About Cake Fiction

Creating Edible Dreams

Wedding cake, groom's cakes, engagement cakes, cupcake displays and favors by internationally trained pastry chef Paula Tosonotti. Call to book a tasting at our fabulous boutique cakery in a converted historic New Jersey barn.

Categories: Wedding Cake

Regions serviced: Northern New Jersey

Follow Cake Fiction on

48 Reviews for Cake Fiction

out of 5.0
User Photos
todo alt text
Filter reviews by services used:
All Reviews
Consultations (6)
Delivery (6)
Private Tastings (6)
Custom Design (5)
Cakes (4)
Cupcakes (4)
Setup (4)
Cake Stands (2)
Fresh Fruit (2)
Local (2)
Vegan (1)
Organic (1)
Sort by:


Paula and her team were wonderful to work with. I had had her cupcakes a few years ago as a guest at a wedding and I knew I wanted them whenever I got married- they did not disappoint! We went for a tasting at Paula's barn and picked out four flavors to serve guests at the wedding. When I called Paula some time later with a request for a change, Paula was totally flexible and understanding. I also reduced the number of cupcakes based on our RSVPs and she was again understanding and flexible. The cupcakes arrived on time and looked BEAUTIFUL. I thought we would have lots of leftovers but sure enough we only had a few left at the end of the night. They tasted even better than they looked, and am savoring each remaining one. I cannot recommend Cake Fiction enough!

View Vendor Response
Profile Picture Taylor, 6/9/18, 7 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake
Services Used: Cupcakes, Consultations, Delivery, Private Tastings

I really cared about having a delicious cake made from fresh ingredients, which is exactly what Paula provides. We also had a very different theme and Paula really caught onto our vision of a pierogi-shaped cake and pierogi-shaped cupcakes. She made little pierogi toppings and went so far as to give them a filling. Everyone was talking about how good the cake and cupcakes were. Best decision.

Profile Picture Alicia, 5/19/18, 4 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake
Services Used: Vegan, Consultations, Custom Design, Delivery, Private Tastings, Cakes, Cupcakes, Fresh Fruit, Local

Cake Fiction Pricing

Wedding Cakes Pricing
Buttercream Frosting (Per Slice, Without Tax)
Starting from $6.00
Fondant Starting Price (Per Slice, Without Tax)
Starting from $7.50
Cupcakes (Each, Without Tax)
Starting from $3.50
Prices Include:
Custom Cake Design
Set Up
Tasting - Private

Cake Fiction FAQ

Groom's Cake
Cake Pops
Dessert Buffet
Custom Design
Private Tastings
Cake Stands
Cake Cutters
Cake Toppers
Gluten Free
Nut Free
Lactose Free
Fresh Fruit
Health License


32 Photos

My Photo Album

32 Photos
220x220 sq 1283124509406 birchtreebarkcakephoto
220x220 sq 1509937313188 gold wedding cake with ivory lace and sunflower
220x220 sq 1283124658469 ivoryweddingcakewithdahlias
220x220 sq 1509937514975 naked cake with fresh gerbera daisies
220x220 sq 1509938135696 birch bark cake with carved monogram and sugar suc
220x220 sq 1509937614387 blue marble wedding cake with edible gold leaf
220x220 sq 1509937737293 naked topsy turvy cake with calla lilies
220x220 sq 1509937880660 naked cake with fresh peonies and garden roses
220x220 sq 1509937966982 buttercream wedding cake with fresh stephanotis an
220x220 sq 1310180256734 damaskcakewithchandeliersandredroses
220x220 sq 1310180218498 cymbidiumorchidspurpleweddingcake
220x220 sq 1310180524555 magentaorchidsweddingcakewithsnowflakes
220x220 sq 1310180689354 whiteweddingcakewithpeonybouquets
220x220 sq 1283124561359 violetandbluehydrangeasweddingcake
220x220 sq 1283124606453 purewhitebowcake
220x220 sq 1283124704250 peacockfeathersandrosesweddingcake
220x220 sq 1283124771781 newyankeestadiumretirementcake
220x220 sq 1283124807953 lamborghinimurcielagogroomscake
220x220 sq 1283124847156 indianweddingcakewithgarnetreddetails
220x220 sq 1283124925625 img1883blueweddingcakewithhydrangeabouquet
220x220 sq 1283124986250 poppiesandliliesweddinganniversarycake
220x220 sq 1310180292707 fallweddingcakewithchrysanthemumsanddahlias
220x220 sq 1310180368523 fashionshopaholiccake
220x220 sq 1310180474541 guccihandbagandboxbridalshowercake
220x220 sq 1310180603429 seashellsandcattleyaorchidsweddingcake
220x220 sq 1310180630261 steinwaygrandpianogroomscake
220x220 sq 1310180723689 yellowrosebowlweddingcake
220x220 sq 1310181390419 gaudiinspiredmosaicweddingcake
220x220 sq 1310181455939 louboutinshoecake
220x220 sq 1310181514361 quiltedivoryweddingcakewithcallalillies
220x220 sq 1310181551520 whiteranunculusflowersweddingcake
220x220 sq 1356060764836 drumsetweddingcake

Professional Network & Endorsements

What can I say about Cake Fiction? That they are fabulous, impeccable attention to detail and quite yummy. I get so excited when I get a chance to photography their works of art. I love Cake Fiction


The Barn at 11 East Mill Road, Long Valley, NJ 07853   See On Map
862-205-9035 (phone)
By Appointment (9am-2pm and 5-7pm)
Cake Fiction is a wedding cake designer from Northern New Jersey. We service weddings throughout the local area, including New York, New Jersey , and Connecticut. Cake Fiction is a professional wedding cake designer that has been part of the New Jersey wedding industry for 6 years. We specialize in specialty wedding cakes.