What an amazing experience working with Marc, Jacqueline, and the Jay Feder Jewelers team. I've been a customer of this family business for over 20 years. It's their service, value, and eye for design that keeps me coming back. The entire process of creating a custom-designed engagement ring including the selection of a loose diamond was done online and through FaceTime conversations. There's no other place I would go for jewelry purchases. Thank you!

Jay Feder Jewelers is the epitomy of what it means to go above and beyond for their customers.

Last February I met the girl of my dreams and after a few months I found myself thinking about something I had never before thought about, proposing. With that thought came the realization that I would need to buy a ring. As a result I started researching rings and where the best place to buy a ring would be. I told my dad I was thinking about proposing and he said you need to go to Jay Feder. He told me that he was one of Jay’s first customers in the 1980’s. I was a bit skeptical at first, because they didn’t show up in my research and my now fiancé had her heart set on a specific style of ring. So in an effort to humor my dad I agreed to meet with Jay Feder Jewelers, believing that I would end up buying the ring for my fiancé at a more well known jeweler.

I walked in for my appointment and none of the ring options fit what my fiancé was hoping for in a ring. I figured that I would have to look elsewhere. Denise, the representative I was working with, asked for examples of rings my fiancé liked, so I whipped out my phone and started showing her pictures of rings my fiancé liked when she and I went looking for rings. What happened next truly surprised me. I figured Denise would see the examples and realize that they didn’t have what I was looking for. Instead she asked me what it was about each ring I showed her that my fiancé liked. After I told her what my fiancé liked about each of the rings I had pictures for, Denise suggested that they build a custom ring with each element from the different rings that my fiancé liked.

This was great news, but there was one problem. I was planning on proposing in less than a month at Yankee Stadium. It was at this point that Marc Feder called me from his personal cell phone. He told me they would build my custom ring, have it ready in time, and he came in under my budget! I could not recommend Jay Feder Jewelers higher!!

Jay Feder is the jeweler my dad went to 35 years ago when he picked out my mom's engagement ring and is who my husband ultimately went with as well. They are so nice and provide excellent service for a great value. My husband said he was incredibly nervous trying to pick out the perfect ring, I gave him very little direction. He said Avi was incredible to work with and spent a lot of time with him making sure he felt confident and happy with his choice. My husband did a great job and I am very happy with the ring he chose. My husband and I came back to pick out our wedding bands and had the same great experience as he did the first time as we tried on almost every ring they had. They were able to size them and get them to us in a very timely manner and we are so happy with our rings!