  • Three Bites Bakery
    Irish coffee cake and desserts
    Almond cake & vanilla sheets
    Pistachio orange honey cake
    Chocolate orange cake View 8 more photos

    Three Bites Bakery

    5.0 (7)
     · Columbus, OH

    Three Bites Bakery is a business based out of Columbus, Ohio specializing in wedding cakes and other decadent desserts....Read more Owner Isabella Bonello offers a decade of professional culinary experience. Using flowers and other natural elements, each cake that is made is a unique creation. Three Bites...

    Setup Delivery Custom Design Dessert Buffet Dietary

Wedding Cakes near New Albany, OH

See other couples' reviews of Wedding Cakes in New Albany

Carrie’s Sugar Buzz
5.0 (8) · Wedding Cakes · New Albany
Samuel
Samuel
5.0 out of 5 rating

I have been ordering cakes from Carrie's Cakes for years. My wife bakes a lot, but when I first ordered her cake years ago she said don't buy me another from nowhere else but from Carrie's. 😂 I just picked up another cake today 6.6.2024. Her professionalism is great and she always replies. And she is very flexible when it comes to picking up her cakes!! As long as she's baking I'm ordering!

The Royal Cupcakery
5.0 (1) · Wedding Cakes · New Albany
J
Jerry
5.0 out of 5 rating

This wasn't either of our first weddings which meant we were looking for a different approach than usually required by first timers. It helped that we knew what we wanted too. Because of the location for our wedding we had chosen, there were certain things we had to take into consideration, among the most important, time. Time for set up, time for the event, and time for clean up. From the very beginning, we had envisioned not going the traditional route of a tiered wedding cake, but that of a tiered cupcake tree with a small topper for the traditional cake cutting. This helped by eliminating the need to spend time in cutting and plating cake for 100 people. My now wife found the Royal Cupcakery using a local site and the fun began. When we met to discuss the wedding and their offerings, they brought us a couple of samples. OMG! We sat and reviewed their website which listed what seemed to be an endless choice of cakes, frostings, and presentations. Luckily, we knew what we wanted ahead of time or making the choices would have taken a really long time. We chose four different cupcakes: devil's food with cinnamon infused chocolate frosting (my fav), carrot cake, traditional white cake, and a key lime cake with lemon frosting tinted green to match our colors. All were dusted with sparkles because, well, because it was a wedding. The stand we chose was solid and fit perfectly with the decor and the style of the room. For $25, they provided a dozen cupcakes so that we could sample our flavor choices. Can you imagine being on a sugar high for a whole week? It was heaven! On the day of the wedding, they arrived right on schedule and set up the tree, cupcakes, and topper cake so that it looked just like all of the pictures. Everyone was professional from day one. Their pricing was better than reasonable and the service was exceptional. And the cupcakes? Even though about 80% of those invited and planned for made it, there were only 12 left over.

Search Beyond Wedding Cakes in Columbus

Show more

Other vendors in Columbus for your wedding

Wedding Vendors