My husband and I had a tough task of finding a cake vendor for our out of state wedding. We knew what we wanted our cake to look like but as for taste we had no way of tasting before our wedding day. All my husband and I had to go by was yelp reviews and photos on websites.
We were very lucky to have found Sugar Mill Cake Co. After checking out the website and looking through the careful to detail on the cakes, we knew Sugar Mill was a great choice. From the start, Jessica was very sweet and replied diligently to our emails. Since my husband and I couldn’t attend our cake tasting, we sent over my groomsmaid, his fiancé and our wedding planner. Jessica accommodated them and she had a wide variety of cake, frosting and filling samples. My groomsmaid’s fiancé took a video of the entire session, so when we watched it we felt like we actually attended all the way from NYC. Jessica allowed us to mix and match the flavors and gave us her valued opinion. We ended up picking a 4 tier cake, to feed 80 guest, with two flavors, almond cake with vanilla icing and salted caramel filling as well as chocolate cake with chocolate icing and raspberry preserves. When we received the quote after our selection, we were very happy it was so affordable compared to other price quotes we received for a 3 tier cake.
On our wedding day, we were eager to try it! It looked so beautiful, it was exactly the way we wanted it, even though there was a slight crack in the fondant. The cake was amazing! My husband and I were worried that the fondant would taste bad, but it was really good! The cake was very moist and the buttercream was smooth and light. It didn’t have a heave cream or cake taste. It was sweet but not to sweet, it was just perfect. Our guests were raving about the cake for the rest of the night and that it was the best that they had ever had. It was the best we had ever had as well.
The next day, my husband and I had to head back home to NYC and we took our top tier with us on th
