My wife and I got married in Ithaca in July 2022, and Emoticakes came recommend to us by our wedding venue. We don’t live locally, and when we were passing through we reached out to her on very short notice to see if we could meet with her to talk about her wedding cake services. She was extremely quick to respond, and welcomed us to her home, AND baked us a cake all within 24 hours. It was delicious, and we were so lucky that she agreed to bake not just our wedding cake, but also assorted cupcakes and cookies to serve at our wedding. She was able to go the extra mile and make vegan cupcakes for several of our guests, and was incredible thoughtful and easy to work with. Again, the cakes were amazing, the best we’ve ever had, and so many of our guests kept asking where we got them from. We are so grateful that Amy worked with us to help create an amazing wedding day. If you are looking for a cake for a wedding or special event, we can’t recommend Amy enough!

We are so happy that we chose Amy to bake for our wedding! She was so professional and very helpful and easy to work with throughout the whole process. We are not local but ended up taking a last minute trip to Ithaca in the months leading up to our wedding and Amy arranged a tasting for us with only two days' notice which was so helpful for trying the different flavors.

She executed our colorful and quirky vision perfectly with minimal input from us. The cupcakes and cutting cake she created looked absolutely beautiful and made a huge impact at our venue! They ended up being a highlight of our decor and our guests were taking pictures of them all night. Plus, everyone kept raving about how delicious and amazing everything tasted! One of the uncles apparently snuck a bite of our cutting cake, declared that it was the best cake he’d ever had, and promptly put a quarter of it in a box to take home with him. We’ve already been saying that the next time we’re in Ithaca we’ll have to order a new cake from Amy to relive the memories. She also provided us with some boxes to take spare cupcakes home to loved ones who couldn’t attend at the last minute which we really appreciated. Her prices for baking, set up/delivery and stand rental were great and overall we had an awesome experience. We highly recommend Emoticakes!

Photos by Kelsey Travis Photography.

We found Amy through positive reviews online and are so glad we ultimately decided to have her bake our wedding cake. Amy was incredibly communicative and even helped coordinate a tasting during the peak of the pandemic. She was not only the best priced in the area but oh my goodness, her cakes were DELICIOUS! On the day of the wedding she blew our expectations out of the water - she made an incredible Italian rum cake with cannoli filling and a lemon cream cake that was just spectacular. I'm not much of a cake person but WOW her cakes have made me a believer. We've been eating leftover cake all week and I don't want it to end. Please hire Amy to bake your wedding cake, your guests will be thanking you later!!